games anime toys
Don't just stand there!
Contribute to Dtoid:
Members login
About us RSS  
   All updates Xbox 360 PlayStation 3 Nintendo Wii PC / Windows DS PSP Retro Indie




   
Nick Chester
Editor-in-Chief
Anthony Burch
Features Editor
Jim Sterling
Reviews Editor
Hamza Aziz
Community Mgr
Niero
Robot-in-Chief
Bloggiest this week
Alan Johnson
Brad Nicholson
Brad Rice
Chad Concelmo
Colette Bennett
Dale North
Justin Villasenor
Samit Sarkar
Associate editors
Conrad Zimmerman
Jonathan Holmes
Joseph Leray
Jordan Devore
Mike Ferry Tom Fronczak
Topher Cantler
Tiffany Chow
Qais Fulton
Contributors
Adam Dork
Charlie Suh
Joe Burling
Jonathan Ross

 
Podcasts
Rev on Podtoid
Dyson on Retroforce GO!
Jim on The Podcastle

Elephant Software
Thomas Lackner

Destructoid is made by
ModernMethod




What's wrong with the female gaming community
by Christina Faith Winterburn on 11.24.2006 9 comments

What's wrong with the female gaming community screenshot

Okay, I’m a gamer and a woman; we all know that. I’ve been gaming since I was 6 when my Dad introduced me to computer games on his Commodore 64 and from there on I loved gaming. During that time, the video game industry did not market to women or girls and yet I still chose to play video games. I didn’t care if they marketed the games to me, because I wanted to play just the same. I didn’t care if they were made for women or not. Even now I don’t care if the industry markets to women gamers, because I don’t choose my games based on whether they are female or male type games. I play something because it’s got good graphics, good game play and a story line that interests me. Nowadays with so many female gamers playing and demanding to be recognized by the industry, the gaming companies are trying to include women in their marketing. Funny thing is that when the companies fail to market the right way to us, the female community is suddenly up in arms like the gaming companies don’t get us, but truthfully the problem is that they can’t market to us, because they don’t know what we want, because we don’t know what we want.

Female gamers demand equality in the industry, and yet we are the ones destroying any chance of being taken seriously by flip flopping on how we want to be treated. As a female in the gaming community, I’ve realized through trial and error that we as a group make things worse for ourselves sometimes without even realizing it, because we as group can’t decide how we want to be treated as a group. If you look at all the women gamers out there, you will see there are generally three types of gaming females, and two of those types are the ones killing gaming for the other group.

First you have the pretty girl gamer that post pictures of her on websites and always refers to herself as a girl gamer. I admit I started out as one of these because I didn’t realize how much I was hurting myself and my image in the long run. When it comes to gaming, guy gamers don’t care what you look or what sex you are, because they just want you to play games. The moment you post a picture of yourself or start with the whole I’m a girl gamer thing, you lose all creditability as a gamer and will have to start down the road of proving to the whole world that you actually game. Now I’m not blaming these types of girls saying it their fault for posting the pictures, but I’m just warning those female gamers out there that there are consequences to outing yourself, especially if you aren’t bad to look at. Ladies, by posting these pictures no one takes us seriously and in the end we just make ourselves look like attention whores they keep labeling us as. Plus consider this for one second, there are three women that frequent Destructoid.com that I know of and I know what each of these women look like, yet I couldn’t tell you what half of the writers look like on Destructoid. Also out of these three female gamers, two of them posed half naked for our site or another gaming site and out of the hundreds of male gamers I know; only three of them posed half naked for Destructoid and all of them were doing it as a joke. I know what I’m saying sounds wrong, like I’m saying that we are responsible for the evil remarks people make about us, but I’m not trying to say that. I trying to show that unless someone decides to post a forum topic that asks for the readers to post pictures, male gamers are less likely to post avatars or pictures of themselves on gaming sites, and yet female gamers feel the need to include pictures and then whine about the consequences of doing so. What can’t we just use a Gears of War logo as an avatar like everyone else? I hate to say it, but I know why we post the pictures, because we do want the attention and we have no one but ourselves to blame when the gaming community treats us badly for it or fails to take us seriously. We especially can’t whine about how people treat us when we pose in our underwear. If someone wants to see your pictures or it related to a story or something, then it’s okay to post your pictures, but otherwise a picture will just be the start of something bad.

