Casus Gaming blog header photo
Casus Gaming's c-blog
Fronts 2Posts 16Blogs 42Following 0Followers 4



Murder being killed for it's length


Most of the controversy surrounding the game Murder stems from it only having a twenty-minute length, and in a post-Steam refund world, some people think that’s unacceptable.

In my review for Murder, I said that while the game has a beautiful art style, its incoherent plot and short length make it feel incomplete.

Many Steam reviews agree, saying that “the length of the game does not justify the price” and “if you want your walking sim to be worth the money you need a longer playtime.”

Peter Moorhead, the developer of the game, said he was okay with Murder’s mixed reception.

“I'd far rather have my games be polarising than have everyone think they're "just alright”,” he said on Twitter.

Moorhead has also written about his problems with Steam’s recently implemented refund system, where consumers can get a refund regardless of circumstances, as long as they’ve played the game for less than two hours.

In a Tumblr post about the topic, Moorhead said that, “by implementing a one-size-fits all solution, Valve have just introduced a significant risk to the livelihoods of thousands of independent developers who rely on their platform for income.”

A passage from Moorhead's blog post on the topic of Steam refunds.

Moorhead said that Steam’s refund system is unfair to shorter games that can be completed in less than two hours. There’s nothing to stop people from finishing a game and then immediately requesting a refund

He also said that the system supports the idea that good games should be a certain length. Moorhead said this doesn’t account for story-driven games, or ones that have an emphasis on replayability.

Moorhead compared Steam’s refunds to a restaurant meal, saying that, “If you decide you don’t like it after a couple of bites, fine - if you decide it was bad after you’ve eaten the whole thing, of course you aren’t entitled to a refund.”

In his post he proposed that games only get refunds for games if they are less than half or a quarter completed. He also suggested refunds only apply to games of a certain price.

Jim Sterling, former editor of Destructoid and The Escapist, covered the game in a video titled, “Murder – Best Unintentional Comedy Game of 2015.” Sterling was disappointed by the game’s length and said that the plot, “barely got started and then the credits rolled.”

After Sterling’s video, Moorhead said on Twitter that his inbox was filled with abuse, and that Sterling was, “passively fielding people in his direction while claiming impunity.

Sterling responded by saying that while he stands behind everything he said in the video, he was sorry for any harassment his audience had given Moorhead.

Sterling said that his “caustic style” was part of the problem, and that it was a skill he needed to work on.

Afterwards Moorhead announced on Twitter that he was going to take a break to think about things, saying that he had felt, “anxious and unwelcome in games for a while now and it’s beginning to negatively affect my health.”

Login to vote this up!


Casus Gaming   



Please login (or) make a quick account (free)
to view and post comments.

 Login with Twitter

 Login with Dtoid

Three day old threads are only visible to verified humans - this helps our small community management team stay on top of spam

Sorry for the extra step!


About Casus Gamingone of us since 7:55 PM on 10.17.2015

The word 'amateur' is really just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to me as a human being.

I'm a writer and a video game player, with that last one taking up way too much time out of the first two.

If you like From Software, Persona and have a hard-on for retro shooters and the N64, I think we'll get along.