Sonic Mania is all the proof I needed that Joy-Con need a D-pad


Directional buttons just don't cut it

I've been playing a lot of Sonic Mania over the past few days. It's nice that I'm enjoying a Sonic game in 2017, and even more delightful that I get to enjoy it on the Nintendo Switch. 

Sonic Mania does all the right things. The controls are tight, the art is nostalgic but not pandering, and it reminds me of what I liked about Genesis-era Sonic games. The one rather depressing thing it does for me is point out what other people have been saying for some time: the Nintendo Switch Joy-Con need a proper directional pad.

Don't get me wrong, the directional buttons get the job done, but I can't help but feel my times would be a little bit better if I had a smoother directional transition that only a D-pad provides.

Of course, if you own a Pro Controller, you have a D-pad option, but I like many others spend the majority of my time playing the Switch in handheld mode. Some people have even taken it upon themselves to solve the issue. For example, the folks over at Engadget 3D printed a snap on D-pad.

This home modification from a Reddit user is exactly what we all need. 

I'm sure a complete redesign of the Joy-Con is out of the question. In fact, it presents a problem as the left Joy-Con player is then put at a disadvantage when you "share the joy," but it wouldn't hurt to release new Joy-Con with a D-pad option before all of those classic Nintendo games make their way over via the subscription service.

You are logged out. Login | Sign up



Rich Meister
Rich MeisterNews/Reviews Contributor   gamer profile

NY gamer who duped Destructoid into hiring him. JRPG nerd and Paul Rudd enthusiast. Full disclosure, I backed some Kickstarter things. Monster Crown and Knuckle Sandwich have my money so take my... more + disclosures



Also on Destructoid: Sonic Mania   (71)   From our database:

  • Sonic Mania Plus' retro styled commercial is '90s nostalgia overload - Peter Glagowski
  • There are no plans for a Sonic Mania sequel at this moment - Chris Carter
  • Sonic Mania hits over one million downloads worldwide - Dan Roemer
  • 'Select Soundtrack' for Sonic Mania pops up on iTunes, Amazon, and Google Play - Jordan Devore
  • Sonic Mania update fixes the Switch home button - Jordan Devore
  • Comical Sonic Mania mod adds Knuckles and Knuckles and Knuckles - Chris Moyse
  • Sonic Mania contains tribute to game modder who passed away - Chris Moyse
  • Fans angry at Sonic Mania's Steam DRM requirements - Chris Moyse
  • Sonic Mania is steeped in history and Easter eggs - Chris Carter
  • More related stories
    Filed under... #Controllers #Nintendo Switch #Sonic



    You're not expected to always agree, but do please keep cool and never make it personal. Report harassment, spam, and hate speech to our community team. Also, on the right side of a comment you can flag nasty comments anonymously (we ban users dishing bad karma). For everything else, contact us!