Quantcast


Would you play a horror MMO? photo

My Fourth of July was spent taking it easy (this is a chic phrase for slacking). I've been on a horror kick lately, and I haven't seen a Nightmare on Elm Street film for at least 5 years, so I borrowed a few from a friend and settled down for some bloody camp and bad dreams. Maybe they were scary in the eighties and nineties, but as a hardcore horror fan, I was only enjoying them because I was remembering them as I watched. I found them most non-frightening when Freddy Kreuger was onscreen, or even worse, when he had actual dialogue. (When were catchphrases EVER cool for evil demons?)

As usual, after watching a horror film that I thought could have been more than it was, my inner mental gibbering immediately started on how horror isn't what it used to be -- it isn't scary, why can't someone do something decent, and thank God there's a Silent Hill series at my disposal when I want to remember what it's like to be afraid. As I headed into the kitchen, the topic of horror flourishing in games blended into another idea before I even realized what I was thinking of. Would I play a horror MMO?

Hit the jump for the diatribe. 

You know, I would. HOLY COCKS YES I would. Immediately, all the secondary ideas came to mind. How would it work? Would people want to log in to a consistently frightening world? Why would it be frightening? Could an idea like Event Horizon's haunted ship be translated into an entire dimension? Bioshock has definitely got the idea -- The Rapture should unnerve many an explorer. However, that's an FPS adventure...and would greatly differ from the logistics of a dynamic world.

One major point of difference is that a horror is rarely a social experience, whereas MMOs thrive on the interactive aspect. Some gamers would say that one difference kills it off before the idea even gets started, but somehow this clash makes me more interested. Could it be possible to play with other people, but only through a complex system (you must rescue a friend or undo a curse before you can play with them)? Would an MMO that made you work to gain interactivity push players to work for it, or simply shut off their PCs in frustration?

Another common complaint of MMO players is that all they do is grind and that the games lack an emotionally engaging story. Perhaps an MMO in a post-apocalyptic setting could kill two birds with one stone -- creating a backdrop of consistent unease and fear while telling a story that all human beings can relate to the terror of. Add in zombies and you could be playing 28 Days Later Online. Imagine the pressure of having to avoid being infected every time you logged in to play, or permanently losing your character if he or she was.

I would like to see the MMO genre electrified, as even consistent WoW players admit to boredom or quitting the game because they just aren't having fun anymore. Bioware claims to be making an online title focused on "story, character and emotion", which gives us something to look forward to. When I think about playing a game that would keep me on the edge when I played, unsure of what could happen each time I logged in, I think that just might be the thing to make me interested in MMOs again. The question is, How do you execute it to strike the ideal balance between fear and playability?

I don't have answers for my questions yet, but I do know I'd be off to the game store like a shot to get a title like this. Hell, if I still went to Gamestop I might even reserve the damn thing out of excitement. Would you do the same, or would it still be just another excuse to spend 60 hours a week not having a life?








More gaming stories around the web. Got news? Submit yours to tips@destructoid.com

Colette Bennett is a Destructoid features editor from New Orleans, Louisiana. She is also a founding member of Destructoid's sister sites Tomopop, a toy lover's blog and Japanator, our anime site. Likes Nintendo DS, NES, Silent Hill series, Rhythm games, RPGs Meet the rest of the team



Post a comment! You can also post a photo below:

Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

49 comments | showing # 1 to 49
prev next

Skeeblar's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 21:53
Skeeblar
I dunno about an MMO.
Something more along the lines of Left 4 Dead, would be better, in my opinion.
Tron Knotts's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 21:59
Tron Knotts
I would not play most MMO games, as they are boring.

A horror MMO game could alieviate that problem, but only if it were awesome.

I was playing Resident Evil 4 on the Wii today, Mercinaries mode, and it never stopped being frightening. To hear that chainsaw rev up, not knowing how close it was, to then see your character's head suddenly severed from his body, that never stopped being that fun sort of scary that you get from good horror movies.

