I will start by saying that I love console games. They are a lot of fun in the right context. However, I can't see how a console could ever be considered as good as the pc platform for gaming.
Two things I notice that is better in PC games:
Sure, they are adding all kinds of buttons to the console controller. I started playing when there was one button, or just a wheel your turned. But the PC has always outclassed console games in control depth.
Take any Jane's Flight Sim. Every keyboard key is attached to a control of the aircraft. Then you have alt, control, and shift to add even more controls than even a keyboard can offer.
There is no way to have that amount of control using a handheld xbox controller.
Aside from that is speed and control at the same time. I'm a big "mouse" fan. I can run, jump, leap, fall, and always keep my sites where I want them, for the most part.
With a joystick-based thumb-control, no matter how much you speed up the sensitivity of the stick, it's still not as accurate as using a mouse.
People that have never gotten over the mouse-shooter learning curve, or never even tried to play shooters on a PC argue with me over this. But I have given both platforms many hours of play. Mouse still have a better control system than joysticks.
I love playing multiplayer in the stage maps in just about every shooter. What I do hate is these blockbuster games that are making a billion dollars in 24 hours, like Black Ops II, that ship without the ability to play COOP campaigns.
When there are two buddies getting together just to play xbox, why not allow them to explore the theatrical story of the game together in co-op? You can do it split-screen or just on networked xboxes. But most of the games out there refuse to add this feature.
I will give sports games to the console. PC versions of sports games are usually just cheap replicas of the console version. The PC hand controllers were never perfected either.
I will give graphics to the console games. They are simply amazing. Unless you have an AMAZING gaming PC, graphics won't get anywhere close to the consoles.
The solution is to merge the two platforms.
Microsoft has the edge in the console market with the xbox. They have the community on xbox live. They also have their windows operating system on just about every computer in the world. (says the guy blogging from a mac)
Why don't they spend a little bit of their enormous income on creating a bridge between platforms?
If they ever do, I've got a lot of young, whipper-snapper xbox players who I'm ready to slaughter when I get my mouse!
LOOK WHO CAME: