Quantcast
Why Mass Effect 3 haters need to calm down - Destructoid




Game database:   #ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ         ALL     Xbox One     PS4     360     PS3     WiiU     Wii     PC     3DS     DS     PS Vita     PSP     iOS     Android


Mass Effect 3  



Why Mass Effect 3 haters need to calm down


4:00 PM on 03.19.2012
Why Mass Effect 3 haters need to calm down photo



I realize that expecting reasoned discourse from the internet is a tall order, but the reaction to the Mass Effect 3 ending is beyond absurd. It transcends rationality and tips over into the positively juvenile. This is meant to be a counter to many fan complaints. I don’t have a response for all of them, but I definitely have some ammunition of my own.

Let’s do this.

MASSIVE SPOILER ALERT- YE BE WARNED!

Mass Effect
could be said to be the original BioWare studio’s magnum opus.  A grand space opera that is as massive in scale as any modern-day epic. In terms of the scope of the original works, it dwarfs Star Wars and Lord of the Rings combined. A monumental undertaking that should definitely be commended in part if not in whole.


"I didn't get any closure!"

There are -- as pointed out in this article at Gamefront -- dozens of concepts, questions, philosophies and the like that are raised, examined and then considered. A broad variety of topics ranging from free will to racism and gender equality has a role in the tale of Commander Shepard. Many have claimed that the ending of Mass Effect 3 doesn’t address these and gives fans the short shrift, but I think that’s bogus.

ME3 answers a lot of questions. It gives closure to damn-near every single event that has taken place over the past few games, and every major theme gets some screen-time. In the last 10 minutes alone we have heroic sacrifice, unity of peoples, hope for a new tomorrow, and the consideration of the imperfection of humankind. And all of this is before the “multi-colored explosions” bit that so many hate on. It is at once a tribute to Shepard, a new beginning for the inhabitants of the Mass Effect universe, and the only true way to break the cycle and start over from scratch.

In both Mass Effect and Mass Effect 2 there are references to the fact that the Reapers are guiding the evolution of organic life by putting the Citadel and mass relay network in place. It ensures that organic life will develop along pre-determined lines and discourages them from finding their own solutions to their own challenges. Legion comments on this in 2; by reflecting on the Reapers’ offer to provide the ‘heretics’ with a Dyson sphere, they neglect the importance of the journey, of discovering for themselves. When the Mass Relays are destroyed; it is a partial ‘reset to zero’ for galactic civilization. They still possess substantive tech, but with the war destroying local infrastructure and the collapse of the relay network isolating each species, they can steadily explore their own futures and mature with their technology instead of being rocketed ahead by the very bunch of sapient starships that came to kill them. I can’t think of any more substantive closure than that. Shepard, in every ending but one, dies so that everyone who survives the war can see a new tomorrow.

 

"The ending is far too bleak!"

Throughout the series the Reapers are built up as an obscenely powerful force that can and do easily wipe out all intelligent life. At the end of Mass Effect 2, when the camera panned out to show thousands of Reapers ready to come and retaliate against Commander Shepard, I thought that Mass Effect 3 was going to be awful. I couldn’t see how, given the degree to which this great force had been established that anything other than the game could be believable, maintain appropriate pacing, and avoid a deus ex machina in the ending.

I was wrong. My fears were addressed, and in the best way I could have hoped. Instead of giving you “mindless crap”, everything is tied into building up the Galaxy for the final confrontation. All of your choices help civilians directly and unite the galaxy against the Reaper threat. Even so, you are treated to poignant morsels from your crew, both past and present, as well as countless people you have met along the way. Every choice you’ve ever made is shown to have significance, has some impact. I interpreted that, especially after finishing the game, as a metaphor for Shepard’s life flashing before their eyes. Nearly every question is answered, we see almost everyone’s homeworld, and we move towards clearing up any “unfinished business” as it were. BioWare shows you what all of your actions meant, all of the people you’ve helped or hurt. The whole thing is the “closure” fans have been asking for as we are shown the consequences of our actions. This is all in the face of that overwhelming power, the Reapers.

