World of Warcraft: Forever made gear a lot easier to look at compared to its Classic and OG counterparts. Stats are more laid out in what they do, related ones were merged, and Spell Power being re-split into more concrete spell damage and spell healing modifiers made gear collection more exciting to look at.
So this means seeing the green comparison line makes any new piece of gear an upgrade, right? As it turns out, not necessarily. If you really want to min-max your way into a decent gearscore, you need to understand the nuances of just what extent of a green line does gear count as an upgrade and when you should probably consider the other gear you’re ignoring.
Table of contents
Let’s get stats out of the way

Forever streamlined the way it presented stats so it’s easier for you to see your overall base stats, any secondary stats that can affect your performance at large, as well as offensive and defensive abilities that cover how your character fares in combat specifically. Gear can affect any of these stats, and Classes favor certain stats for their builds:
- Primary stats: Strength, Agility, Stamina, Intellect and Spirit are your core stats and mostly affect a variety of Secondary Stats and other “base” numbers
- Secondary stats: Critical Strike, Hit Chance, and Haste that determine your performance in combat
- Defensive stats: Armor, Defense, Block, Block Value, Dodge, Parry, and Resistances that determine how tough your character is in combat
- Modifiers: Attack Power, Spell Damage, Spell Healing, and Spell Penetration modify the “degree” of change your combat elements have
*Do take note that Forever hasn’t published the hard calculations per stat, so we’re taking these values from the closest reference, which is Classic:
| Primary stat | Offensive effect | Defensive effect | Special stat |
|---|---|---|---|
| Strength | *Attack Power | Block, *Block Value | – |
| Agility | Attack Power, Critical Strike | Armor, Dodge | – |
| Stamina | – | – | *Health |
| Intellect | Spell Critical Strike | – | *Mana |
| Spirit | – | – | Health and Mana regen |
For Primary stats, the main thing to focus on here is that a stat isn’t worth the same for everyone else, except perhaps Stamina, which determines overall health and Spirit, which is in charge of resource regen. Otherwise, the other stats influence effects in a different way depending on specific Classes or the nature of some Classes, so take note of these while you level up. For example:
- Strength helps heavy-hitters like the Warrior and the Paladin
- Agility is useful for everyone to get Armor, but each Class treats Attack Power and Critical strike chance (physical/magic) differently
- Intellect is more useful for spellcasters since they use Mana
| Secondary stat | What it does | Comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Critical Strike Chance | *A crit deals +100% bonus damage (melee and ranged) or +50% bonus spell damage | Agility, Intellect (Spell Crit only), gear percentages |
| Hit Chance | Lowers your chance to miss with any attack or spell | Gear and Talents, Dwarves also get +1% |
| Haste | Faster attacks and casts | Gear and some Racials (Troll Berserking, Skyborne Wind Blessed) |
| Class | Critical Strike Chance | Hit Chance | Haste |
|---|---|---|---|
| Warrior | +1% Crit (20 Agility) | Gear, plus Furious Precision 4/7/10% off-hand hit (Fury) | – |
| Paladin | +1% Crit (20 Agility) +1% Spell crit (54 Intellect) | Gear, plus Divine Precision 4/8% hit with Holy spells | – |
| Hunter | +1% Crit (53 Agility) | Gear | – |
| Rogue | +1% Crit (29 Agility) | Gear | – |
| Priest | +1% Spell crit (54-60 Intellect) | Gear | – |
| Shaman | +1% Crit (20 Agility) +1% Spell crit (54-60 Intellect) | Gear, plus Precision 2/4/6% hit with all spells | – |
| Mage | +1% Spell crit (54-60 Intellect) | Gear | – |
| Warlock | +1% Spell crit (60 Intellect) | Gear | – |
| Druid | +1% Crit (20 Agility) +1% Spell crit (54-60 Intellect) | Gear | – |
Compared to primary stats, these secondary stats influence how often hits and crits happen. Crits are a big deal when you’re fighting one mob after the next or tough bosses, as scoring one nets double damage (physical, ranged) or plus half as much (spell) damage. And the more attacks you make, and the more of them hit, the more damage you can send the enemy’s way. All Classes benefit from these chances in some capacity.
