OpiumHerz blog header photo
OpiumHerz's c-blog
Fronts 1Posts 0Blogs 93Following 0Followers 49



Dear Jim Sterling...

Dear Jim Sterling,
first of all, let's get the slime out of the way, shall we? Big time fan, love Jimquisition, love PodToid, yadda yadda yadda. See, you are essentially what brought me to this site - to this community. A community I liked so far a good bit. But today you posted an article. Namely this one.

(if the picture isn't displayed I'm sorry - it IS displayed in the editor just fine, it is simply a screenshot of the article itself)

After reading this, it was the first time I felt you could be rightfully accussed of bad journalism. For more than one reason. See, I know you like to ride things beyond the past, where they are dead for most people. It's something I actually don't find bad, seeing how quick the carpet was lift over the desaster that was Aliens: Colonial Marines. And while I find the fight you fight for female characters in gaming one that is only between you and enemies you yourself make up (but that's not the point here - that would be a topic for a whole different evening), I enjoy those pieces too. I often disagree with you, I would even dare to say: most of the times I disagree with you. But I enjoy your works nonetheless, since it offers me another point of view. One I might have not considered yet. One that makes me think. You actually inspire me sometimes to ponder over my point of view.

This article however was something I didn't see coming. The first thing that made me raise my eyebrows was the fact that you withheld the covers that were offered for voting, only presenting the shopped picture. You didn't even MENTION the fact that one of the four covers to vote for was another The Last Of Us picutre - one with Ellie in the foreground. It was a user, CommanderZx2, who had to reveal that little fact in the comments. This fact alone gives the thing pretty much a new perspective, doesn't it? Because maybe it has nothing to do with "women are shunted off promotional materials and deemed unworthy to act as playable characters", but more with the fact that a magazine wanted to give their readers some kind of choice for a popular game? 2 out of 4 covers to choose from were from The Last Of Us, one of it had Ellie in it, the other didn't. One went for the typical, as you coined it, "Gun Bro"-cover, the other one for the cover the artists wanted. But it's a 1 on 1 thing here. This sounds like a pretty fair quota to me.
Now you can argue that removing Ellie in the first place is a questionable act - I agree with that. As a writer I don't think too highly of retouching other people's artwork, especially not without their consent. However, apparently it was within the rights given to the magazine and going for two directions in a user based vote is something I can't blame them for.

The second thing is the tone of it. The retouched picture was used in a vote for the readers and the reader chose the one without Ellie (I would simply assume because the other artwork, which is also the cover artwork, has been seen to death and has become boring over the time - but that's just my guess). You know, I'm pretty sure of that thing here, NOTHING about the motives of those who voted. You don't know if the readers knew Ellie was removed from the one picture or not, you don't know what the backgrounds for the votes were.
Because, there is a simple little fact: it might have won because the readers simply liked it more. Without any prejudice or negative feelings against Ellie, or female characters, or women in general. And this it what REALLY rubs me the wrong way here. That you put off the result of the vote as a "compound of sadness", without knowing ANYTHING about the voters. You simply imply with this text, especially considering your previous works, that the people who voted for that are some assholes who have something against women in their videogames. And this is where you are absolutely out of place, without any room for "but"s or "if"s. I also read a comment that Ellie was, apparently, removed because the editor in chief of Gamereactor found her simply looking "pasted in" in the artwork.

I bet there will some more fact bubble up, maybe they already did while I was writing this, but I wanted to get this off my chest. Dear Jim Sterling, I am used to read better things from you. And while I know I can't [u]DEMAND[/u] better, I do [u]ASK[/u] for it.

a reader

EDIT: Jim went and edited the article in regards two the second part. Thank you.
Login to vote this up!


Usedtabe   1
Mike Martin   1
qlum   1
Marcel Hoang   1
Jinx 01   1



Please login (or) make a quick account (free)
to view and post comments.

 Login with Twitter

 Login with Dtoid

Three day old threads are only visible to verified humans - this helps our small community management team stay on top of spam

Sorry for the extra step!


About OpiumHerzone of us since 3:54 AM on 04.10.2013

German Blogger, writing the series "The worst thing about censorship is ███████ " (go check it out!) since I like to write about that topic and am invested in it a whole lot. Also writes some other stuff sometimes. Likes to listen to very strange bands and has the ultimate goal in life to taste every soft drink there is at least once.
Pure Gonzo - and while I thank god for Jim Sterling sometimes, I thank god for Hunter S. Thompson every day.

I'm a bastard. Don't trust me. Always keep asking, don let yourself get fed bullshit - not even by me.

I like good games. Yes, that's quite general, but I don't really like confining myself to certain genres. I like interesting approaches, invention and creativity. But I can enjoy a straight-up shooter as much as a "Bastion". It just has to be done well and appeal to me on some level.

Want to know anything else? Just leave a comment under a blog or write a message. Same goes for corrections (please), as English isn't my native language and thus isn't nearly perfect.

Censorship Blogs so far:
001: The System (Part 1)
002: The System (Part 2)
003: The stupid publishers
004: How Germans get uncensored games
005: Bioshock Infinite
006: Call Of Duty
007: Grand Theft Auto
008: Dead Space
009: Manhunt
010: Sniper Elite V2 (again)
011: Fallout
012: Various Games #1
013: Nazis
014: Mortal Kombat 9 on Steam
015: Contra
016: Halo
017: Saints Row
018: All the other stuff
019: Command & Conquer
020: The Lanzarote Convention
021: Various Games #2
022: Half-Life
023: The Legend Of Zelda
024: Various Games #3
025: Various Games #4

026: What system would you prefer
027: South Park - The Stick Of Truth
028: South Park - The Stick Of Truth (Part 2)
029: Various Games #5
030: Wolfenstein
031: Resident Evil (main series)
032: Resident Evil (spin offs)
033: Various Games #6
034: Turning Point: Fall Of Liberty
035: Blacks and women
036: Pokemon
037: Left 4 Dead
038: Left 4 Dead 2

039: 2015 Predictions
040: Dying Light
041: Coca-Cola
042: Pillars of Eternity
043: The Order: 1886
044: Mortal Kombat X

Stuff I also wrote and you should read:

~ Punish the individuals - not the scene they move in
~ My consoles don't fight each other - what's your excuse?
~ But what about the men?
~ Fake gamer girls and the damage they do
~ The Raid On Castle DToid
~ My little guide to german music (NVGR)
~ You should buy Goat Simulator - no, seriously...
~ Gravelord Nito, I love you more than Vanilla Coke
~ Let's clear up the console wars, shall we?

... und Pan spielt die Fl�te.