dark        
nekobun blog header photo
nekobun's c-blog
Fronts 19Posts 0Blogs 171Following 0Followers 30


 
 

LONG BLOG

There are two kinds of people who don't have the r-word in their vocabulary.

   0


Children, and rapists.

I promise this is my last bit of commentary on this issue. At least, until something more redeeming comes forth regarding the new Tomb Raider, or someone else at Crystal Dynamics says something stupid.

The icing on the recent shit cake that's been the handling of some questionable content in the latest Tomb Raider trailer is a series of statements from global brand director Karl Stewart, denying that anything about Lara's creeptastic, touchy-feely encounter with a soon-to-be-dead sleazeball is remotely sexual. According to Stewart, in regards to Ron Rosenberg's use of the term "rape" in his own comments, "[Rosenberg] said something which is certainly a word that is not in our vocabulary and not in our communication," as well as describing things as "close physical intimidation." A Crystal Dynamics PR rep even stepped in at one point during Stewart's interview with Kotaku to state, flat out, that "nothing sexual occurred."

Man, do I ever look forward to the Forced Hickey becoming the new Teabag in first-person-shooters. I wonder if Assassin's Creed 3's Connor's going to lay down a little thigh-touching before some of the more personal target eliminations.

As if these denials weren't ridiculous enough, Stewart's admission that this sort of thing would have played out differently with a male character on the receiving end comes into conflict with the idea that this "intimidation" wasn't sexual. If a man's threat methods differ based on the sex of the person he's threatening, what basis is there for such a difference besides sexuality? Concerns about cooties? Optimal scare factor based on her difference in center of gravity? It may not be the most comfortable topic to address, but it would be better to tackle the concerns regarding sexual undertones in this case rather than trying to completely shut inquiries into the topic down. I mean, consider other organizations who've been well-served by completely ignoring matters of sexual import. It's done wonders for the Catholic clergy, never mind the altar boys serving beneath them.



It's not as if Crystal Dynamics doesn't have defensible points to work with here, either. Or at least they did, before everyone providing a face for the company decided to pound tallboys of silly juice before talking to the press. One of the clearest and easiest arguments that can be made is that, while an implied sexual assault is initiated, the game's protagonist doesn't let it come to fruition. Emphasizing the fact that Lara clearly takes command of her situation, and explains to her captor that the end result of trying to force yourself on a woman is a quick dose of lead-based sinus decongestant, would have painted this whole thing in a much better light than trying to say Crystal Dynamics wants you to feel bad for Lara Croft and be her adventure buddy because someone tried to rape her. Asserting the scene as a demonstration of Lara's taking back of power, rather than another near-tragedy to throw on the pity pile, could've saved a lot of face, and stopped any potential "Give Back Lara's Pants" fan backlash that may eventually force that sequence to be removed from the game.

I, for one, am legitimately saddened by all of this stumbling, because Karl Stewart then went on to say something that actually sounded fairly impressive and intelligent. To summarize, he stated that, via Tomb Raider they're trying to "raise the bar in immersive storytelling," by throwing all of these graphic and impactful stimuli at the player, giving them a lot more to think about and interpret than the series' traditional questions of "How do I solve these puzzles?" and "Did I shoot all the dudes yet so I'm out of trouble?" They're clearly trying to push the envelope in the game itself, and it's a shame watching them collectively stumble so much as they try to remain within the envelope of social and media acceptability whenever they're asked to discuss things.



That, along with several other reasons, is why I don't think games are a medium yet equipped to address issues of sexual violence, implicitly or explicitly. The bulk of games that have dealt with sexual themes, even on a consensual level, tend to treat the subject as a throwaway in already mature-rated games, and do little more than attempt juggle and justify the addition of such content rather than actually legitimizing it as an element of story or gameplay. Watching the reactions all of fifteen to twenty seconds of footage from a teaser trailer grow into a PR circus is a pretty solid indicator that, while they wanted to push some buttons, and maybe even sincerely address a serious, real-world issue in Tomb Raider, no one at Crystal Dynamics was actually ready to discuss it. It's a damn shame, too, because aside from all this nonsense, the game looks pretty good.

