This is the fourth installation of a series of ‘Dueling Editorials’ I’ve been doing with Aerox
. Today’s topic is Doom vs Marathon, both leading FPS games on their respective platforms in the mid 1990’s. You can view Aerox’s argument for Marathon here
Point & Counterpoint 3: Earthbound vs. Chrono Trigger Earthbound Chrono Trigger Point & Counterpoint 2: Originals vs. Remakes Originals Remakes Point & Counterpoint 1: Video Game Violence Violence Doesn’t Affect Gamers Violence Affects Gamers
While Marathon is indeed a great game, one that I was able to experience only because a friend had a Mac, and a generally underappreciated one, it did not do for the gaming world what Doom and its first sequel did for the first person genre. Doom was the pioneer, the groundbreaker, which brought the FPS genre to everyone. Without Doom and its greatness we wouldn’t have Half-Life, Quake, or Unreal (Or any mods that go with them, like Team Fortress). What wouldn’t we have without Marathon, Halo; I don’t think it would be sorely missed.