Tzara blog header photo
Tzara's c-blog
Posts 0Blogs 1Following 0Followers 0



A Rant (okay fine, a MANIFESTO) Concerning Video Game Journalism

Hello Dtoiders,

I've never written a blog here because I never really had much I felt compelled to say. I just wrote this for my personal blog today and thought some of you here may get a kick out of it, or it may give even more of you something to do by calling me a pretentious idiot! Either way, I figured why not post it here and let the anger wash over me like a beautiful waterfall.

Take the following for what you will:

I have no real personal stake involved with the act of writing about video games – My family will not go hungry if no one reads my thoughts on Mega Man 6 – I do this purely for my own edification. I have nothing to lose or gain and I have no horse in this race. With that basic qualifier out of the way, lend me you ear:

We are all biased in one regard or another, it’s an immutable fact of the human condition, but the honest amongst us own up to our biases – in fact, I wear my goddamned heart of my sleeve and shout my bias from a mountaintop. I do not kowtow and I feel no need to ever try and hide the fact of who I am or what I feel. The reason I’m able to do this is precisely due to the above mentioned fact; I’m not beholden to anyone to supplant my livelihood. I have a regular full-time job that has nothing to do with this website – this is purely, 100% hobby for me and I receive no compensation or reward for writing a single word upon this filthy little corner of the web you’re currently visiting. Enough stroking my own ego though, let’s jump beyond my back-patting, boring opening salvo and get into what this post is REALLY about – the overwhelming bias in contemporary game’s journalism.

Now, personal ‘fan-boy’ bias wherein you personally prefer one system or company over another is completely natural and should not be something people are ashamed to admit to in mixed company. However, if the very function of your job is to report fairly upon an industry – not a single company or product, then wilful deceit at the service of special interests is another matter entirely and one which should not be abided by anyone, whether their views align with those who deceive or not.

To put it in familiar terms; this is the gaming world’s journalistic equivalent of Fox News – sure, crazy right-wing republicans like it because it repetitiously forwards simple refrains which echo their own personal ideologies, yet they “like” it only out of the knee-jerk human desire for confirmation bias. It’s a soft handcuff chaining them to a form of cognitive dissonance which allows them to have a driving social purpose and a perceived position of some superiority in a world far out of their control. (Holy christ, I swear my plan was to make this short and simple and now I feel like I’m writing a fucking thesis).


This feeling of being ‘in the right’ justifies their abhorrent behavior in the social sphere. The analogy is germane to the gaming industry in that, once the consumer invests X amount of dollars into a console they want to feel as though they made the “correct” investment and that their decisions are justified by some form of demonstrable ‘superiority’ over any other brand or product they could have chosen to support.
It is all part of a larger narrative where the true plot is played out inside ledger books in gilded towers far from any kids sitting in their homes with a controller in their hands. Video games have blossomed into a multi-billion dollar industry and as such, much like any other industry which becomes a world-wide economic force, it has been infested with people and companies hungry to secure their own financial success with nothing but cynical opportunism as their endgame. In short, they’ve taken another successful industry into the dark wood of relentless corporate capitalism where they begin existing solely to facilitate the growth of special interest groups controlling a crafted narrative which is then espoused to the consumers of said business product in order to maintain a brand identity at all cost. This in turn inevitably brings about the ruination of the ethical portions of the industry by rewarding those who are most willing to follow and support the subverted narrative.

Which brings me to the point of all this droning verbosity:
Within the past week it seems as though the veneer has slipped due to a certain level of frenzy surrounding the new console launches and a certain company has finally succumbed to the barrage of months of bad news which has now culminated in proof positive, real-world examples of those months of disastrous and vocally denied “rumors”. Yes, all coyness aside, Microsoft, and their Xbox One product has been troubled from the start and now every terrible, hushed rumor you’ve heard about the poor design, insincere company focus and outright dishonest product perception turns out to be (mostly) true.

