The 5th nominee for Destructoid Game of the Year 2009

Recommended Videos

Every day this week, we here at Destructoid are revealing one of the five nominees for Game of the Year 2009, with the winner being announced next Monday (12/21). What game will take the crown this year?

Here we are with our final nominee for Destructoid Game of the Year 2009. (You can click here, here, here, and here for the previous four that were revealed all week!)

First off, we need to give props to Destructoid’s “video-in-chief”, Rey Gutierrez for producing the amazing videos that have accompanied each of these nominees this week. Regardless of how you feel about half-naked women dressed in revealing videogame costumes and dancing around to pop music, you have to admit Rey did an excellent job with the production values on these things. He is one talented guy. And, seriously, if I had a nickel for every time I walked down the street and was randomly surrounded by half-naked women dressed in revealing videogame costumes and dancing around to pop music … I would have exactly 30 cents.

Hit the jump to find out the 5th nominee for Destructoid Game of the Year 2009 (and for the list of runner-ups as well!), watch Rey’s video for your daily fix of pretty people, and make sure to check back this Monday (12/21) for the grand announcement of the winner! Who knows? Maybe I will be the one wearing a tight t-shirt, cut-off shorts, and dancing around to something by that Lady Gaga character.

Can’t read my p-p-p-poker face, indeed, Ms. Gaga.

I think the entire world of gamers collectively groaned when they heard a semi-realistic, Unreal Engine-fueled new Batman game was going to be coming out for multiple platforms in the summer of 2009. Sure, early images of Batman: Arkham Asylum looked incredible, but when was the last time a game based on Batman turned out even slightly good? The NES, maybe?

To the surprise of maybe everyone, Batman: Arkham Asylum not only turned out to be an incredibly good Batman game, it may be the greatest videogame based on any comic book character ever. Seriously. Batman: Arkham Asylum benefits from its wickedly slick presentation, but excels because of its exquisitely designed, surprisingly Metroid-esque structure and killer stealth action gameplay. Whew! That’s quite a description, but it only scratches the surface of how incredibly deep and satisfying Batman: Arkham Asylum really is.

As fellow editor Samit Sarkar perfectly put it in his initial preview, when you play Arkham Asylum, you constantly want to shout “I AM THE GODDAMN BATMAN!”

From our original review: “Arkham Asylum is the single most fun stealth game ever made. Period.”

(You can read the full review right here.)

What do you think of our final fifth nominee? Were you just as surprised by how good Batman: Arkham Asylum turned out to be? Now that all five nominees have been revealed, which game deserves to win? Which game do you think will win? And what are some of your favorite videogames of 2009?

Don’t forget to check back Monday (12/21) for the reveal of the winner of Destructoid Game of the Year 2009!

 

Nominee #1 – Left 4 Dead 2
Nominee #2 – Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
Nominee #3 – New Super Mario Bros. Wii
Nominee #4 – Borderlands
Nominee #5 – Batman: Arkham Asylum

… and, for the curious, here is a short list of the games that almost made the final cut. It was a really close race this year. 

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
Demon’s Souls
Half-Minute Hero
Henry Hatsworth in the Puzzling Adventure
Machinarium
Mario & Luigi: Bowser’s Inside Story
Plants vs. Zombies
Professor Layton and the Diabolical Box
Punch-Out!!
Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time
Red Faction: Guerrilla
Shadow Complex
Shatter
Street Fighter IV


Destructoid is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more
related content
Read Article Zenless Zone Zero is open for pre-registration, and over 30 million have already signed up
Zenless Zone Zero key art
Read Article Metaphor: ReFantazio locks in an October release date, showcases more gameplay in trailer
Metaphor ReFantazio date
Read Article The Meta OS is opening up to third-party headset makers
Meta Quest 3
Related Content
Read Article Zenless Zone Zero is open for pre-registration, and over 30 million have already signed up
Zenless Zone Zero key art
Read Article Metaphor: ReFantazio locks in an October release date, showcases more gameplay in trailer
Metaphor ReFantazio date
Read Article The Meta OS is opening up to third-party headset makers
Meta Quest 3