As all of these choices are made manifest, the inevitable truth is made abundantly clear: success against the Reapers will not be without cost. The sheer chaos, the undisputable power of the enemy Shepard faces demands the utmost respect, and ultimately the highest price -- Shepard’s life. The poetic nature of that sacrifice shouldn’t be subsumed in all of this. Shepard has the most direct connection to the Reapers. As the game progresses we can see that Shepard's psyche is steadily being dominated by them. Shepard was given life after natural death to keep fighting, and when that fight is over, gives that life to stop them. 

It’s elegant and poignant to see that struggle end with the existential cessation of Shepard's only foe.

 

"All you get to pick are different-colored explosions!"

I contest the claim that there is no player choice and that the ending doesn’t reflect decisions from any games; especially when those complaints come from “fans.” I am operating under the assumption that these people liked the endings of the previous games, given that they are, you know, fans.

In Mass Effect, regardless of any choices made before, you can choose to save the council, kill the council or pragmatically withhold Alliance forces to take down Sovereign. Nothing else you’ve done in the entire rest of the game matters, and regardless of what you choose Sovereign dies. It’s the same cut scene too, with the Normandy delivering the final blow.

In Mass Effect 2, you have only two options. Destroy the Collector Base or preserve it, but either way it is the EXACT same cutscene that plays at the end. Weird.

In Mass Effect 3, your choices affect whether or not everyone on Earth dies, how the Reapers are handled, and whether or not Shepard dies. There are parallels drawn to the indoctrination of Saren with the Illusive Man and you can see the steady corruption of good intentions and sympathetic ideals. It’s a cautionary tale against blindly charging forward with an idea without careful consideration of all options on the table, and all sides of the debate; a fun little comparison I like to make to the lion’s share of ME3 ending detractors.  

"The scene with the Stargazer invalidates the whole series!"

Mass Effect constantly references our earliest space exploration efforts (Commander Shepard being an allusion to Alan Shepard). The 'bedtime story' is meant to give the child, and the audience, hope for the future of space exploration. It's fitting then that, after having established the notion of a new age for the Milky Way's residents, that we are treated to scene about the hope that Shepard inspired. I took it as a not-so-subtle nod to the generations of kids that were influenced by the early space programs, and a desire to that optimism imparted on a new crop of starry-eyed youngsters.

Then I went back and checked something. It turns out that the Stargazer is actually Buzz Aldrin, the second person to ever walk on the moon. That scene took on a new significance for me, as it paralleled a lull in our own exploration after the conclusion of the Space Race. Now entering an era of privately funded ventures, we are on the cusp of another period of advances in extraterrestrial excursions. Aldrin, a consistent proponent of space travel is beckoning the child, and by extension us to look to the stars and hope, for the first time in decades.

The real tragedy...

The final moments of Mass Effect 3 are definitely outshined by the sheer brilliance of the showdown with the Reaper on Rannoch, the death of Mordin, and the entire run up to the final confrontation with the Illusive Man, but it is still a very solid piece of work. Especially when taken together with the rest of the game. It's a perfectly competent conclusion to an outstanding space opera, totally undeserving of the vitriolic hatred it's been getting.

Casey Hudson has gone on record stating that he wanted a "story that people can talk about", and regardless of how you feel about the game, it's definitely accomplished that. Between the hallucination/indoctrination theory or our own community discussion, there's been a lot of chatter. 

Still, I think people should really be getting pissed about the fact that they changed Mordin's voice actor. It's bullshit.








Comments not appearing? Anti-virus apps like Avast or some browser extensions can cause this.
Easy fix: Add   [*].disqus.com   to your software's white list. Tada! Happy comments time again.