Pretty gamers are usually the types to come on a site and scream, “I’m a girl gamer and I’m a hot too” as if to say they are special, but this really only kills our image for the female gamers that just play and don’t need to the world to know they occasionally wear a skirt. All these websites for female gamers, female gaming clans and everything else specifically for women gamers just shows the gaming community that we are special and that we want to be treated different from them, but guess what… we aren’t special any more. The ESA site says that 38% of game players are women and that we spend only 6 minutes less a day than men who play video games. Those numbers continue to grow everyday which shows that female gamers are just as normal as male gamers now. We don’t need to have special sites to cater to our needs as females because we’re not mythical beasts only spoke of in legend anymore. We can hold our heads up high and log into a normal gaming site like Destructoid.com and not feel out of place. We don’t have to hide anymore, but still we choose to make these specialty sites for ourselves so we can continue being singled out. We “girl gamers”, whine about how the male gaming community tends to question our gaming abilities and mock us at every turn, but how are they suppose to treat us when you show up with pictures of yourself half naked, declaring “I’m a hot girl gamer and a member of the Girlie Vixens Clan”. You set yourself up to be singled out because you are singling yourself by declaring these things. Being a “grrl gamer” isn’t a thing to be shouting to the world about anymore because we’re not alone in the gaming world anymore. It would be like wearing a badge that says “Women can vote” about 50 years after women got the right to vote. Everybody knows women play games, and if they do treat you like a unicorn for being a female gamer, then that’s they’re fault for elevating you to a higher level, but if you do it, then you only have yourself to blame for what happens after that.

The second type of female gamer that is ruining it for the rest of the community is the uber woman gamer; the woman that spends every waking moment complaining about how the gaming industry doesn’t cater to them and will take offence to every little thing that is said about female gamers that doesn’t feel politically correct. If you want a good example of these types of gamers, then check out Official Shrub.com and read just one of their articles on gaming. Gamers like these hate gamers like me. I represent everything that is wrong with girl gamers. Heck, the very fact that I’m using terms like girl gamers or female gamer is probably annoying the heck out of them right now.

These types of feminism gamers take the role of hardcore female too far by constantly declaring the multiple reasons of why the gaming industry is sexist to women. From the clothes video game female characters wear to the term fanboy, anything and everything could be looked at as sexist and/or non-exclusive for women. Now I agree that sometimes the industry can insult the female gaming community with their poor attempts to market to us, but if you pick on every little thing that you consider sexist, then you’re going to end up with female characters that look like real women, and truthfully I don’t want to play as an Oprah look a like or as any other normal looking woman. Video games are about fantasy and about playing as something you want to be, which why game designers create male characters with big muscles, or a James Bond look and female characters with big boobs and a tiny waist. I can be fat in real life, but I can’t have a 28 inch waist and a DD bra size. Game designers don’t create characters to be sexist, they create them because they understand that gamers want fantasy characters to play with, so they can be for a few hours something they may not be in real life.

Feminist gamers also tend to freak out about games not catering to their needs by not allowing female characters to be as strong as male ones, or by not having a choice to play a female character. I too like the choice to play as a female and I also want to see female characters have equal stats with the male characters, but I know these things all depend on the game itself. If you have a game that is going for some realism, the truth is women tend to be physically weaker than men, unless they are built the same as the guy is. I don’t like it, but it is true. I mean they could provide an Amazon woman type character to allow for equal strength, but even I admit I would still choose the petite female character over the Amazon, despite the lack in stats. As for the lack of gender choices, I would like to see more games with gender choices, but if the story was written for a male character then it’s for a male character. You don’t see male gamers getting upset because they have to play a female character in Tomb Raider, do you?

In the long run, the more you complain about the little things, the less the industry will want to cater to you or worst try to cater to you, but fail miserably and tick you off even more. If you stopped complaining for one second and realized that gaming has never been about gender from the beginning, then you wouldn’t care if Halo 2 was marketed towards you. You would just play it because you liked to play it. Be happy that at least game design companies are trying to please gamers from all walks of life with gender choices and sexual choices and stop complaining when they refer to you as a lady instead of woman. They’re just trying to be polite.