| Defensive stat | What it does | Comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Armor | Reduces physical damage | +2 (1 Agility), gear |
| Defense | Raises Dodge, Block and Parry; lowers your chance to be hit and crit | Gear |
| Block | Chance to block a hit with a shield | Defense, gear percentages |
| Block Value | How much damage a block stops | +1 (20 Strength), gear |
| Dodge | Fully avoid a frontal attack | Agility, gear percentages, Defense |
| Parry* | Fully avoid a frontal attack; 1 Parry gives +40% speed on the next attack | Defense, gear percentages |
| Resistances | Reduce one school of magic damage (Arcane, Fire, Frost, Nature, Shadow) | Gear |
| Class | Armor | Block | Block value | Dodge |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Warrior | +2 (1 Agility), gear | Yes, with a shield | +1 (20 Strength), gear | +1% (20 Agility) |
| Paladin | +2 (1 Agility), gear | Yes, with a shield | +1 (20 Strength), gear | +1% (20 Agility) |
| Hunter | +2 (1 Agility), gear | Can’t block | – | +1% (26 Agility) |
| Rogue | +2 (1 Agility), gear | Can’t block | – | +1% (14.5 Agility) |
| Priest | +2 (1 Agility), gear | Can’t block | – | +1% (20 Agility) |
| Shaman | +2 (1 Agility), gear | Yes, with a shield | +1 (20 Strength), gear | +1% (20 Agility) |
| Mage | +2 (1 Agility), gear | Can’t block | – | +1% (20 Agility) |
| Warlock | +2 (1 Agility), gear | Can’t block | – | +1% (20 Agility) |
| Druid | +2 (1 Agility), gear | Can’t block | – | +1% (20 Agility) |
Defensive stats are mostly a tank’s concern, but everyone gets a little something from Armor, even though it only technically blocks physical damage. Other considerations include:
- Armor caps at 75% physical damage reduced, achieved with Agility and gear
- Resistances cap at 75% magical damage reduced, achieved with gear
- Defense at 440 makes you uncrittable by raid bosses, achieved with gear
- Block only works for Classes who can use shields, so Warriors, Paladins, and Shamans
| Modifier | What it does | Comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Attack Power | *Adds melee and ranged damage, 14 AP adds 1 DPS | Strength, Agility, gear (plain AP on gear helps both melee and ranged) |
| Spell Damage, Spell Healing | *Adds to each spell by that spell’s coefficient (Frostbolt and Fireball about 80 to 100%, Arcane Explosion about 15%) | Gear only, and healing gear adds about 1/3 as much Spell Damage as its healing |
| Spell Penetration | Ignores the target’s Resistances, and below zero gives a chance for 10/20/30% more spell damage | Gear, no Primary stat gives it |
| Class | Attack Power* | Spell Damage, Spell Healing* | Spell Penetration |
|---|---|---|---|
| Warrior | +2 (1 Strength) +1 ranged (1 Agility) | Gear | Gear |
| Paladin | +2 (1 Strength) | Gear, plus Champion of the Light (up to 60% of Intellect) | Gear |
| Hunter | +1 (1 Strength) +1 melee, +2 ranged (1 Agility) | Gear | Gear |
| Rogue | +1 (1 Strength) +1 melee, +1 ranged (1 Agility) | Gear | Gear |
| Priest | +1 (1 Strength) | Gear | Gear |
| Shaman | +2 (1 Strength) Mental Dexterity adds up to 150% of Intellect | Gear | Gear |
| Mage | +1 (1 Strength) | Gear, plus Arcane Blast stacks (12% of Intellect each) | Gear |
| Warlock | +1 (1 Strength) | Gear | Gear |
| Druid | +2 (1 Strength) +1 melee in Cat Form (1 Agility) | Gear | Gear |
Unlike your secondary stats, these Modifiers add a set amount to what you already do. So more Attack Power and Spell Damage/Healing will result in a direct increase in how “big” your hits will actually land. However, do take note that not all your Spell Damage will be added to big spells, as some of them will only take a percentage of it. With Forever’s new itemization changes, Spell Healing also imparts +1/3 Spell Damage to the user.
Use Weapon DPS when choosing between 2 Weapons

Now that we got the stats out of the way, how exactly should we start evaluating gear? If we’re talking about weapons, then Weapon DPS is almost always the stat to look at. You don’t necessarily need to pay attention to Attack Speed, since at the end of the day the damage you deal per second is the one resource you won’t lose unless you’re stunned or CC’d.
Consider these two weapons for a Feral Druid:
| Weapon | Damage | DPS shown | Stats | Damage over 10 seconds |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Defender of Dalaran | 82 to 124 | 31.21 | +9 Str, +13 Sta, +9 Int | about 312 |
| Ironshod Bludgeon | 74 to 112 | 37.20 | +8 Str, +20 Sta | about 372 |
The Defender of Dalaran might have more base damage at 82 to 124, but it’s a much slower weapon compared to Ironshod Bludgeon. The high base damage becomes negligible if you don’t hit with it fast enough. So when you compare their damage over 10 seconds, the Ironshod wins by around 60 points. Not to mention it has more Stamina, which a Shaman would appreciate in terms of resource regeneration.
