Join us! Nintendo Enthusiast Forums
Tubatic blog header photo
Tubatic's c-blog
Fronts 11Posts 1Blogs 208Following 0Followers 151



Sigh...Tubatic Blogs about Race: RE5, Definitive Verdicts and Convenient Acceptance of Academia


Hey. What's up guys. Its Tubatic. Truly, I should spend my Friday evening STFUAJPG, but I've got a few things I'd like to say about this "Final Verdict" on the RE5 Racism Issue.

Hear me out. I'm not trying to bring down gaming society or call everyone racist or racially insensitive or , even, ask you to understand how someone could have valid negative feelings about the imagery of RE5 and/or its trailers. But I would advise you to scrutinize your media

I know its always refreshing to find an opinion from a guy with a degree or five that share the same opinion that you came to with your 0 to 3 degrees of knowledge. Sharing an opinion with smart people feels awesome, and certainly no one can really take that away from you, right?

Right. But the thing is, its just one dude and his opinion on the material he was presented with.

Everyone balked at the two or three studies that our friend Jack Thompson carted out to prove whatever belief he wanted to push about game violence. And certainly, everyone shunned his studies as bullocks, partly because it wasn't what anyone wanted to believe and partly because it was a few questionable studies. So I posit to you, revelling gamers, that perhaps this is just one man's opinion on an issue, and that nothing has truly been decided/solved/or finished. If a study or an expert lawyer can be questioned, why not an anthropologist?

Given that, consider what Mr. Bowman was asked to comment on. Three levels of a certainly more than three level work of video game artistry. Of course, any final verdict on a game should involve the entire work, right? I mean, we could certainly look up Mr. Bowman's gamertag and see how much of the game he's completed. That's got to have some bearing on his professional opinion, I reckon. If our own Jim Sterling can't come to an informed opinion on Halo Wars after more than 40% completion, can we let an Expert Anthropologist slide that easy on his final verdict? (This paragraph contained Sarcasm on the Internet)

Enh, maybe we can. What ever. But consider this: Where's Mr. Bowman's opinion of the trailer? There was a stir of emotions surrounding the trailer long before the game came out. If anything, our Anthropologist's opinion is a great *beginning* to a larger discussion about the game proper. But, I would wonder what message he would infer from the trailer, which started this whole topic. has done well to bring some specifically informed and educated thoughts onto the issue. But they've done you all a disservice by asserting itself as an end to a discussion.

I think taking the very layered discussion about RE5 and its imagery, when racially considered, and boiling it down to "Is it racist" disregards everything in the way of discourse about race, racial tension, racial perception, stereotypes, interactions and cultural implications that the entire issue has been weaving in and out of.

Look, I don't think RE5 directly disenfranchises anyone. It didn't steal my wallet and it didn't keep me from getting a job. But I think that its unfortunate, even given that the internet will be the internet, that a single opinion on an issue from an expert illicits such blinding self-reassurance.

Am I alone in my hestitation to feel safe and righteous because one guy that lectures on anthropology expresses an opinion on RE5?

Regardless, I'm Ready to Friday.

Edit: For your consideration, the unofficial curriculum vitae on Glenn Bowman
#Community    #Rant   
Login to vote this up!



Please login (or) make a quick account (free)
to view and post comments.

 Login with Twitter

 Login with Dtoid

Three day old threads are only visible to verified humans - this helps our small community management team stay on top of spam

Sorry for the extra step!


About Tubaticone of us since 2:45 PM on 11.13.2006

-Super Meat Boy regarding Super Meat Boy

Hey. Follow me on Twitter! I'll tweet about games! Promise!
Twitter - TubaticPrime

Highlights from my blog include:

-2010 Sucked: Fable III Exemplifies the Year in Disappointement*Promoted Blog
-Keep It Complicated, Stupid
-What Wii Gaming is Like for Me*Promoted Blog
-I, The Author: How I Stole the Declaration of Independance*Promoted blog

Way of The Samurai, Shadow of the Colossus, Castle Crashers, Jet Grind Radio, ICO, Super DodgeBall, Canabalt, FTL, Final Fantasy VI and X-Com are some of the finest games ever made in ever

Xbox Live: Tubatic
PSN: Tubatic
Wii Console Code: 3554-2775-5012-0810
Tatsunoko Vs Capcom Code: 2107-0561-3043
Brawl Friend Code: 1762-2359-5359 "Tbatc"

Players can elect to summon "cartoony" versions of bats, bombs, guns, and flamethrowers. These types of items can be used to destroy objects or even other summoned items (e.g., a club can be used to hit an animal; steak can be attached to a baby to attract lions; rockets can be lobbed at a man).

-From the ESRB description of Scribblenauts

"Right after getting back to Japan, [Miyamoto] suddenly said: "You know we're including golf now." Apparently he'd stated in an interview that this time round golf shots would be determined by the backswing, even though at that time a golf game didn't exist in any shape or form!"

-A Nintendo Staffer explaining why Golf was added to Wii Sports Resort

"I have seen the Summa that everyone talks about. And I want to pour gasoline on him and cut off his ear. "

-Pendleton21 after listening to the disavowed Podtoid 94: So Baller

"question, did you play with controller or keyboard?

because controller is unplayable"
-Luc Bernard re: the first release version of Eternity's Child on Steam


"Just because u like a game doesn't mean u have to give it a high score"
-excerpt from the epic trolling on the Prototype review, inFamous/Protoype Wars, June 2009

Xbox LIVE:Tubatic
PSN ID:Tubatic
Steam ID:tubatic
Mii code:Tubatic?


Around the Community