I would go for that in a MMO game, but I'd just as likely go for in off line.
Gameboi's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 22:01
Gameboi
I doubt I'd pay to play any MMO. However, a horror-based one would be somewhat tempting. As you guys/gals know, ghoulies are a soft spot of mine -- Krueger is at the top of that list.
bluemeep's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 22:02
bluemeep
I'm still appalled at the lack of a proper zombie MMO. And no, Urban Dead doesn't count.

You know, the world is lacking zombie games in general. Dead Rising remains the only one that's even made a blip on the radar since...what...the cancelled Land of the Dead tie-in game?
Colette Bennett's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 22:08
Colette Bennett
All I know is, if grinding meant eating brains, I'd play that shit.
Creamsnake's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 22:09
Creamsnake
I'd buy that for a dollar!
Nick Chester's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 22:10
Nick Chester
Zombies. A game with zombies. Please. Come on. Let's go already. Jesus.
momiji58's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 22:12
momiji58
A horror-genre MMO would be pose challenge to game developers. I liked the 28 Days Later MMO idea, and would probably play it if nicely executed.

But on the whole I think horror-genre games are better when you're playing it either alone or in small groups. The problem with MMO's I think is that it will dilute the horror experience since you have a lot of people in your party a la WoW. What makes horror games good is that you know you're alone, and no one is there to cover your back, and you don't know where the monster or whatever will pop up.
HawtPawkitHero's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 22:23
HawtPawkitHero
Think of this:
[list]
[*]Opening scene.
[*]EULA Agreement
[*]Login Screen
[*]Realm select
[*]Character select
[*]Character create
[*]CHOOSE YOUR SIDE: ZOMBIE OR HUMAN
[/list]
HawtPawkitHero's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 22:23
HawtPawkitHero
screw bbcode.
jerrt's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 22:27
jerrt
nick brutal: i was just discussing the same thing with some friends over the weekend. man i hop they make one.
Agent Nixon's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 22:28
Agent Nixon
Hell no. There is now way you can get immersed into a feeling of suspense and terror when there are idiots around you saying spamming things like "OMGHAXORWTFBBQLOL". Either that or offering you sex.
Anthony Burch's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 22:30
Anthony Burch
I'd play this horror MMO in a heartbeat.
RWarrior1CO's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 22:31
RWarrior1CO
>>cancelled Land of the Dead tie-in game?<<

Huh? It wasn't canceled. I even played it.
BlueWolf72's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 22:33
BlueWolf72
one is in the works :)

http://www.exanimusthegame.com/
Topher Cantler's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 22:36
Topher Cantler
If I got to play something like Dead Rising, knowing that every crushed zombie skull resulted in someone miles away cursing and screaming, I think I might. It sounds mean, but the thought of that kind of mass pissoffery makes me giggle. ^_^
th0mas28's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 22:37
th0mas28
Can someone please explain to me why I have an obsession with zombies? And, it seems like there are quite a few of you on dtoid that are fanatics of zombies also. I know it is nice to blow up their heads, and it is always wonderful to become an undead and attack your friends and families. But it still doesn’t fully justify this ridicules obsession I have with zombies.

I guess my question is, how come nothing else (vampires, werewolves) come close to how fun zombies are?
BlueWolf72's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 22:38
BlueWolf72
wife made me see dark chocolate so if your into wolves like me rent it... since were talking about horror
boylie's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 22:43
boylie
cancelled Land of the Dead tie-in game?

I work for the company that made that game
bluemeep's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 22:46
bluemeep
@RWarrior1CO

My mistake, it was the Dawn of the Dead game that got canned ("City of the Dead"). You're right, the Land of the Dead game, Road to Fiddler's Green, did in fact come out.

