HandsomeBeast blog header photo
HandsomeBeast's c-blog
Posts 0Blogs 17Following 0Followers 19



Eww, Brown People In My Videogame?!

I’m a very dumb person. Maybe my multiple, extended stays in federal and state prisons are to blame, but my poor brain just can’t…do…good…think. In terms of cognitive capacity, I’d say I’m below the average bear.

Because of my inherent lack of intellect, it’s been tough trying to “do school” and “play video games” at the same time. I beat a grand total of around three full games in the last year. However, that didn’t stop my squirrel brain from making profound observations and drawing ingenious connections that sent my brain to overheating.

The three the games I am speaking about are Dark Souls, El Shaddai, and God Hand. All three were great games, and all three were developed by Japanese companies.

However, something more significant they shared was their individual inclusions of “Brown People.” What I mean by the potentially politically incorrect term, “Brown People” is, “People that aren’t White.” The term “White” can also mean many things, but for this blog pretend you are smart and understand that “White” just means a person with low levels of melanin pigment in their skin.

All three games had some inclusion of characters that were specifically not White, or included the choice of many non-White characters. The way each game used said “Brown People” also varied. The way Brown people were represented ranged from positive to negative to downright indistinguishable from using a White character. Here’s what I’m talking about:

Positive: God Hand

While it seems like this game would be the least likely to have positive portrayals of any group of people, I thought it had a fairly respectable character in one of the main villains, Elvis. One can safely guess that Elvis is meant to be Mexican from his use of luchador-like henchmen, poisonous Chihuahuas, and the appropriate use of the cuss word “mierda.” Despite the fact that those are some egregious stereotypes used to associate him with Mexican culture, they aren’t malicious by any means, and his character probably has the most development out of everyone in the whole game.

Elvis may be a demon, but it is slowly shown that he gains a respect for Gene - the main character - that keeps beating him in fights, instead of growing resentful and bloodthirsty like a typical villain would. It is shown that he may actually resent having to fight Gene in the final showdown with him as both characters seem to develop a playful friendship as they fight each other numerous times. It can also be seen that Elvis seems to have a fairly playful and possibly romantic relationship with one of the other demons, the succubus Sharon. It may not be much development, and it doesn’t seem very deep or original, but it is more than can be said for the other villains of the game, and it is a very surprisingly profound thing to be found in such a “dumb” game.

Indistinguishable: El Shaddai

This game uses the darker-than-the-usual-skin-tone-of-other-videogame-protagonists protagonist, Enoch. He doesn’t talk, and he doesn’t offend. He hardly has any character whatsoever, but it’s rare to see a “Brown Person” play the protagonist in a video game. Even if it’s just a palette swap of what could’ve been a European rendition of biblical figures, it’s still a Brown person. Take it or leave it, I guess.

Negative: Dark Souls

One need only to spend a few minutes in the character creator to see this:

Need I say more…

This isn’t malicious or anything, and it’s not on the same level of Mr. Popo or anything, but this does look kinda goofy, especially in such a gloomy game like Dark Souls. I guess it might be a bit racist, but one might say that Japan’s racism is kinda cute since it’s childishly ignorant and silly.

The way your character looks also doesn’t really matter since they are covered in armor anyways…

What should you think about this?

So, the question is whether any of the three representations of brown people are better than the other. My answer: not really.

The point I’m trying to make is that being a little fearless in designing a game can never hurt anybody (unless you are trying to hurt somebody). Including “Brown People” in video games won’t blow up in your face, so long as there is no malicious, hurtful intent in any accidental racism. These three games have prominent Brown characters in them probably due to the fact that they were developed by Japanese companies, and they had less fear of being “politically incorrect” and they aren’t in jail or being ran into bankruptcy (Clover closed, but their geniuses still live on in other companies).

In fact, taking some of that brown from a game’s environment, and putting it on the protagonist may end up making your game more interesting just based off aesthetics. Don’t you want interesting games? No? Oh, okay. What do I know? I am very dumb after all.

My constant incarceration has prevented me from playing many video games since youth, so I am also ignorant. Is it actually uncommon to see “Brown People” anywhere in video games as I think it is? I know Shadows of the Damned featured Garcia Hotspur, and the new Assassin’s Creed has a half-Native American protagonist, but are there older games out there I don’t know about? Is this something worth talking about? Are Japanese purposefully racist? So many questions left unanswered! Thanks for reading. All two of you!
Login to vote this up!


Kyle MacGregor Burleson   1
knutaf   1
Ben Davis   1
Marcel Hoang   1



Please login (or) make a quick account (free)
to view and post comments.

 Login with Twitter

 Login with Dtoid

Three day old threads are only visible to verified humans - this helps our small community management team stay on top of spam

Sorry for the extra step!


About HandsomeBeastone of us since 6:44 PM on 07.14.2010

I can't resist an oppurtunity to write about myself. I'm a fungi and I don't like to party. I prefer a cool damp place to chill in cuz I'm cool and damp. You can find me just vegetating in my house which is actually my parents' house. Having no income other than government reparation checks, I figured crashing with my old man and old lady will help alleviate the pressures of their life as they near twilight. I never get out and I don't plan on doing so in the near future. I thought this place could use some good looking me grace the c-blogs, having spent the last decade or so modeling for big corporations pro bono. I actually discovered Destructoid through reccomendations from one of my many fans.

If you can see my recently posted header, I'm a 69 years old Polynesian man living vicariously through the internet. After retiring from the drug game, I decided to lay low and assume a more humble lifestyle as to avoid cops. As a result, I came across this cave where nuclear scientists created an electronic tennis game from an oscilloscope. I've secretly followed the world of video games ever since then.

I didn't actually play any vidja games with my hands until 1997, having been imprisoned since the '40s by the U.S. government for stumbling onto their nuclear science project all those years ago. It was a Super Nintendo, and I played Super Mario World until the cartridge would bleed. To cut it some slack, I also played Super Mario All-Stars, Pinocchio, Super Street Fighter II, Extra Innings, and Donkey Kong Country 2.

I progressively continued playing Nintendo stuff because the world of war and corrupt state prison had made me a peaceful man, and I did not favor the more mature, violent alternative systems. Fast-forward to 2007 when I discovered Destructoid after the Nintendo forums were shut down. I've been watching you closely and have come to care for your community of intelligents and rogue thugs, so I decided to share my story with all of you- something I've never shared with a member of the animal kingdom with the ability to talk.

Hope I see you around, and you comment on my stuff, cuz it's like crack to me when I read somebody's input on my ramblings ;(
Steam ID:RobotSnake
Mii code:4892-7640-7746-5537


Around the Community