The Internet has spoken
The polls have closed for BioShock Infinite's reversible cover art, and as you can see above, the end result is the red Songbird cover. According to Irrational Games, this design received 38 percent of the votes, with the next most popular one garnering 26 percent.
I have to wonder how many of these people (myself included!) will even go to the effort of changing the cover, despite having voted. What an unusual turn of events this has been.
Poll Winner Announced! [Irrational Games]