The type of female gamer all we should all strive to be is the type of woman that just plays games. They don’t complain about every little thing wrong with video games that they think is sexist, they don’t pose all pretty in their favorite Mario tank top and then post the picture on their favorite gaming site, and they don’t spend all their time on women gaming sites or join all women clans. They just play games. This is the type of gamer I should be and am trying to be because this was the type of gamer I started out as. I didn’t make a big deal about my gamer status because I didn’t care. I just played games. These are the types of female gamers the market should be focusing on, because they are marketed to the same way that men are marketed to; show us the game and how great it is and don't try to relate it to our sex. So to sum up all my ranting, the truth is this: We female gamers tend to make things worse on ourselves either by flaunting our girl gamer status, or by demanding the industry cater to us and in the long run, all we need to do as my one of my fellow writers would say, is shut the froag up and just play games. 

OR HIT OUR Things Gamers Do SECTION



Latest comment by Ayane chan |view all 9 comments
I'm really impressed by this article. Great job Christina! It's really well-written and intelligent. Keep up the good work :)...





Nex's Avatar
Nex at 11/25/2006 06:13

I hate to say it, but I know why we post the pictures, because we do want the attention and we have no one but ourselves to blame when the gaming community treats us badly for it or fails to take us seriously.

One could blame a society that judges a female's worth almost entirely on her looks. One could blame Cosmopolitan magazine, or the E! Network or the Dallas Cowboy cheerleaders...


All these websites for female gamers, female gaming clans and everything else specifically for women gamers just shows the gaming community that we are special and that we want to be treated different from them, but guess what… we aren’t special any more.

Like this? http://4thegirlgamers.blogspot.com/


If you stopped complaining for one second and realized that gaming has never been about gender from the beginning

Really? How about this: http://kotaku.com/gaming/itagaki/dead-or-alive-xtreme-pole-dancing-217057.php
Christina Faith Winterburn's Avatar
Christina Faith Winterburn at 11/25/2006 11:28

Nex, if you actually read my post carefully you would have realised I've pretty much answered your points.

One: Society may be the cause of the people automatically judging women by their looks, but as a internet user, you have the choice to post your picture or not on a website or forum. Any woman who does post her picture on a site that over 3/4 of the readers don't unless there's a forum asking them to, she's looking for validation.

Two: I said in my post that I was one of the "Girl Gamers" in the beginning, hense for the name of my site and I can't change the name now since its in the web address.

Three: Pole dancing DOA Girls aside, I can still play the game and enjoy it, just like Summa can play Cooking Mama, a supposed girl game and still enjoy it.
Chris Taran's Avatar
Chris Taran at 11/25/2006 22:15

Faith, just wanted to say that I loved the article! I don't want to sound like I didn't like you in the past, but ever since you dropped the Naked and started being more of a gamer and not a "girl gamer" I've had a lot more respect for you.

blackacidevil's Avatar
blackacidevil at 11/26/2006 00:16

that was good. you werent just bitching, you were proving points and pointing out the wrongs. i dont mind games that have chick characters as long as im able to choose, just as the chicks would want to choose to be a chick character
i think to help out the chick gamers, us dudes need to start the male gaming groups saying we want fat, or pimply, or pasty, or gangly, or whatever male characters and need to make a game with those people to show how lame it is.
how lame would halo be if master chief had a pot belly and got winded running around?
and then if there were fat characters in games, other groups would complain saying that the game is promoting poor health choices. i dont know if there is any one, or more for that fact, solution that will fix games forever.
if the gender issue is ever fixed, race with be soon to follow
Zaron's Avatar
Zaron at 11/26/2006 04:27

I just wanted to echo what Chris T said, great article, and it's earned you a lot of respect in my eyes.
Xev's Avatar
Xev at 11/26/2006 06:05

Finally you see the light!.
Problem is girls like who you described make the real gamers all look like bimbos, and those that speak agaisnt these "girl gamers" were right away called ugly and told to shut up unless they post a bimbo photo.

Change thing's around faith, you have an audience and fans who will hear what you have to say. Make "us" gamers proud and happy. Give us articles that matter, less eyecandy and more content.

Teach the art of gamer camoflauge to the ditzy gamers. Work on something to be proud of.

and good for you for admiting your faults and changing, it takes a lot to do that.
Christina Faith Winterburn's Avatar
Christina Faith Winterburn at 11/26/2006 14:38

Even I can admit when I'm wrong, and I've realised it needs to be about the games and not about gender.
poopysocks's Avatar
poopysocks at 08/20/2007 13:59

First off, I loved this article. I think it brings up some really great points about how advertising tries to squeeze every last spot out of every last "demographic"(female gamers). But I still believe that you can create a genuine community for female gamers. For instance IGN.com has obviously made the decision to cater JUST to men. I think this has proven successful for them. I think if there is a female gaming community that is genuine, it can work. The hard part is getting one of these sites on the same scale as IGN or Gamespot.


