Destructoid's 2017 Community Choice Award!


My original plan for this subheader was to write that everyone has Pokemon Gone to the polls but writing Pokemon without the accent feels wrong and this doesn't support utf-8

Crazy. There's no better word to describe 2017. It was a crazy year. Good crazy in some places, like video games, and bad crazy in others.

Over the past few weeks, the community has been hard at work voting for their favorite games released in this wild, wild year... Also, hard at work reminding me that Doki Doki Literature Club should have been an option. Sometimes, people chose to vote multiple times for the same game, which made tallying pretty tricky. You know who you are. But now, the results are finally in.

For those wondering how their voting power was used, here's a quick rundown. Basically, one point was given to a game for each fifth-place vote, two points for each fourth-place vote, four points for each third-place vote, and so on. Amusingly, the top 5 you'll find below would have been the same if I just ranked the games by their number of first place votes...

I guess that makes these rankings extra valid!

Horizon: Zero Dawn is gorgeous, it's huge and it has robot dinosaurs. I haven't played it yet, but I can get behind at least two of these things! The PS4 exclusive made quite a splash when it launched in February, and its popularity among the community here shows it wasn't just a flash in the pan.

Guerrilla Games' previous title, Killzone: Shadow Fall, didn't quite stick the landing when it launched alongside the PS4 in 2013. It's nice, seeing a return to form for the team!

Super Mario Odyssey needs no introduction. The first collectathon platformer in the series since Super Mario Sunshine on the GameCube, the game included elements of other masterpieces like Banjo-Kazooie and Crash: Mind over Mutant to great effect.

For me, the most interesting thing about Super Mario Odyssey will be its legacy in the long run. It's certainly found a home within speed-running communities, and I'm also curious to see which ideas will carry on in future entries.

In any case, Super Mario Odyssey is arguably the Switch's biggest game of the year. It was by far the most popular exclusive on the system. But beyond that, it was an expansive, creative game that was a joy to play, especially after reaching post-game content. It's no wonder that it ended up in the community's top 5.

We've finally moved away from Atlus' endless stream of Persona 3 and Persona 4 spin-offs. We haven't quite reached the deluge of Persona 5 spin-offs yet. No, 2017 is this very special year where a new entry is unleashed upon the world, a fresh start for everyone. Fresh-ish, since there were already tons of spoiler before release date around the internet. The game's original release in Japan was last year after all.

Persona 5 went above and beyond when revamping the daily simulator formula introduced by Persona 3. Everything, from hanging out with your friends to defeating demons in a parallel world, looks and flows better than ever before.

Personally, what I enjoyed most out of Persona 5's improvements is the return of proper level design in its dungeons, something that wasn't seen in the series since Persona 2: Eternal Punishment.

Also Kawakami.

NieR: Automata's popularity, especially on this website, keeps surprising me. In a good way, of course! Drakengard and the original NieR were far from mainstream successes, and even the game's announcement trailer during E3 2015 was suitably low-key and relaxing. 

It surpassed all estimations. With currently roughly 700k owners on Steam, and over 2 million copies in total as of September. Who could have expected a sequel to a game barely anybody played to become such a hit?

But something along the way did make NieR: Automata a success despite all odds. Maybe it was getting Platinum Games on board, giving the game a lot more mechanical polish. Maybe it was the reviews, which were much kinder to the game than other Yoko Taro experiments. Maybe it was that the internet couldn't shut the hell up about 2B's butt.

In any case, I'm glad it succeeded. And so is the Destructoid community, judging by the game's second position in the poll.

Look, I wasn't a fan of Breath of the Wild. But I'd be lying if I said any other game felt like the biggest release of the year. It sold like crazy. People talked about it like crazy. It even got a 10/10 on the biggest and greatest video game website of all, Destructoid. Wait, it got two.

Breath of the Wild wasn't just a game, it was a phenomenon. No matter if someone hates or loves the game, you've already read their reasoning a billion times by now. There's no point in even getting into it. Even though the game had a Wii U version, it was the reason why most of my friends wanted a Nintendo Switch.

Don't lie, you saw this coming.

Ehhh, these community awards could have used a few more surprises, I hear you say. They're basically identical to the staff picks. You're not wrong! But I have some nifty trivia to show to you, who made it this far.

  • PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds didn't get its chicken dinner

The game ended in 23rd place in the community vote, the worst position of all our PC GOTY nominees. Divinity: Original Sin II would have won the category instead, were the proletariat really in power. The RPG ended up in the seventh position overall.

  • Troll and I, or Knack II?

The latter ended up with significantly more votes. It was the 28th most popular game in the poll, while Troll and I had to go home with a measly 35th place. Now, the age-old question finally comes to a close.

It helps that Knack II can actually be enjoyed somewhat unironically.

  • What if we used the average position to rank the games instead?

That's not the best system for a community vote like this... It's much easier for games with few votes to end up at the top. But still, to satisfy your curiosity, the rankings would end up like this:

  1. Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild (2.16)
  2. Wonder Boy: The Dragon's Trap (2.33)
  3. NieR: Automata (2.45)
  4. Persona 5 (2.46)
  5. Horizon Zero Dawn (2.50)
  6. Super Mario Odyssey (2.63)

Wonder Boy got all the way up there! Look at it go. Incidentally, it was also the least voted game in the entire poll.

Well, that's it for this year's edition of the Community Choice Award! Let's hope 2018 is another great year for video games.

You are logged out. Login | Sign up



BassCommunity Manager   gamer profile

French Canadian gamer that has transcended human flesh. Current gen systems used: PS4, Switch, 3DS, Vita, PC. Now a real deal employed software engineer! Oh also I backed Indivisible and Hives... more + disclosures


Also on destructoid: The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild   (132)   From our database:

  • (Update) Switch suffers from a glitch that bugs Zelda: Breath of the Wild playtime records - Chris Carter
  • Check out this beautiful Zelda: Breath of the Wild soundtrack set - Chris Moyse
  • I love that people are making amazing Zelda: Breath of the Wild clips a full year after launch - Chris Carter
  • Destructoid's 2017 Community Choice Award! - Bass
  • Zelda: Breath of the Wild fans keep finding creative little ways to make me want to replay it - Chris Carter
  • We might not know what the future of Zelda holds, but producer Eiji Aonuma says it'll involve freedom - Chris Carter
  • Peter Glagowski's personal picks for GOTY 2017 - Peter Glagowski
  • Zelda producer 'kind of scared' to say where Breath of the Wild might fit on the timeline - Chris Carter
  • Those free Zelda: Breath of the Wild gifts keep coming, and this one is useful - Chris Carter
  • More related stories
    Filed under... #Nintendo #Nintendo Switch #The Legend of Zelda #Wii U



    You're not expected to always agree, but do please keep cool and never make it personal. Report harassment, spam, and hate speech to our community team. Also, on the right side of a comment you can flag nasty comments anonymously (we ban users dishing bad karma). For everything else, contact us!