dark        
Faye Dantes blog header photo
Faye Dantes's c-blog
Fronts 4Posts 0Blogs 50Following 0Followers 44


 
 

LONG BLOG

Last Guardian is Sexist!

   0


(A Chinese Qi Pao)

While I understand that while by today's standards, this is sexist but that is how society was during those ages in history. To change the design would be like having Spartans wearing jeans in the next God of War. It is unfitting for the time frame and the feeling they are trying to create.

Though the clothing design was not the only design issue. Last Guardian focuses a lot on exploration and examining the environment that you are in as well as the scale of Trico. Therefore, Team Ico chose to use a camera view that spanned farther away from the character than most games. Uede felt that it would be difficult to portray feminine traits on a screen with a focus so far out.

Clement was not buying "technical limitations" as the only reasons. Eventually the topic regarding physical strength came into play. "If you particularly focus on this title -- there is a scene where the boy is on the back of the Trico, for example, or climbing the wall. If we replaced the boy with a girl of the same age, she probably wouldn't be physically strong enough to do such movements," Ueda stated in the interview.

Clement countered Ueda by saying that if a girl was raised in a harsh environment, then she too should have equal physical strength. Perhaps there is some truth to his argument, especially for two children who have yet to hit puberty, but there's still a significant difference between men and women physically. Studies have shown that women have "45, 41, 30 and 25% smaller muscle" when it came to upper body muscles. So even though a woman could be physically fit and strong, a man is more likely to be stronger. Something I have witnessed first hand back during my high school weight lifting classes. Even the weakest male in my class could lift as much (if not more) than the strongest woman. This does not necessarily mean that females are weak and incapable of handling themselves, nor Ueda implying this. He is simply just basing his decision on what we've scientifically been told for generations.

"Tradition is important to the Japanese," Clement writes in his article, "But this tradition can also hold the culture back creatively."

It is true that there is a large cultural gap between Japan and America. He discovered that Japan views gender roles very differently than America does, thus why Ueda saw no insult in his train of thinking. While women in Japan are not oppressed, they still follow certain roles or do certain tasks due to it being an importance to their culture. However, Clement found all of this to be very unsettling to the point of being disappointment in the developer. While I understand how Clement could interrupt some of these points as being offensive, I can't help but feel as there is some hypocrisy at work here. In a way, is demanding that a female character is created for the sake of having a female character not being sexist in itself? By implying that it is wrong to use a male design more frequently in one's work?

I get that this media form is overly saturated with male leads, but I feel as if there is no reason to over enforce female leads just for them to be there. Perhaps this is just a personal opinion, but sometimes a certain gender is more fitted for the part. A developer should not have to defend oneself when it comes to choosing one gender over another unless the work is overly, bluntly offensive. At least, that is how I feel.

I do no find Last Guardian to be offensive in any way just from having a male lead and am rather confused as to why and how anyone could.
#Community    #Rants   
Login to vote this up!

LOOK WHO CAME:


Faye Dantes   
Tubatic   1
endshark   1
Kaggen   1
Dreggsao   1
zinger   1
Nihil   1
Enkido   1
LawofThermalDynamics   1
knutaf   1
Noir   1
rexwolf2   1
Marllone   1
M Randy   1
Knivy   1
LsTr Of SmG   1
Narishma   1
Smurgesborg   1
TheCleaningGuy   1
TezElNerdo   1
Subenu   1
EdgyDude   1
Elsa   1
Occams   1


 
 

  0 COMMENTS

Please login (or) make a quick account (free)
to view and post comments.



 Login with Twitter

 Login with Dtoid

Three day old threads are only visible to verified humans - this helps our small community management team stay on top of spam

Sorry for the extra step!

 

About Faye Dantesone of us since 10:00 PM on 02.07.2010

When I move my mouse around it's like my hand and the mouse don't even exist and that I am moving the pointer around solely with the power of my mind. I have achieved nearly 100% synchronization this machine and soon I will become The Internet.

It has been nearly 5 years since I've last written anything on Destructoid or any other sites. After a little rebanding and a lot of time to reflect on life, I have returned to try to breathe life back to two passions that I have neglected more than I wanted. I won't bore you with what I've been doing since then (moved a few times, got engaged, got married, and bought a house), but I'm happy to be back!

Pocket Camp ID: 4795 5943 592
Pokemon Go Code: 0731 6378 1705
Steam: Faye
FFXIV: Faye Dantes
PSN: Trapped_Artist
Twitter: zomg_its_steph


----- Past Promoted Articles ---


C-Blog Interview

Aaamaazzing: It Hurts
E for Effort: Resident Evil 4
Have a Nice Day
My Expertise - Resident Evil
Xbox LIVE:Trapped Artist
PSN ID:Trapped_Artist
Steam ID:Kumiko122


 

Around the Community

Featured

Posts

Blogs

Support