@BlueWolf72:

You've intrigued and mildly aroused me.
Gameboi's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 23:01
Gameboi
@th0mas28

We are built this way by design. It is better not to question the grand scheme of things, but just to fall in line.
tom90deg's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 23:25
tom90deg
Hmmm..I'll be honest, I'd play it. But the problem is, i think in most horror, the fear is driven by plot, and most MMOs Don't really have a big plot. Sure, they may have a slight one, but not one that drives itself to fear. Also, the big fear in Horror is that you'll die. In a MMO, you die, you respawn. It's like makeing a horror Deathmatch game, if that makes sence. No threat, no fear.
Reeper's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 23:29
Reeper
maybe because being a zombie seems within a certain realm of possibility?

idk, but there's just something about seeing a huge population of zombies shuffling towards a small group of survivors quickly running out of ammo as they discover one of their friends is bitten and turns that is pretty awesome.

i remember resident evil did a big coop thing online where if you were bitten and not killed, you could turn into a zombie without the antidote in time.
Aaron Mxy Yost's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/04/2007 23:31
Aaron Mxy Yost
Was it Kojima who had the crazy idea for a mmo zombie game with perma-death? I remember someone talking about it, and everyone saying he was nuts.
MaxVest's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/05/2007 00:15
MaxVest
@th0mas28: My own love of zombies comes from the shambling. And the limited, "brains"-centered vocabulary. And the simple motive -- all they want is freakin' brains. That's it. Zombies want brains, and you've got 'em. Ergo, they must die.
Founder's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/05/2007 01:58
Founder
Exanimus dude. Look it up, it's late and I'm too lazy to link.
Ritalin Twitch's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/05/2007 03:08
Ritalin Twitch
I think a horror MMO would work quite well, at least as a setting. As to actual horror and the player, alot of the elements that make a horror game work rely on the player being alone against the environment. Kinda like the first time I played as a marine in AVP, hearing the aliens in the ductwork all around me and not knowing where they were going to come from.

I'd love a victorian set gothic horror themed MMO. Hell, *ANY* MMO theme that dosn't involve fantasy creatures grinding out hours in the desert of despair looking for the widget of woe that only spawns off of the rare kancho oni which 72 other players are camping in order to sell online. Give me a different setting, any setting at all.

Fuck the elves.
Linkoman's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/05/2007 07:34
Linkoman
@im ok: about what agent nixion said, two words.
frendly fire.
of course. then everyone would be constantly killing one another. and if its permament death then its like one giant elemination game. although it would easily replicate people going crazy and indescriminatly killing if there was a real zombie attack.
*gasp*
Alaphic's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/05/2007 08:26
Alaphic
I have to agree with the people that are questioning how one could include player interaction without breaking the atmosphere. My first impulse is to mute everyone, making them communicate through a series of elaborate emotes, but something tells me that wouldn't be awesomesauce.
aborto thefetus's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/05/2007 09:14
aborto thefetus
Personally, I would think a zombie versus human mmo would just be bad ass. And as for what Im Ok said, I believe there are other ways to persuade a person into playing as a human. Those being that only humans can use guns, humans would be faster, humans can squeeze into places such as ventilation shafts etc. That and the whole survival thing would make the player want to play as a human or at least think twice about it.
AngelsDontBurn's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/05/2007 09:57
AngelsDontBurn
I really don't like MMO's but I'm pretty sure I'd be interested in a horror related MMO. Because anything horror related would interest me. :)
GENACON's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/05/2007 10:12
GENACON
Horror MMO huh, sounds like fun.

As long as there are no instance areas.
Humans can't talk to zombies or monsters and vice versa.

There are areas that only humans or zombies can access.

Large city like environments that have buildings people can actually enter.

Zombie ambush for the win.

And other cool stuff.
Bricfa's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/05/2007 10:36
Bricfa
I think there would have to be lots of NPC zombies Just to make sure that humans don't ever outnumber zombies. Or you could do the winnable server thing.
Bioautographical's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/05/2007 10:54
Bioautographical
I don't know how well it would work. The most horrific aspect to MOST really scary horror films or games is the feeling that you (or the main character) is completely alone. Take, for instance, 'Dream Warriors', NOES's third installment. I love that movie. But not because it's scary. And one of the reasons it wasn't scary is because no one was truly alone. There was the big gang of misfits. Sure, they all got picked off like a game of Duck Hunt, but the "safety in numbers" thing has a definitely smidge of truth to it.

