Being the biggest game of the year, and possibly of all time, GTA 6 is under an extensive amount of scrutiny. Players are analyzing every nook and cranny, leaving no stone unturned, especially if what they find under said stones allows them to throw a fit on Twitter and tell the world how much this once-in-a-generation game sucks, actually.

Recommended Videos

From attacking Rockstar for focusing the story on Jason and Lucia to being angry at doing so-called “chores,” which are, in fact, completely optional, some people online simply want to find reasons to hate on GTA 6, caring little if their criticisms have a leg to stand on. And so, as soon as Metacritic opened the floodgates (the user reviews), things became messy. Really messy.

At the time of writing, GTA 6 has a 5.6 average user score on the site, compared to the flawless 99 average on the critics’ side. This is way up from when the reviews were initially enabled, as the game launched to around a 3.5 average score on this platform. The averages have slowly climbed since, reaching 5.6 today, based on 64,795 reviews total.

GTA 6 Jason Lucia guns in car
Image via Rockstar Games

Make sure you go and check out our sister site, GTA 6 Bible, for all your GTA 6 needs.


With so many reviews left, you’d think the score to be legitimate. After all, political polling institutes need about 1,000 people to create a “representative sample” predicting outcomes across multi-million populations, and I’m certain they’re just hoping to ever have a 64,000-person sample size. However, once you open the reviews, you will find that many, if not most, of the accounts leaving zeroes have only ever reviewed GTA 6, or one other game which they scored a 10 for having none of the “problems” of GTA.

Some are quoting Gabe Newell, who said realism isn’t fun, arguing that since GTA 6 is fairly realistic, it is by default not a fun game. What they do not quote is the rest of what Newell said, i.e., that fun is defined as how the game reacts to the player’s input, which, if they’d ever actually played the game, they would find around every corner in GTA 6. Reactivity is probably the strongest part of its world, I dare say, but of course you’d need to play it to see it.

Other zeroes stretch from complaints about 30 fps, bugs, or the fact the game “doesn’t feel like GTA.”

“I didn’t like it [it’s] simply [a] cuck sim, nothing like old GTA games, there are no prostitutes and no way to cheat on Lucia, which is literally not understandable,” one 0/10 review reads. Of course, on the inverse side, there are a ton of 10/10s with little to no input or explanation for their score, so it’s not a perfect situation whichever way you cut it.

User scores on Metacritic do not require game ownership verification, so anyone can make an account and leave a score without having to prove they even played it. This creates situations where some games have horrible user scores despite universal acclaim, making the system rather pointless as a result.

NEWSLETTER

SIGN UP FOR THE
DESTRUCTOID NEWSLETTER