The GHost blog header photo
The GHost's c-blog

Ghosts Posts

Fronts 2Posts 0Blogs 53Following 0Followers 119



Is The FPS Genre Stagnating?


It may be popular, but is there any genre more maligned for it's lack of innovation by "hardcore" gamers today than the venerable first person shooter?

Well maybe the sports genre... (sorry Samit :( )

Still, at some point, you have probably heard someone say that they hate FPS's, and when you hear someone critiquing the genre several comments generally come up:




While those exact words aren't always used, the basic sentiment is that the FPS genre is overcrowded, the online community is filled with assholes, and the games themselves generally require you to run through linear corridors mindlessly blasting away at enemies charging you headlong. However, the most damning problem with the genre that many people cite is the "sameness" of the games. By most accounts it looks like the "FPS formula" is pretty much set in stone.

Here's the thing: while many people fault the FPS games for the things mentioned above, I really don't think that the genre is stagnating. FPS games are popular, and as such will have many mediocre to bad games flooding the genre, ultimately making the games seem "samey" and unoriginal. In fact, I would go so far as to say that any genre that becomes as popular as the FPS genre is today will get overrun by crap games that essentially "whitewash" it.

Anyone remember when platformers and shooters were all the rage?

Looking back today we can say "oh man, things were so much better back then." but were they? Since we were so much younger we probably didn't notice as many of the flaws in our now beloved "classic" genres, but think back about how many garbage games were made for the SNES and Genesis to capitalize on the success of games like Mario and Final Fight and it seems pretty clear to me that nothing has really changed. Every once in a while we get great FPS games that expand the genre like Portal or Bioshock, but 90% of the time we get games that either "refine" the genre or simply tread metaphorical water. Same thing was going on back in the day; you have innovative games, good but unoriginal games and bland copycat games. It only seems like the genre isn't going anywhere because of the sheer number of titles, but make no mistake: this is a genre that is extremely old (at least on the timescale of videogames), and we are still seeing innovation, partially due to the crazy overcrowded market.

Even if there were a lot of copycats in the good old days, was the ratio of innovation to unoriginal better back in the day?

Can't really say, but regardless of which genres innovated more or faster, I don't think that it's fair to label the FPS genre as "stagnant" or "unchanging".

Believe you me, I'm as critical of the FPS genre as the next retro gamer, but I feel the need to just shout out into the dark abyss of the c-blogs...

FPS games aren't stagnating, they're just popular.

Random quote... EXECUTE!

I used to make original snowmen, but it was time consuming, hard work. So I said, heck, this is crazy! Now I crank out crude imitations of what's already popular! It takes no time or thought, and most people don't care about the difference, anyway! And what good is originality if you can't crank it out?

~Bill Watterson via Calvin
Login to vote this up!



Please login (or) make a quick account (free)
to view and post comments.

 Login with Twitter

 Login with Dtoid

Three day old threads are only visible to verified humans - this helps our small community management team stay on top of spam

Sorry for the extra step!


About The GHostone of us since 1:55 AM on 01.25.2008

For the basics, check out my forum intro thread.

Or for the lazy, here's all you really need to know about me summed up in one picture:

Now that that's done with, let's move onto the blog itself. This blog isn't going to contain any news. Like EVER. Like NEVER EVER FOREVER NEVER. I have no intention of doing anything other than posting original content (mostly just pictures that I make with my extremely limited photoshop skills along with original stories and whatnot). The bottom line is that I think that there are plenty of people doing editorial/reviewer style content already, and so instead of adding to the glut, I'll just stick to what I know:

Dicking around :D

Now enjoy... or DON'T!

My one year anniversary: I did a bunch of traveling and met a bunch of Dtoiders whilst doing so. Here's my one year anniversary/travel summary audio c-blog.

Other work: I also write for a site called Negative Gamer which was started by Wardrox. It's super cool and full of dinosaurs. RAWR!

Destructoid Cards

I've made many a card for many a Dtoider after getting the idea from a forum thread in which Atheistium posted a template and a challenge. Currently I'm a little too busy with school/work/fighting enemies of truth and justice to make more, but I'll get another batch out eventually. Here are links to all my Dtoid card posts!

FooLiz, Blehman and Requests: The beginning

Booster Pack 1
Booster Pack 2
Booster Pack 3
Booster Pack 4
Booster Pack 5
Booster Pack 6
Booster Pack 7
Booster Pack 8
Booster Pack 9
Booster Pack 10
Booster Pack 11
Booster Pack 12
Booster Pack 12.5
Booster Pack 13
Booster Pack 14

Secret Booster Pack 1
Secret Booster Pack 2
Secret Booster Pack 3

Rules Post 1
Rules Post 2

Cards (jpegs)
Photohop Files

Frontpaged Posts

Destructoid card wrap-up post
Katamari Damacy: The Ultimate Murder Simulator?
Why Fanboys Are Better Than You

(Header images from https://thewsk.deviantart.com)
Xbox LIVE:ImpudentCorpse


Around the Community