Now - a merely online game that WASN'T massive-multiplayer? Or MAYBE making a game that's free to play if you're a monster, but you have to pay to be an actual "good guy" so that maybe there's a disparity in favour of the monsters that the "good guys" have to fight? That might work. Sort of like that Vampire/Werewolf browser-based game. It wasn't what I'd call scary, though.
vcleniuk's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/05/2007 13:24
vcleniuk
A 28 days later MMO could work. Part of that storyline is to survive on your own, or find a group of survivors to stay with. You could help each other stay alive or throw them to the rage.

There's also the constant search for weapons and food. I think this is all the makings of a good MMO.

Though after the 10,000th time of being chased, hiding, bashing/shooting zombies, it might get boring. The game or story would need some type of increasing challenge built in. Not sure how though...
buddamagoo's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/05/2007 14:17
buddamagoo
I like browser-based games better, it's easier getting by with playing them at work. :)

Waiting for MurderMotel.com to come out of Beta. That should be cool.

Anyone tried The Ship? It's a Steam game based on the HL2 engine.
notquiteallhere's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/05/2007 16:37
notquiteallhere
Isn't CCP working on a World of Darkness MMO after buying out White Wolf? Couple of years down the line, you might have what you're looking for. And there's Hellgate: London, of course, but that doesn't qualify as a true MMO in many people's eyes.
Tankety-Tank's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/05/2007 17:05
Tankety-Tank
I think the best way to pull this off would to have NPC Zombies and then the players are the people. There are NO levels for the players to obtaine, that would be kinda gay in a game like this. When your Char dies, hes dead forever. The way that a person compares himself to other people is the amount of places he has explored, the weapons he has, the amount of time he has logged, and zombies killed. The reason i say there should be no levels is because perma death isnt so bad. Still bad just not something you would want to kill yourself over. You would lose weapons and quests/missons you compleated, thats it. I do like the idea of having to earn the social interactive side of it by "rescuing a friend". To keep party numbers low, they could take aspects from the Guild Wars system. These are just my thoughts on it.
Roland Deschain's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/05/2007 17:09
Roland Deschain
I think we need a vampire MMO. Something with all the traditional lore, myths, etc. surrounding it.

But, alas, I dream...since nobody has even made a damn classic vampire game of any sort, yet. Just a bunch of cheap knockoffs that don't even begin to touch on vampires, as traditionally thought by most people.
devon3100's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/05/2007 18:05
devon3100
A horror MMO is already being created. It was announced just around E3 last year. It's called Exanimus. It's a Zombie based MMO where players can choose to be human or a Zombie. Check it out at http://www.exainmusthegame.com. There is also a wiki for the game at http://exanimus-wiki.com
UniversalTarget's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/06/2007 01:25
UniversalTarget
honestly, I'd play it if it a guild wars approach (not combat system-- world system) with some modifications. You'd not have the open and vivid world, but you WOULD only have a few people around to help you out in the instanced missions, leaving the claustraphobia. You could even have classes or characters that had no combat capability whatsoever, but would be able to do things like heal or use computers (a doctor, a nerd) which characters like cops or military would have to protect. These characters would have to solo by sneaking around, but could get EXP based on what they do-- not how much time they spend killing stuff. You could even do sizes instead of races, so smaller characters could sneak through air ducts or tight areas and zombies could sneak in the same way. Larger characters could break through doors or throw things, allowing bigger characters to bar off doorways and bigger zombies to smash the barricades down easier.