Over on Reddit, Shamans are asking a similar question. After completing Heart of Disruption (City of Dalaran), they can choose between Defender of Dalaran and the Striking Staff, especially as a replacement for Corpsemaker. Let’s take a look at the stats:
| Weapon | Damage, speed | DPS | Stats | DPS + stats (estimate) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Corpsemaker | 88-132, 3.80 | 28.95 | +15 Str, +8 Sta | about 31.1 |
| Striking Staff | 77-117, 3.10 | 31.29 | +9 Str, +6 Sta, +14 Int | about 32.6, plus Int |
| Defender of Dalaran | 82-124, 3.30 | 31.21 | +9 Str, +13 Sta, +9 Int | about 32.5, plus Int |
| Rage of the Storm | 102-154, 3.60 | 35.56 | +16 Str, +15 Sta, +10% Stormstrike damage | about 37.9 |
At first glance, both Heart of Disruption rewards have similar DPS numbers, with the Staff offering more Intellect while Defender offers more Stamina. Either seems to be a good choice. But one reply said to get neither and pursue Rage of the Storm instead. It has both high Attack Power and raw DPS, making it the best surprise candidate despite its rather long questline. Not to mention, it provides extra Stormstrike damage.
Casters and healers now share the same gear, so who gets healing gear?
Spell Power is now present across all casting gear, and healing gear partially gives extra damage as well. So if a damage caster doesn’t have access to their ideal gear yet, knowing they can get healing gear to compensate can be a big plus. But that does leave a sour taste in the mouth of healers, who already struggle to dish out damage for semi-decent leveling. So how do we reconcile this? Consider these:
| Item | Slot, level | Healing | Spell damage | Other stats | Best fit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ladimore Heirloom Ring | Ring, item level 35 | 5 | 5 | +6 Int | Any caster or healer |
| Staff of Westfall | Staff, item level 24 | 48 | 16 | +5 Int, +6 Spi | Healers, early casters |
| Whitemane’s Chapeau | Cloth head, req. 39 | 20 | 7 | +9 Sta, +10 Int, +12 Spi, faster resurrection | Priests and healers |
| Hide of the Wild | Cloak, req. 57 | 42 | 14 | +8 Sta, +10 Int | Healers |
| Robes of the Guardian Saint | Cloth chest, req. 60 | 70 | 23 | +20 Sta, +22 Int, 7 Mana per 5 sec | Healers |
The simple approach is to check the other stats. If there are big, glaring Spirit and Mana regen stats, they are ideally for healers to use. But if it’s almost equal parts Spirit and Intellect, then it’s somewhat fair game. Take note of specific abilities too, like if a piece of gear facilitates faster resurrections, then they ideally go to the Priest who’s mostly in charge of it.
Consider special effects like procs
Some gear in the game also offers special abilities like procs that add some pizzazz to the item. These are few and far between, but they make gear extra special because of them. When judging potential gear upgrades, see if any of these procs can contribute to a stat you’re looking at, such as Weapon DPS, or maybe it has some synergy with a talent or build. For example:
| Item | Damage, speed | DPS shown | Stats | Proc | DPS with proc (estimate) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Black Malice | 48-73, 3.30 | 18.33 | +2 Shadow Res | 55-85 Shadow damage bolt | about 21 |
Take the Black Malice. On paper, the Black Malice doesn’t do as much in the DPS department. But it does have a chance of releasing a Shadow damage bolt as well. Assuming it happens once every eight swings (so it’s not totally a standardized “out of ten”), then its DPS can become 21 instead of just 18.33.
| Item | Effect |
|---|---|
| Ankle Slicers | Chance on hit to slow movement by 30% for 6 sec |
| Skullflame Shield | 3% when struck in melee to steal 270 life, 2% when struck to deal 90-140 Fire damage around you |
| Hurricane | Every ranged auto attack adds 6-10 Frost damage |
Other procs are not necessarily “a chance” to do some damage, as seen above. For example, Hurricane adds damage to every hit as though it’s been buffed by a spell. Ankle Slicers have a chance to slow, while Skullflame Shield has a chance to lifesteal or deal Fire damage AOE. They might not have the best stats on paper, but if their procs fit a preferred playstyle, then use them.