As you progress through The Keepsake Sea, you’ll face a series of daunting trials involving all kinds of unique tasks to tackle in Disney Dreamlight Valley. One of the trickier ones you’ll encounter asks you to cook a meal fit for a Pirate Captain.
The Keepsake Sea has quite an array of unique dishes you can cook up, but only one counts for this specific task. It’s quite a difficult mission to solve on your own, so here’s how to cook a meal fit for a Pirate Captain in Disney Dreamlight Valley.
Table of contents
Meal fit for a Pirate Captain in Disney Dreamlight Valley

The meal fit for a Pirate Captain is Kraken’s Catch in DDV. This piece of the Trial of Resilience references back to the Captain of the Dead quest, in which you were tasked with feeding a mysterious Skeleton Captain that was eventually revealed to be Jack Sparrow himself.
It can be tricky to connect the information you learned in a past mission here since Jack Sparrow was referred to as a Skeleton Captain rather than a Pirate Captain before. There are also many recipes in The Keepsake Sea, so it’s tough to determine that this is the right one at first.
Read what’s behind the latest news in gaming (with a bit of snark) by subscribing to the Destructoid Checkpoint newsletter!
Cook a meal fit for a Pirate Captain in Disney Dreamlight Valley

To successfully complete the cook a meal fit for a Pirate Captain task that’s part of the Trial of Resilience, you need to make two Kraken’s Catch. This is a four-star meal that requires you to combine four ingredients, which are:
- Mini-Kraken – Can be caught from gold bubble spots anywhere around Shipwreck Shores.
- Dreamlight Avocado – Can be planted, watered, and grown using Dreamlight Avocado Seeds. You can grab these seeds from Goofy’s Stall in Barnacle Bay for 25 Star Coins.
- Any Dairy – Any item listed under the Dairy category counts for this dish, even if the listed item doesn’t seem like Dairy. Valid options include items like Butter, Olives, and Tree Resin.
- Any Fruit – All Fruits, including those found around The Keepsake Sea, the main valley region, and other DLC areas, can be used to make this dish. Valid options include items like Lychee, Apple, and Cherry.
To complete this mission for the Trial of Resilience, make sure you cook Kraken’s Catch twice. This quest will only be marked as complete once you’ve cooked up this recipe two times. Although Jack Sparrow previously requested a Dessert dish to go with Kraken’s Catch when he asked for a meal, no Desserts count here, so stick to only making Kraken’s Catch to complete this task.