A hobbit with curly orange hair and a yellow skirt standing on a wooden bridge looking out at a forest scenery in tales of the shire
Screenshot by Destructoid

How to increase Fellowship in Tales of the Shire

Help Bywater thrive.

Bywater, the village you call home in Tales of the Shire, isn’t recognized as an official village when you first arrive there. To help it become one and progress through the main storyline, you need to work on increasing your Fellowship.

Recommended Videos

Leveling up your Fellowship is one of the most important gameplay aspects to work on, but you’re not given a whole lot of guidance on how to do so. If you find that this recurring mission has you stumped, here’s how to increase Fellowship in Tales of the Shire.

All ways to gain Fellowship in Tales of the Shire

A bunch of townsfolk gathered together in a group standing outside in tales of the shire
Screenshot by Destructoid

There are three ways you can increase your Fellowship in Tales of the Shire, including:

  • Leveling up relationships.
  • Leveling up clubs.
  • Completing tales.

Each of these methods for earning Fellowship is unique, and some are more rewarding than others. Here’s a full breakdown of everything you need to know about all three of them.

Leveling up relationships in Tales of the Shire

The first, and least rewarding, way of earning Fellowship is leveling up your relationships with each of the 15 townsfolk who live around the Shire. You can increase your friendship with these characters by cooking meals and inviting them to dine with you at any of the available spots where you can host a meal.

For the best chance of increasing your relationship, you’ll want to cook villagers’ favorite dishes. All characters have specific preferences and enjoy certain foods more than others. Even if you give them a random dish, though, you’ll still gain some friendship, so don’t worry too much about it if you don’t have the ingredients to make one of their desired dishes early on.

A group of characters sitting around a table eating in tales of the shire
Screenshot by Destructoid

Leveling up clubs in Tales of the Shire

The second way you can build your Fellowship is by leveling up clubs. This is a decent way to do so, and rewards more Fellowship than leveling up friendships, but it’s not the overall best method for it. You can level up clubs by completing missions associated with them, which are pinned on the board at The Ivy Bush Inn.

The cooking club requires you to cook up meals using certain ingredients, the fishing club has you hunting for varying amounts of specific fish, the foraging club has you gathering various resources, and the gardening club tasks you with harvesting certain types of seeds. You can work on up to 10 tasks across all clubs at once, and once you’re done with one, you need to visit the club leader to officially finish it and claim a prize.

Completing tales in Tales of the Shire

The third and most rewarding way to boost your Fellowship is by completing tales. Tales are quests given to you by the many villagers who call Bywater home. Some quests may ask you to find a specific item around the Shire, some may have you running around to talk to various villagers, and some may send you on a scavenger hunt. The exact requirements for each mission you come across vary, so how easy or hard a task is to tackle does, too.

Best way to level up Fellowship in Tales of the Shire

All three options for increasing fellowship in tales of the shire including relationships, club missions, and tales
Screenshot by Destructoid

Overall, the best way to increase your Fellowship is by completing tales, otherwise known as quests, in Tales of the Shire. This includes main story quests, side quests granted to you by villagers, and those you come across while exploring, which are marked with white sparkles.


Destructoid is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more about our Affiliate Policy
Author
Image of Kacee Fay
Kacee Fay
Staff Writer
Staff Writer at Prima Games & Destructoid covering a wide array of topics including Disney Dreamlight Valley, Fortnite, Marvel Rivals, Minecraft, Phasmophobia, general gaming, and more. She has been avidly writing and gaming her whole life and now spends her time combining the two. Kacee graduated from San Diego State University in 2021 with a Bachelor’s Degree in English and a Certificate in Creative Editing and Publishing. She joined Dot Esports as a Freelance Writer in 2022, transitioned to a Staff Writer in 2023, moved to Destructoid in March 2025, and joined Prima Games in September 2025. In her spare time, she enjoys buying more books than she can read, gaming alone or with friends, drinking too much tea, attending concerts, fangirling over movies and television, listening to music, and spending time with her family, friends, and pets, who are the most important parts of her world.