hot  /  reviews  /  videos  /  cblogs  /  qposts

What Twitch Plays Pokemon and True Detective teach us about modern storytelling

2:00 PM on 03.25.2014 // Steven Hansen
  @dtoidsteven

There are no monsters but men -- Scooby-Doo taught me that

Recently, two opposite things have become popular: Twitch Plays Pokemon and True Detective. Popularity is a plague, now more than ever. It spreads. Tumblr fandoms have gif sets up before an episode of a show can end. On Twitter, people are "live-tweeting" a thing while they're supposed to be engaged with it, filling that space in between live-tweet sessions with themed hashtags (#truedetectiveseason2).

I was into Twitch Plays Pokemon (Red) for its novelty, for the creativity is spawned: songs, comics, and other bits of art. But its crowd-sourced canon is infinite monkeys on infinite keyboards. Except eventually writing memes instead of Shakespeare. Because time is finite and there are constraints. The same ones that let it finish Red in only 16 straight days. Because the monkeys can't just fling shit for six years between typing "up" and "a."

The live-shared experience of things -- to the point that a thing millions are engaging with is created on the fly, user-generated -- is what is irking me. I love the communal, fish tale of games. Talking about shared experiences after the fact, but intimately and directly. Or to an audience that is looking to hear about it (in an article, for example), rather than to everyone and anyone who you have a social media connection to.

I always thought people were a bit much in considering something like a new Pokemon design a spoiler, but I'm starting to get it. These ambient spoilers, perhaps more than a plot spoiler, can affect the feel of a thing. I watched True Detective after it aired and somehow caught nothing on Twitter (besides the inconsequential #truedetectiveseason2), but I did read one spoiler for, of all things, a joke late in the season, a brief moment of levity that still gave me a laugh even though I knew it was coming, but knowing it was coming gave it less unexpected contrast. 

It's why Dark Souls is a different game at launch than a few months after, with a community to fall back on that's done exploratory legwork and crunched numbers. It's why Dark Souls II is an even more different game before launch, before the servers turned on and I wandered around with nary a note or bloodstain on the ground. 


[Xie art]

True Detective is rare in any large industry (TV, films, games). It's led by one creator/show runner, one director, and two actors. It has that palpable sense of authorship and executed created vision that I find in my favorite games, from Shadow of the Colossus to anything from Clover/Capcom in the PS2 generation to great indie titles like Kentucky Route Zero.

It is the antithesis to the seven different development team bloat of Assassin's Creed, and the antithesis to Twitch Plays Pokemon. But the latter is where gaming seems to be going. Twitch itself is only becoming more popular with PS4 and Xbox One integration. "User-generated content" has been a selling point and buzzword since last generation. And it's not inherently bad. Sometimes it's great. Sometimes it leads to cool people doing cool things the tools makers didn't even dream of. 

Maybe I'm just a shut-in stick-in-the-mud for not liking the white noise that "social integration" is trying to bring directly into my authored experiences, but as "fandoms" grow in social media size (and visibility), it's hard not to wonder what affect they have on what content gets green lit by shitty executives trying to monetize teens or whatever.

For some people, the fun of engaging in some art or creative thing is the cultural zeitgeist and shared experience, abetted by Twitter and social media, but that din kills me (unless it's Animal Crossing: New Leaf). It's unflinching, unthinking expulsion; hedonistic and boring. The rapacious plot-guessing gets out of this world.

"I've enjoyed reading people theorize about what’s going to happen because it's a sign that you're connecting," True Detective's Nic Pizzolatto said in an interview with The Daily Beast. "But I'm also sort of surprised by how far afield they’re getting. Like, why do you think we're tricking you? It's because you’ve been abused as an audience for more than 20 years. The show's not trying to outsmart you. And really if you pay attention... if someone watches the first episode and really listens, it tells you 85 percent of the story of the first six episodes."

And it's because it's not about engaging with the thing they're watching, but with the pop culture around it. "Now you're looking for the secret," Michael Caine's character says in The Prestige, "But you won't find it because of course, you're not really looking. You don't really want to work it out. You want to be fooled." It's its own Twitch Plays-style crowd-sourced storytelling and lack of thoughtful consideration that sees awful shows like The Following get continued runs. It's fan fiction without the social shame, or "you had to have been there" comedy on a scale of millions.     


[dreamondog]

Twitter and its slapdash response versus absorption and consideration is an extension of the death of the author. Twitch Plays is that taken to its logical extreme. The real story, for many people, isn't the work itself but subsuming, self-perpetuating paratext. And maybe it is all in good fun. True Detective is a story about narratives, about the stories we tell ourselves and how they shape who we are and how we view the world and how they can be dangerous. Maybe I'm telling myself a curmudgeon-y story about what is and isn't worthwhile, waving my cane at people's fun.

But with the Crystal playthrough over and done with and me not getting filled in on bits of canon every other day by colleagues, there is nothing there. You can work backwards and glean the woven tale, but it’s not the same as experiencing it firsthand. And why would you actually want to experience it firsthand? You'd need more free time and patience than I have. Its description encourages participants to, “make their own memes." That's what Twitch Plays Pokemon is. Memes. A grandstanding tale full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.



