Thanks to Dory’s whale-speaking expertise, you’ve managed to get the giant Narwhal out of the way, exposing a new whirlpool you can explore in Disney Dreamlight Valley. This means it’s time to find another keepsake, which is done through the Sunken Echo: The Cookie Cutters quest.
More puzzles await you in this trial, which means it’s yet another mission you may end up stuck on. To help you through it, here’s a complete walkthrough for the Sunken Echo: The Cookie Cutters quest in Disney Dreamlight Valley.
Table of contents
How to complete Sunken Echo: The Cookie Cutters in Disney Dreamlight Valley

Make sure you go and check out our sister site, GTA 6 Bible for all your GTA 6 needs.
To finish the Sunken Echo: The Cookie Cutters quest, you have to tackle two mysterious underwater puzzles to claim the keepsake. The premise of this task is similar to past missions like Sunken Echo: The Binoculars, Sunken Echo: The Fancy Hat, and Sunken Echo: Rain Boots, but the puzzles you face are completely unique.
Interact with the Cookie Cutter keepsake
Start by swimming over to the Cookie Cutter keepsake floating underwater. Interact with this object to trigger the first mysterious puzzle scene you need to investigate and work on.
Solve the first mysterious puzzle
Take a look at the note in front of the first mysterious puzzle to learn about it. This one tasks you with combining ingredients and baking some chocolate chip cookies.
- Open the tall dresser on the left side of the room to grab Sugar, Salt, Chocolate, and Flour.
- Interact with the fridge in the back left corner of the room to grab Butter, Jam, Ginger, and Eggs.
- Interact with the whisk in a bowl on the counter in the middle of the room to mix together the Sugar, Salt, Flour, Butter, and Eggs.
- Interact with the counter again to use the Jam, Ginger, and Chocolate.
- Pick up the mixed batter on the counter and place it in the oven to your right.
- Grab a cookie to finish the puzzle.

Solve the second mysterious puzzle
Read the note next to the second puzzle to see your next objective. This puzzle tasks you with helping the child figures deliver the right boxes of cookies to the neighbors.
- Pick up the green box of jam-filled cookies from the wagon and deliver it to the door in the middle of the scene.
- Pick up the pink box of gingerbread Mickey cookies from the wagon and deliver it to the door on the right side with a pink carpet in front of it.
- Pick up the red box of chocolate chip cookies from the wagon and deliver it to the door on the left side of the scene.
I found that the second box of cookies was really difficult to get the pick-up prompt for in this puzzle, so if you encounter this issue, keep moving around and trying different angles while spamming the interact button to help make it happen.

Pick up the keepsake
With both puzzles complete, swim over and grab the keepsake you earned, thus completing the Sunken Echo: The Cookie Cutters quest. Now that this task is done, you can get back to the I Can Speak Whale! quest.