Did you know? You can now get daily or weekly email notifications when humans reply to your comments.






timeline following:
Mass Effect 3



5:00 PM on 05.15.2014
BioWare announces most popular Commander Shepard names

BioWare has published player data culled from Mass Effect 3 to determine the five most popular names chosen for Commander Shepard, and the top names might surprise you. Sarah and Jack are at the top of the list for both femal...more



3:15 PM on 05.02.2014
Thank the Goddess! Mass Effect 3 Omega DLC is free on PSN

If you've been holding off on purchasing additional Mass Effect DLC because of the sticker shock, today's your lucky day -- if you're a PS3 player, at least. The Mass Effect 3: Omega DLC pack is currently free via PSN for US ...more



5:00 PM on 04.25.2013
Pew pew pew! Check out these new Mass Effect replica guns

Project TriForce is at it again, making detailed replicas of some of our favorite game items. Joining the M-3 Predator are three more full-scale replica weapons from the Mass Effect series, including the M-77 Paladin, the Get...more



5:00 PM on 02.25.2013
Details on Mass Effect 3's final free DLC pack Reckoning

Reckoning, the last and largest multiplayer pack for Mass Effect 3, will release tomorrow on all platforms except Wii U. The pack includes six new characters, seven new weapons, and new equipment. On March 6, BioWare will release the final singleplayer DLC, Citadel. For more information on Reckoning's contents, take a look at the summary provided by NeoGAF's EatChildren:more



7:30 PM on 01.28.2013
Mass Effect 3 downloadable content teased, I think

The fact that BioWare isn't quite done with Mass Effect 3 has been known for some time. Today however, we have our first set of screenshots which include a casino, apparently on the Citadel, and a krogan with what looks to be...more



10:00 AM on 11.06.2012
Check out Mass Effect 3's female turians

It's nearly "late November," which means that it's almost time to dive into the latest bit of Mass Effect 3 DLC, Omega. Aria looks so excited, doesn't she? To hype you up a bit, two new screenshots have been shown by All Game...more



9:00 AM on 10.19.2012
RIP Commander Shepard

Today, we lose one more ally in the fight against all those who would encroach upon our basic right for inter-dimensional peace. When the new war for galactic freedom is waged (Salarian historians are poised to potentially ca...more



12:00 PM on 10.12.2012
Mass Effect 3 'Omega' DLC slated for late November

More details have come out of New York Comic Con regarding Mass Effect 3's Omega downloadable content that we briefly heard about back when Ray Muzyka and Greg Zeschuk announced their departure from BioWare. In short, it's go...more



6:30 PM on 10.04.2012
Mass Effect 3: Retaliation is largest multiplayer DLC yet

Mass Effect 3: Retaliation looks like another tempting bit of downloadable content intended to keep us playing the multiplayer mode. In addition to bringing the Collectors into battle, this will include a new persistent chal...more



3:00 AM on 09.07.2012
Mass Effect anime delayed

During my Mass Effect 3 experince, Lieutenant James Vega never really caught my attention. It could have been Freddie Prinze Jr's voice acting, the character's backstory, or just his design. Dude just gave my FemShep the cre...more




Anime

6:00 PM on 08.15.2014
Weirdos abound in this latest batch of Danganronpa 2: Goodbye Despair screens

What can I say? It's a screenshot kind of day. Danganronpa 2: Goodbye Despair is on the horizon, and NIS definitely doesn't want us to forget about it. Especially with the amount of weirdos in the game, as evidenced above.&nb...more



11:00 PM on 08.11.2014
A bunch of bad anime, anime games are on sale on PSN

What is an anime game? Devil May Cry? What is an anime? The Simpsons is my favorite anime, but this upsets people. The best anime movie discounted during this PSN sale is The Iron Giant, which a lot of people with a...more



4:30 PM on 08.08.2014
Naruto Shippuden: Ultimate Ninja Storm Revolution receives official Steam release date

Ever sit and pontificate on how there just aren't enough Naruto games on Steam? Boy, do I have great news for you! Naruto Shippuden: Ultimate Ninja Storm Revolution is headed for Steam on September 16 for European Naruto fan...more



View all Anime






Back to Top




All content is yours to recycle through our Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing requiring attribution. Our communities are obsessed with videoGames, movies, anime, and toys.

Living the dream since March 16, 2006

Advertising on destructoid is available: Please contact them to learn more