I do feel, some, for Electronic Arts and the people responsible for making Madden every year. This is only my 4th year (out of 27 releases) covering it and I fear I may have peaked with last year’s review. But like a fringe player with one too many concussions and a fear of the future, I’ll trot out another year to earn my keep.
[Note: I didn’t receive a PS3 copy of Madden this year. Last year I noted that the PS3 (and 360, presumably) version was insultingly sluggish, ugly, and missing key added features.]
Madden NFL 16 (PlayStation 4 [reviewed], Xbox One, PlayStation 3, Xbox 360)
Developer: EA Tiburon
Publisher: EA Sports
Released: August 25, 2015
Madden 16 makes an interesting opening gambit, once again going right into a game, this time a fabricated Super Bowl 50 starring the Cardinals and Steelers. No one wanted to watch that match up seven years ago (except me because of the Kurt Warner), but EA insists on framing this nostalgia-less, fake match up with Any Given Sunday editing, close ups on players, and even tepid, badly-acted football dialogue, the kind of jawing written by someone who has not played sport.
Fuck, is it boring. It introduces new (very simple) catching mechanics in painful slow motion setting up situations (oh, one of the teams is trailing!) we’re supposed to have emotions in, like I have any stake in Fake Super Bowl 50, like I’m supposed to feel something when alleged rapist Ben Roethlisberger (who narrates later tutorials) tells his mates, “It’s time to be the team we’re supposed to be right now. Believe in the man to your left and to your right. It’s our time right now” like he’s reading commercial cue cards. At least the San Jose 49ers’ digital Levi’s Stadium field hasn’t turned to pudding like the real one.
This is what Madden is, though. In past years I have creatively ripped on the series for aggressive advertisements of real-world products, which this one seems to have toned down significantly (unless they’re coming dynamically as updates post launch). But! Madden is a yearly advertisement for the NFL. From the start menu it encouraged me to share my information with the NFL, promising digital playing cards as a reward. This is what it means to have exclusivity rights to the only meaningful football league (because no one internationally gives a shit), the commodification of players.
It is cool to see the increased likeness of Arizona’s head coach whose fascinating neck folds and face-scanned pores have him looking like a corrugated version of Dana Carvey’s turtliest member of the turtle club.
In 2006 (that would make it Madden 07) I distinctly remember when I fell into the habit of abusing slot receivers instead of number one and number two wide receivers. This meant a lot of balls to the perfectly serviceable Kevin Curtis instead of two of the greats, Isaac Bruce and Torry Holt. The worst thing about those slot receiver posts, or crossing routes over the middle, has always been linebackers undercutting the passes for picks.
Here is the scenario: a player looks reasonably open for a pass. It is a pass any NFL quarterback could make. It is a pass I, an idiot with bad knees, could make. You throw it with a nice arc over the front defensive layer and before the safeties. Madden has never wanted to give you that pass and it has taken near 10 years for the series to introduce “touch passing,” a double tap that lets you drop balls into open zones. Ten years. Low and high throws are executed by holding L1 (high) or L2 (low) while passing.
The passing game has seen the most new features added this year. Aside from the aforementioned quarterback stuff, there are three types of catches, done by holding one of three buttons while the ball is in the air en route to the receiver. The Aggressive catch (triangle) is for leaping catches and bodying cornerbacks. RAC (square) encourages the player to make a catch in motion and continue running up field, provided they’re not about to be clocked. Possession catches (x) are for keeping feet in-bounds or making sure the receiver hangs on to a first down.
These useful buttons encourage more user interaction during catches and also speak to a refined interplay between defensive backs and receivers. On the other side of the ball, you can have defenders play the ball (hold triangle) to go for an interception or deflection, or more conservatively play the receiver (hold x) to ensure you make a tackle and possibly knock the ball from them.
There is much more realistic jockeying for body position and faithful physics so long as you don’t stare too closely at the instant replays. Eventually you’ll notice some similar, more dramatic catch animations (a particular one-handed one stuck out), but it is a plus on the whole for verisimilitude, for giving weight and feeling to awesome athletes interacting in a confined space.
That’s about it, though. There are some neat presentation additions (statistic graphics overlaid on players) and the menus are well laid out, though they are also pretty slow. Load times, too, are still a bit of a problem (and intrusive presentation elements are bothersome when running a hurry up offense). The insistence towards microtransaction-laden Ultimate Team and the new fantasy football-cribbed Draft Champions modes is useless. Throwing, catching, and defending throws have seen some welcomed, long-ignored additions that get a couple yards closer to faithful simulation. You can decide if that’s enough.
[This review is based on a retail build of the game provided by the publisher.]