If you're not prepared and equipped to to defend a choice to include a hot-button issue as a key element in your game in the face of inevitable scrutiny from fans and media, or you're simply ignorant of the likelihood of such inquiry and/or backlash, then maybe, just maybe, you should reconsider including that content in the first place. I, for one, am all for games trying to do new, different, and possibly controversial things for the sake of progress and expression, but if such things are being done without genuine concern for the topics at hand and lack cohesive support from the creative minds trying to do those things, then it's all for naught.
Login to vote this up!


 
 

  0 COMMENTS

Please login (or) make a quick account (free)
to view and post comments.



 Login with Twitter

 Login with Dtoid

Three day old threads are only visible to verified humans - this helps our small community management team stay on top of spam

Sorry for the extra step!

 

About nekobunone of us since 5:17 PM on 06.29.2007

Hi, I'm Chris, though I've been going by nekobun and variants thereof for so long, I kind of answer to both anymore.

While I've kind of got my own thing going in the realm of indie coverage, at least in the form of playing through (and streaming) (and writing about) the huge backlog I'm developing of games gleaned from various indie bundles, I try to keep my more mainstream, game-related features here, as well as opinion pieces on the industry at large, out of mad love for the 'toid. When I'm not rambling here or trying to be clever in comments threads, you can catch me rambling on Facebook and my Twitter, and trying to be clever in the Dtoid.tv chat.

Now Playing:
360: Halo 4
PC: F.E.A.R.
SNES: Secret Of Mana

Promoted:
I suck at games: PEW PEW LASERS
Improving game communities: Collective consciousness
Nothing is sacred: These walls have torn my world apart
The wrong thing: Only cream and bastards catch them all.
Love/Hate: I love to hate -you-
Love/Hate: B(u)y the book
The Future: Is still what it used to be
My Expertise: Playing the race kart
Something about sex: Sex sells, but who's buying?
E3 Approaches: It's oh so quiet
Freedom: Together, we'll break the chains of HUDs
East vs West: We've got the empire
Handhelds: Graduating as 2000's Catchemaledictorian
Relaxation: Cheesy double Chief burrito
Online Passes: A spoonful of sugar
Peripherals: Many tentacles pimpin' on the keys
This is what MAGfest is all about
Beginnings: Put it on the pizza
Disappointment: Bad(vent) timing

Recap Topsauce:
It's Thinking: Could you quit playing with that radio, love?
Do the wrong thing: And do it right, for once.
Afraid to shoot strangers.
Not if you were the last junkie on Pandora
Is Jim Sterling servicing the video games industry?
Something About Sex: Unsafe at any speed.
Doing DLC right
Congress passes sweeping Elfcare reform bill
Bottom five healthcare systems in videogames.
Pushing my love over the quarter line.
When my life would depend on an eight point none.
Remember the heroes.
Every Journey begins with a single step.
It's all over now, bomber blue.
Being Social: We'll always have Rainbow Road
Labor Day: Of course you realize, this means wark.
Please, aim it higher.
There Would've Been Brawl: Show me 'round your eggplantcage.
Integration: A place for everything
Zelda Week: I guess this is growing up.
MAGfest: the (don't be an) idiot's guide
Promotions: The bees are alright
Now is the winter of on-disc content
This was supposed to be a dozen items about nekobun.
Without Slenderness, there's something missing.
Cheap tricks (and treats) don't come cheaper than free.
The legacy of the (unlikely) wizard.
Cheap Tricks II: Sugar rush boogaloo
Thank you, for bringing me here, for showing me Home.
Burnt flowers fallen: the tragic bitchotry of Lilly Caul
Red and blue, resolving into purple.
Xbox LIVE:nekobun
PSN ID:strictmachine
Steam ID:nekobun
Mii code:2610 8366 7890 1412


 

Around the Community

Featured

Posts

Blogs

Support