On top of that you could have combat-heavy battle areas where there were a lot more people and zombies, explorable land space, and that are there for specific objectives. Imagine being the lone nerd in a group of 10 military guys that are trying to hack a communications center that's overrun. "LFM for Zombie Mall, have lockpicker and doctor, gonna go get chainsaws..."
GrimReaper's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/06/2007 18:46
GrimReaper
I've thought about a zombie mmo quite a bit. I think a good way to go would be like how Gunz Online is set up. You pick a class(medic, cop) such as that, and join small groups. The leader of the group chooses the settings. Different modes, how difficult, the setting, how many people, things like that. You could also buy weapons and armor at a shop before entering the game.

For example: 8 players, hospital setting, survival mode. The objective is to survive. Someone posing as a scout reports that a massive number of zombies are headed in the direction of the hospital, one of the last few safe havens within the city. There are some medical supplies, but ammunition is low. Within an hour, the zombies are in sight. Set up barricades, traps, and other such obstacles, then wait till they're in range and let loose. The players must work together in order to keep the zombies at bay, for if they manage to break in, all is lost, since there is no longer a barricade holding them back, and several bites could mean the end of your existence as a human, and the beginning for a zombie.

I really think something like that would work pretty well. What do you guys think?
atheistium's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/09/2007 14:05
atheistium
Just the two of us~~~ *sings*
It's pretty scary that we both like scary games and that I am going to rape you in about 40 minutes and then make you watch me eat delicious cake... BWHAHHAHA!
Maserati's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/11/2007 22:06
Maserati
A zombie MMO is running right now - browser based even. It's called [url=http://www.urbandead.com]Urban Dead[\url]
Maserati's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/11/2007 22:08
Maserati
[url=http://www.urbandead.com/Urban Dead[/url]

damn bbcode
Maserati's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/11/2007 22:09
Maserati
http://www.urbandead.com

copy n paste ftw
merix's Avatar - Comment posted on 02/26/2008 22:16
merix
i think a 3d zombie mmo would be fun, and the sokution to the crowds thing is simply this in my opinion, instances of areas, limit it to X number of peeple per area and each party gets their own separate instance of that area. you get the horror experience and the mmo experience, everyone wins:P
September Abraxas's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/30/2009 00:27
September Abraxas
Dear Colette,

I do think you should put the apostrophe where it does belong.

Also I think that horror might be composed of more than guns and walking dead. Please refer to Ravenloft, Call of Cthulhu, and GURPS Horror. I think market saturation might be met by present high budget walking dead flicks -- but horror movies remain a constant sale.
Jeffrey Peterson's Avatar - Comment posted on 11/30/2009 15:47
Jeffrey Peterson
I dunno about anyone else but i would prefer a MMO game based in a hospital, basic synopsis would be that you are a patient there that has the ability to "see" outside the normal world into another phase of reality. The player would have special abilities (these would be your skills according to the class you choose) to help fend themselves from attacks.

The hospital of course has power problems which would reason why some areas go out of power and cause your reality to shift but not always.

Some features would be: character customization, branching storyline that changes depending on how you react when in the light (lights on) that change how you see tings in the dark (when power goes out) as well as a story that can only be understood after multiple people play through the story line.

The feel if you want to imagine would be something like an Asian horror. dark lights, stuff that creeps up on you. things like that.
prev next

Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

Comments policy

Destructoid is an open discussion community. You don't need to "audition" to post a comment - just speak your mind. We respect differing opinions on the site, so have at it. Be smart, funny, insightful, clueless, or cute -- but back it up with substance. Keep your cool, keep it fun. We only ask that you act respectfully and above all: don't be a troll and ruin it for everyone else. Don't bring down gamers or we'll, you know, gently shoot you in the face and stuff you into a flaming mailbox. Each comment is your opportuntity to make this community awesomer. Is that even a word?

Avoiding the banhammer only requires common sense: spamming, trolling, racism, NSFW stuff, and other forms of sucking will not be tolerated. If anyone is griefing please report abuse. Be good. Don't suck!