Microsoft has really gone into damage control and basically declared martial law and called all hands on deck. Many people who previously seemed fair at best (in regards to their ethical commitment to their jobs), have started to reveal they are anything but Lines have clearly started to appear in the sand and certain people with widely listened to voices in the industry press have begun to, for lack of a better phrase, spin for corporate interests (like a record, baby, right round). These people who have most publicly responded to this call have become unhinged, nasty, and volatile in their dealings with a public more and more aware of the now blatant problems with Microsoft’s new console.

Let me be fair and say this – for all the technical problems The Xbox One seems to be saddled with, this is th least of my concern. These things can be forgiven if a console has good games and other mitigating factors are in place to justify purchasing it. The problem lies in how journalists try to obfuscate these facts and misrepresent them to the public that is the problem I speak about here. The Xbox One could be a great console in a year’s time – I don’t care either way. I still play my SNES so obviously I have things I rank above raw performance power to justify a console’s worth. The onus of the negativity in regards to what the Xbox One is or isn’t is directly related to how this information is delivered to us all by gaming journalists – not on whether it can hit 60fps or not.

These “journalists” who have been vocally indignant at anyone who dare question Microsoft’s intentions or PR babble throughout this shitstorm have shown their true nature as nothing more than an extension of these PR mouthpieces for corporate conglomerates. Their interests clearly lie within themselves and they should not in any way shape or form be regarded as journalists, or be given the benefit of the doubt when it comes to any form of ethics or integrity in the field of reporting un-biased news.
This past weekend proved that passive aggressive, attention-whoring tweets are not only lame for the obvious reasons, but doubly lame because what these allusions really boil down to is the authors being cowards who are afraid to speak their minds in fear of angering any corporate interests, while still managing to infer that one company is doing something wrong and deceitful to change the focus away from the true problems at hand. They walk this feigned line of insult and adoration between two companies in order to continue to parasitically suck at the teet of free games/systems/swag. They’d rather be pampered than to come right out and take one of these companies to task for underhanded or disingenuous practices.

They’ve displayed such obvious and blatant obfuscation of facts and stand as nothing more than cynical and worthless advertisements for corporate interests. They’ve shamelessly perpetuated what amounts to fraud upon the audience they are supposed to represent the best interests of – this is unforgivable and wholly unethical in every logical regard. They unwittingly cast off the auspice of “journalist” when they buy into the cult-of personality and place the focus on promoting themselves (or the public persona they’ve crafted of themselves) over reporting news, facts or covering events. The downtrodden finally grow up and find an audience who will treat them like rock stars and these silly twats play out their neurotic savior-complexes with all the subtlety and decorum inherent in the act of killing an ant with a sledgehammer. They grow into comfortable, passive outlets for crafted information to be channeled through.

My blacklist of the major gaming sites I choose to boycott after these last few weeks stands as follows:
[li]Rev3 Games[/li]
[li]Game Trailers[/li]

I do not trust, enjoy or give these sites a single modicum of respect – I hold them in complete contempt and I charge them with the ruination of decent games journalism in every regard. I won’t go into specifics about individuals or the entities they currently are employed by, but suffice it to say – just read everything I wrote preceding this list and apply it liberally and with a wide brush to the names written.

Corporations do not care about you – Microsoft or any other. Do not play into their game of becoming their somnambulistic defense force at the sake of your own logic and gut-feelings. You do not need to justify to anyone why you feel you should spend $500 of your own disposable income on a video game system – if you want to enjoy it you will. You create your own meaning and can find peace within yourself through honesty and empathy for others. Enjoy what you enjoy and leave the shameless whoring to the professionals so it is easy to spot who you should ignore.
Login to vote this up!


Tzara   1



Please login (or) make a quick account (free)
to view and post comments.

 Login with Twitter

 Login with Dtoid

Three day old threads are only visible to verified humans - this helps our small community management team stay on top of spam

Sorry for the extra step!


About Tzaraone of us since 12:31 PM on 12.01.2010

Film/noise/love maker, writer and gamer.

Xbox LIVE:Tristan Tzara
PSN ID:Surrealist_gest
Mii code:5429-3155-5130-1358


Around the Community