Steven Hansen, Features Editor
 Follow Blog + disclosure dtoidsteven Tips
Steven watches anime & sports, buys meat out of trucks, dates a Muppet, and is only good at cooking. He stands before you bereft of solace and well on the road to perdition. ('^ω^) more   |   staff directory



 Setup email comments

Unsavory comments? Please report harassment, spam, and hate speech to our moderators, and flag the user (we will ban users dishing bad karma). Can't see comments? Apps like Avast or browser extensions can cause it. You can fix it by adding *.disqus.com to your whitelists.

 Quickposts
Status updates from C-bloggers

extatix avatarextatix
Seems rather excessive for a 3ds game. (3ds xl for scale) [img]http://i.imgur.com/DwOtP0s.jpg?1[/img]
Cosmonstropolis avatarCosmonstropolis
Tried the stealth approach for awhile, time to switch things up. *plants C4 everywhere* I'll probably toss one on the poor schmuck that delivers my copy of MGS V. For taking so long.
WryGuy avatarWryGuy
Just a quick update for folks. Phil/Mike Martin is off the streets and safe for the next month. Thanks to everyone who helped out. You can keep up to on the forums: http://www.outerheavenforums.com/showthread.php?41974-The-Save-a-Phil-Foundation
Script avatarScript
Watching Twin Peaks for the first time. Just yooou... aaaand IIII...
Perro avatarPerro
So the 3DS Dragon Quest VII remake is coming to mobile in Japan, so there's a chance that version will get ported over here. Not ideal but if we get it at all I'll be happy!
The Travisionist avatarThe Travisionist
I'm just waiting for "Mad Max: U Mad, Bro?"
gajknight avatargajknight
Put down the deposit for my new car, will probably be able to pick it up on the weekend. Insurance is pretty good too, sub £1000 which is excellent. Kinda. My mum tried to reverse in 5th gear. She drives an automatic. What a noob. :P
Bardley avatarBardley
We are Diamond Dogs.
IDrawOnTape avatarIDrawOnTape
I get to work to stock and STAR WARS TOYS STAR WARS TOYS STREET DATE SEPT 4 OMG STAR WARS TOYS STAR WARS TOYS STREET DATE SEPT 4 STAR WARS TOYS STAR WARS TOYS STAR WARS TOYS STAR WARS TOYS STAR WARS TOYS STAR WARS TOYS STAR WARS TOYS WHY ISN'T IT SEPT 4?
Cosmonstropolis avatarCosmonstropolis
Still waiting by the mailbox. Tranq'd a jogger and stuffed them into a locker just for fun. I keep throwing rocks to get the attention of the neighbors and then hiding in tall grass. They look noticeably upset. Probably because I kept them up all night.
ChillyBilly avatarChillyBilly
Metal Gear or Mad Max? The choice is obvious. [IMG]http://i22.photobucket.com/albums/b321/Felth/obvious%20choice.jpg~original[/IMG]
Jiraya avatarJiraya
Quickpostmortem My wife´s dog died yesterday . Rest in peace Diamond Dog . [img]http://i.imgur.com/uVT3HlF.jpg[/img] Here's to you, Malu Rest forever here in our hearts The last and final moment is yours That agony is your triumph
SeymourDuncan17 avatarSeymourDuncan17
Xbone journey continues! I thought I would like Dead Rising 3 well enough as a huge fan of 1/2, but I must say I find it's emphasis on hard drama laughable and the game fundamentally disingenuine. Guess I'm moving on to Forza Horizon 2.
TheDefenestrator avatarTheDefenestrator
I dig the feature in Until Dawn where, if you have the Playstation camera, it will record you briefly during jump scares for you to watch later. It's a really neat use of an underused peripheral. Too bad I'm dead inside and never react to them.
Shinta avatarShinta
[img]http://i.imgur.com/oZ7CQJa.jpg[/img]
nanashi avatarnanashi
Fallout Shelter: Impossible to Learn, Easy to Master.
Mike Wallace avatarMike Wallace
Not saying this is the case, but Kojima has gone on record as being a huge Mad Max: Fury Road fan. Konami decided to release MGSV on the same day as Mad Max TVG. They're trying piss on Kojima's lawn, man.
ooktar avatarooktar
Downloading Phantom Pain. ETA, 16 hours. Just in time for lunch tomorrow.
Mr Knives avatarMr Knives
OH WOW. Talk about a complete about face. After slogging through the horrid beginning and slow ass swap sequence this game picked up exponentially. So far, I'm enjoying the hell out of it now. All if forgiven. Thank you based Kojima.
Rad Party God avatarRad Party God
Oh, joyful night. [youtube]https://youtu.be/6EfhAFA2yFE[/youtube]
more quickposts


Contest!


Seriously

Invert site colors

  Dark Theme
  Light Theme


Destructoid means family.
Living the dream, since 2006

Pssst. konami code + enter

modernmethod logo



Back to Top


We follow moms on   Facebook  and   Twitter
  Light Theme      Dark Theme
Pssst. Konami Code + Enter!
You may remix stuff our site under creative commons w/@
- Destructoid means family. Living the dream, since 2006 -