So many girl gaming blogs. Not enough good communities for them. Thats a big problem.

So I agree with many points of that article, but I also think that woman would enjoy a genuinely rich online experience in which they share that with other woman gamers. Not just for the label of "girl gamer".
Ayane chan's Avatar
Ayane chan at 02/13/2008 02:08

I'm really impressed by this article. Great job Christina! It's really well-written and intelligent. Keep up the good work :)

You must be logged in to post a comment. Click here to login or create a user account now.

RELATED ARTICLES

The ten best videogame moms EVER!
84 comments

THQ: 'Girls have better things to do than videogames'
67 comments

May the best breast win: New screens of Soul Calibur IV full of smut and gravity
57 comments

Wait a minute, female gamers can have the same mindset as men!?
39 comments

EA announces Boogie for broads, Boogie SuperStar for Wii
4 comments

Get Dtoid E3 updates via email

Or subscribe to our E3 RSS

Post a new community blog
Call for entries:
A cast of thousands ... of polygons
Game with us: Friday Night Fights
Meet Dtoiders near you

DTOID CONTEST ALERTS
Destructoid/Blast Works level design contest UPDATE: Zycyzyx Returns
E3 08: Contest reminder - blog your brains out, win our swag
[UPDATE!] Overlord: Raising Hell contest winners announced!
Destructoid/Blastworks level design contest UPDATE: Enter Yoshi's Cave
Contest: Post your E3 impressions and reactions, win tons of our E3 Swag!
MORE CONTEST ALERTS


DESTRUCTOID ORIGINALS
Ten Golden Rules
If you disagree ... you are wrong. | Jim Sterling
Hey Ash, Whatcha Playin
Original video series | Anthony & Ashly Burch
The Great Retro Quiz
Test your retro brain | Chad Concelmo
Games Time Forgot
Great games of the past | Anthony Burch
Bargain Bin Laden
The best game bargains | Dtoid staff
The Memory Card
Amazing moments in games | Chad Concelmo
Indie Nation
Killer independent games | Anthony Burch
Friday Night Fights
Game with us online | Dtoid staff
An RPG draws near
Remembering great RPGs | Colette Bennett
You're the man now dog!
Epic game YTMND's | Hamza Aziz
Nerdcore Culture
Trends in gamer culture | Dtoid Staff
Debate to the death
May the best games win | Tom Fronczak
Monday mind teasers
Do you know your box art? | Tom Fronczak
Miniboss Monday
Celebrating minions | Mike Ferry
Art Attack Friday
The artists of gaming | Tiffany Chow
Best of the week
News from our network | Hamza Aziz
Weekend reading
Let it simmer | Brad Rice

     
Friday Night Fights: Farewell, E3 edition
E3 08: Left 4 Dead is frighteningly amazing
E3 08: Mortal Kombat vs. DC Universe is surprisingly solid
Kaz Hirai targeting 150 million PS3s sold
Friday Night Fights: Farewell, E3 edition
E3 08: Mortal Kombat vs. DC Universe is surprisingly solid
Destructoid/Blast Works level design contest UPDATE: Zycyzyx Returns
E3 08: Hands-on with de Blob
E3 08: SPRay interview with Tecmo
 
     
New Mega Man 9 trailer is RETROMAZING!
Best Wii game ever Captain Rainbow has a trailer!
Prediction: Captain Rainbow will be the greatest Wii game of all time!
DS: UK DS chargers could hurt you
PSP: Review scraps: Brave Story: New Traveler
PHONE: Freeverse invading the iPhone App store
Friday Night Fights: Farewell, E3 edition
E3 08: Left 4 Dead is frighteningly amazing
E3 08: Dragon Age: Origins demo footage
 
         
Contribute

Post a blog
Submit a news tip
This month's theme
Video game forums
Tech Support

Login issues
Community Blogs
Report abuse
Keep in touch

Subscribe via RSS
Dtoid Facebook group
Myspace page
Destructoid on Flickr
Game with us on Fridays
Meet Dtoiders near you
Seriously

Advertising
Privacy Policy
Terms of Use

Our software
Jobs - We're hiring!
Our Network

About Destructoid Japanator
Tomopop
Poprox
MiamiNights ModernMethod Publishing