With meat being a hard commodity in Probably Stolen, very few specializations can give you a net positive like aquaculture.
But as you will quickly find out after having the tank installed, getting the right tools is not even half the problem. Here’s how aquaculture works in Probably Stolen and how to make plenty of credits fast with it.
Table of contents
Probably Stolen aquaculture guide
Unlockable by purchasing its upgrade pack on Wild’s Favors or picking the Aquafarmer specialization before starting a run, aquaculture revolves around raising and then scrapping fish for both meat and other related items. To start, you need a few things: a fully powered-up Recirculating Aquaculture System, water, Fertilized Roe (or a few non-breedable fish), fish food of any type, and a handy knife (or Meat Cleaver).

You can access all starting items and fish from day one, with non-breedable fish (like eels and the sturgeon) requiring a second permit from Wild’s Favors. Some fish can also only grow in clear water and demand larger tanks, which makes getting both a purifier and a water source a must. You can check out a few other must-have upgrades, all acquirable via the Retired Aquafarmer or through Dr. Jackson’s shop:
- Livestock Feed Dispenser (300 Credits): Allows you to convert large quantities of fish food or meat and distribute it among your fish in the tank.
- Water Filter (25 Credits): Adding Water Filters to your tank allows it to stay clear of impurities. Remember, pollution will eat away at your fish’s health, and even Pure Water is not immune to it.
- Auto Butcher (400 Credits): Although I find the process of separating the meat from the fish quite peaceful in Probably Stolen, getting an automated butcher can further streamline it. Just don’t forget to mark up the fish you wish to keep after installing it.
Read what’s behind the latest news in gaming (with a bit of snark) by subscribing to the Destructoid Checkpoint newsletter!
All fish types in Probably Stolen, explained

You can farm five different types of fish in Probably Stolen, with their value and requirements varying by rarity. That also means that high-end fish, like the sturgeon, can only thrive in clean water, while others, like the eels, will require focused ecosystems. You can check out an overview of how to farm all fish below:
Tilapia, Graft Tilapia, and Gutter Tilapia
Tilapia, Graft Tilapia, and Gutter Tilapia are acquirable by acquiring fertilized roe and then placing it in a system. The variants are also the only types of fish in the game that can be bred. Here’s an overview of each type’s unique features:
- Tilapia: The regular tilapia. Provides a lot of meat.
- Graft Tilapia: Although providing less meat, grown graft tilapia can also net you bandages.
- Gutter Tilapia: Able to grow in even low-quality water, gutter tilapia can also help you keep the tank clean. It produces less meat and grows slower than the above.
Even if omnivorous, make sure to balance their diet, as any Tilapia that consumes over 25 percent Gutterflow Pellets will have its meat turn inedible. Because of that, we also don’t recommend adding the latter to your dispensers and only using it as a last-ditch effort.
Eel and Electric Eel
Acquirable after getting the Aquaculture II Favor, both the Eel and Electric Eel are premium carnivore fish, whose meat can be sold for higher amounts once fully matured. That also means that the usual Fish Feed won’t do the job here. Instead, you need to give them meat.
Electric Eels can also power up their Aquaculture Systems and all surrounding machines after reaching adolescence, making it an ideal pick when looking to hook up multiple farms.
Sturgeon
The most expensive fish in Probably Stolen, the Sturgeon gets the title for a reason. After all, they can also provide you with caviar after reaching adulthood. You will need to use a Surgery Kit to extract it, however.
How to breed fish in Probably Stolen
Only possible with the tilapia variants, you can breed fish in Probably Stolen by keeping at least one adult female Tilapia, Graft Tilapia, or Gutter Tilapia in an Aquaculture System. They will then have a small chance of laying eggs during the night. Now, simply move the roe into a tank with a matching fish, who will fertilize it within the next 24 hours.

Now that you know the basics of aquafarming in Probably Stolen, make sure to also check out how to trigger and complete Lou’s quest.