Survival horror has always been one of my favorite genres, with Silent Hill being the absolute king. When I heard about a game inspired by and with voice actors from Silent Hill 2, arguably the best in the series, I was excited. Sure Forgotten Memories: Alternate Realities is from an unknown studio, but it isn’t like Konami is going to bother doing anything with the Silent Hill series.
I’m happy to say that Forgotten Memories really recreates that same sense of dread and terror that Silent Hill had — only with horrible touch controls!
Forgotten Memories: Alternate Realities (Android, iOS [reviewed on an iPhone 6 Plus], Playstation Vita, Wii U)
Developer: Psychose Interactive Inc.
Publisher: Psychose Interactive Inc.
Released: April 23, 2015 (iOS) / TBA 2015 (Android, PlayStation Vita, Wii U)
Rose Hawkins wakes up after being shot in the face, only remembering that she was searching for a missing girl named Eden. She doesn’t recall who shot her, how she is alive, or where she is. Upon exiting the room Rose is greeted by a hallway formed in red curtains, the kind you’d find at any theater. An antique dictation device is waiting for her, and a message plays automatically from a woman named Noah who has been waiting for her.
Noah knows Rose by name, and promises her more information on Eden if she can free her nurse friend from the asylum she is about to enter. Rose comes face to face with Noah in a throne surrounded by mannequins one last time before entering the asylum, Noah still talks through audio dictation for some reason. This is the kind of tone you can expect from Forgotten Memories.
Like any psychological survival horror game, the story is deep, twisted and leaves a lot of questions unanswered. Most of the lore you’ll come across in case files, notes, and a couple of cutscenes. Forgotten Memories is very old school in this regard, but still manages to have an engaging story worth searching for.
Old school is a word that can be used to describe most parts of the experience, for better or for worse. I almost didn’t finish the game due to how difficult the game is, just because the developers felt the need to shove in old school mechanics for old school sake. Saving the game requires tracking down a computer and using a floppy disk, an item that is extremely limited in the game. While classic survival horror games used this save game mechanic, most notably the original Resident Evil series, it sucks for a game on mobile, especially when the game is brutally difficult.
Forgotten Memories‘ app store description originally warned prospective buyers to only purchase the game if you are a hardcore gamer due to the level of challenge involved. They weren’t joking — I almost didn’t finish it to how quickly and often I’d die. Luckily I must not have been the only one as the developer quickly released an update that included an easy mode. It provides players with unlimited saves, more ammo, easier enemies and more medkit pickups, among other tweaks. Even with this easy mode I found myself in situations with a sliver of health, no medkits and some distance between myself and the nearest save point.
Touchscreen controls were a mistake, plain and simple, and hopefully they don’t carry over to the Vita and Wii U versions of the game. The left side of the screen controls character movement, while the right side controls the camera and aiming. The first place touched on the left side of the screen acts as a center axis, and Rose will move in the direction of your fingers position in reference to said axis. Camera and aiming control seems inconsistent on how much movement there is, often times leading to needing multiple swipes just turn around.
On the right side of the screen are also icons that allow you to run or go into an aiming mode with your flashlight or weapon. With a weapon drawn tapping anywhere on the screen will cause Rose to attack. The pipe, the only melee weapon I found in my playthroughs, can be used three times consecutively to perform a powerful combo attack that pushes enemies backwards. Since this piece of junk is your main weapon, combat boils down to letting enemies get close enough to attack, performing the combo, rinse repeat. It leaves a lot to be desired.
Shitty controls aside, Forgotten Memories nails the survival horror atmosphere unlike any game I’ve played in years. Haunting violins can be heard as you search for clues and keys, pounding drums mixed with noise play during combat, and the intro music is haunting, a mainstay of the Silent Hill series. I found my heart beating in my chest with my breath held as I ran past enemies to escape rooms. Hearing distorted singing coming from a shadow-like child that is just down the hallway where you need to go is fucking horrifying.
While it is indeed a horrifying affair, it ends all too abruptly at just under an hour and a half on my first playthrough. Having been in development for years, Forgotten Memories feels like it was purposely cut short to allow for sequels or download content. That being said, the pacing is tight and there is no filler whatsoever, but it still feels like the first chapter of a longer game.
Aside from the brevity, awful controls, and dull combat, the game is easily recommendable for those looking for that Silent Hill feel. Though only the desperate should pick up the mobile version, or those that have a compatible controller, otherwise wait for the console and PC releases sometime this year. While the graphics are some of the best I’ve seen on mobile, they can only be better elsewhere. Forgotten Memories: Alternate Realities is about the best you can do for survival horror currently, if you can stomach the control scheme.
[This review is based on a retail build of the game provided by the publisher.]