manasteel88 blog header photo
manasteel88's c-blog
Fronts 9Posts 2Blogs 172Following 0Followers 74



Rant: Uncharted 3 and Euro Gamer


I had this written up late last night, but wasn't planning on doing anything with it because it's pretty ranty and not that good. However, this issue bled on to the front page and I figured I'd post it instead of deleting it.

So apparently Eurogamer gave a game a review score lower than the perceived average score. This being Eurogamer, nobody should be surprised by this. They do it for every game because that's how they use the range. They have a long running history of this.

However, since it's Uncharted 3, one of Sony's big exclusives of the year and a potential game of the year candidate, it seems people have an issue with this.

First of all, I don't care about the review score. Like I said, this is typical Tuesday stuff for Eurogamer. Don't like it, well take that up with the Brits. I also don't care about Uncharted. I played the first game and thought it was a solid game throughout, but couldn't replicate the fun or excitement of the original Gears of War. I haven't touched the sequel, but I can understand where they were going and what they achieved with it.

What Eurogamer complained about wasn't about any of the things we as gamers come to expect from a critic. It was about preference. I have a slight issue with that.

Linearity is the name of the game in this review. Uncharted 3 apparently is so linear that it pushes you to explore their world instead of exploring your own. Simon Parkin over at Eurogamer has an issue with that. For those who like breakdowns, he's fine with the story, graphics and gameplay. He has an issue with how they presented it.

I'm a huge fan of any developer that can actually immerse you in a game. This current generation is spectacular in it's ability to achieve this. Portal, Bioshock and many others have obtained this. It is one of the greater things that can happen in a game. However, as a reviewer, I can't expect you to gauge immersion.

If the game is faulty because of a design element, a glitch or even just poor realization of a goal, I can see that. Those are what we call faults. However, to not be able to specify this and go on a long tangent about how the game seems scripted is weird. He writes about a fault that could entirely be his own. The only hints I can perceive is the fact that he wanted to blow up a wall that wouldn't let him. As if it's a developers job to allow you to break the world apart to create your own.

This isn't Red Faction and the world wasn't built to be destroyed. We as gamers learned all of this in Super Mario when we hit the first brick and it didn't break. Miyamoto told us we couldn't do it, so we played by his rules. Because of this, I understood that when Mario 3 came out, I shouldn't be expecting a Zelda like experience.

Freedom is a choice in a game. It isn't one that the player chooses, it is one the developer does. If they give you that option, then you can achieve what you will with it. Otherwise, you have to play by their rules in their world. If what they present to you is boring, infuriating or something else entirely, then you have grounds to make claims against the game. If you want more, discuss it. Don't tell me that they played it safe except "for a couple of sections where drug-tipped darts cause havoc with the ensemble cast's minds, and some wonderful moments when the scriptwriters dip back into Drake and Sully's origin story." You are a critic. BE CRITICAL. This is praise. You mean there are wonderful moments to enjoy in the story that at times run off into a weird place, but they played it safe?

I know less about the issues Eurogamer have after reading this review than I do any other. As a critic job one is to criticize the faults you experience in the game. If you can't express that in a definitive matter you make it come off as an argument for something different. Right now they are arguing that they wanted more freedom from a linear game that was fun in nearly every single way except when they tried to do something they obviously weren't supposed to.

That's not a valid complaint as a critic. Complaining that you can't turn the game in to your own is a valid concern as a consumer. Post Final Fantasy XIII, that is a cause for concern. However, I can cite more than enough instances in that game where the design elements hurt it. I see none of that in the article.

These are all the problems that I can find for Uncharted 3 in the Eurogamer Review:
Once an enemy sees you, all are alerted to your presence and they don't forget about you.
Discovering random trinkets isn't rewarding enough.
Sometimes Nathan Drake doesn't allow you to pull out his gun during big events.
If you miss time your jump Naughty Dog will help you however, if you jump where you shouldn't, you [i]die.

Those flaws are so weak, it belays the argument.

I believe this is all just the story of somebody that didn't want to get in to the game. Simple as that. Those aren't valid complaints above. This entire review was one reviewer's woes of being forced to follow Naughty Dog's script. It's a game that is "impossible not to get swept up in the drama, and succumb to the ride" apparently. This however is a negative as "the result is that safe thrills and awe-inspiring spectacle are all that remain, sugar-rush gaming that sends your mind into repeated spasm but does little to reward beyond the immediate high."

So it's a game that sweeps you off your feet but doesn't reward you in doing so?

All I'm saying is the review is weird. It isn't an argument on enjoyment, but tiny grievances. The game is apparently flawless in the three categories I deem definitive of a superb game: story, gameplay and graphics. Its just how they achieved this wasn't to Simon's liking. As a critic, you have to justify the faults. I can understand if somebody doesn't like a game because of something in it. However, if I can't find a clear reason for the complaints, they didn't do their job.

I think he went in to this review because he was tired of the big blockbuster experience, which is a valid concern. Break that argument down then. Don't just give us tiny grievances that reduce the game down in score only. Maybe if he had done a better job clarifying the issues he had, the backlash might not have been as harsh. People seem to be defending the review because he has the right to review it this way. Sorry Jaffe, it wasn't a good review.
Login to vote this up!


CelicaCrazed   1
manasteel88   1
Elsa   1
Jed Whitaker   1



Please login (or) make a quick account (free)
to view and post comments.

 Login with Twitter

 Login with Dtoid

Three day old threads are only visible to verified humans - this helps our small community management team stay on top of spam

Sorry for the extra step!


About manasteel88one of us since 2:10 AM on 01.09.2008

Front Paged:
E for Effort: Mass Effect 1+2
E3 2010 Recap
Changes: Fatherhood
Technical Difficulties: What A Difference Time Makes
A True Opponent Stands Before Me
P2 Press Start: Chip n' Dale Rescue Rangers
10 Games Captain America Would Play
Looking Out for the Little Guy
Special Little Places: Mississippi Memories

Front Paged on Flixist:
The Dichotomy of a Dark Knight
Not Understanding Your Audience
A True Classic: Superman Returns

Articles I wrote that I liked:
That One Mook: Gafgarion
My first playthrough of Resident Evil 2
Love/Hate: Operation Darkness
EVO 2010
Recettear Preview
Teh Bias: Nippon Ichi Software, Dood!
More Than Just Noise: Haunted by Final Fantasy
2010: Year in review and some other musings
Obligatory Destructoid Community Rocks Post
Groundhog Day: Stuck in a Book
A story from the Wasteland
PowerUp 2011
E3 2011: MS, Sony, Ninty, and AWARDS
Freedom: Jetpacks
Handhelds: East vs West
Labor Day: Player 2
Online Passes: Nickles and Dimes
2011: Year in Review and Top 10 XBL Indies

Twinfinite stuff I wrote that I liked:
Before Watchmen: It's Not the End of the World
Retrospection: The X-Men vs The Avengers
DC Kills Again
10 Reliable XBLIG Devs You Should Know
10 Disney Classics that Need Remastering
5 Best Moments from EVO 2013
5 Reasons Why the PS2 Was So Successful
5 Ways to Add Flavor to PS Allstars
Did We Really Need to Break Lara Croft?
Father's Day: Bass Armstrong
Why Do We Need Final Fantasy 7 HD?
Wormlight: A Group of No Name Losers
You Can't Fix Bad Parenting
You Don't Deserve Forgiveness
A Forgotten Hero
Future Diary: The Trial of the Father
Silver Haired Devils: Sephiroth, Magneto, Griffith
Sony Made Art Out of Ads
Celebrate the Ridiculousness of Games
The Graying of Gaming
What is Your Deserted Island Game?
An Opinion on How Value is Underappreciated in Gaming
Lazy Brain Games Legacy
Arkham Knight's Knightfall
Next-Gen Gamers: Kinect Party
An Interview with Adam Spragg
An Interview with Miguel Sternberg
An Interview with Nekros Lead Designer
An Interview with Divekick's Adam Heart
An Interview with The Behemoth's Ian Moreno
An Interview with Firebase Studios
An Interview with Lazy Brain Games: Part 1 / Part 2
An Interview with Fun Infused Games
Should I Be Happy Sonic is Selling Me Insurance
Is the $99 Xbox Worth It?
These Games Don't Belong on Steam?
Quest for Sexy Seaside Beachball: Part 1 / Part 2

Comics in Games
Comics in Games: Games in Comics
Comics in Games: The Original Batman
Comics in Games: Fantastic Four
Comics in Games: Fantastic Four Deleted Scenes
Comics in Games: Superman
Comics in Games: The Best of Marvel 1994

Comics in Crossover Games
- Spider-man and Captain America in Dr. Doom's Revenge!
- Spider-man the Video Game
- Spider-man and the X-men in Arcade's Revenge
- Marvel Super Heroes: War of the Gems
- Iron Man and X-O Manowar in Heavy Metal
- Marvel Brothel
- Mortal Kombat vs DC Universe
- Marvel Trading Card Game
- Batman: The Brave and the Bold

It Came From The Quarter Bin

- 1st Edition
- Promised Vengeance
- Sarah's Story Remembered
- First Strike! Extra!
- Fluffie Kiss
- 2112
- The Holiday Spirit
- Days of GLX-Mas Past

Games Created:
Twinfinite Pirate Kart

RetroforceGO Videos

My Greatest Failure

"We constantly have to revisit 'Why would Donkey Kong do this?' or 'Why would this environment be like this?' And then we start thinking: 'We're making a game about a gorilla wearing a tie.'"
-Michael Kelbaugh of Retro Studios on Donkey Kong Country Returns

"I have to say it's kinda scary how much you know about this game."
-Nicolau Chaud creator of Marvel Brothel
Xbox LIVE:manasteel88
PSN ID:manasteel88
Mii code:7373 3222 0438 9008


Around the Community