Quantcast
What I love about the Thief series - Destructoid




Thief  




What I love about the Thief series photo
What I love about the Thief series

4:00 PM on 03.10.2013

Gimme the loot


I love Thief. If you follow me on Twitter, you may have seen me singing the series' praises as I played through Thief 1 & 2 late last year. Finally plunging into the defunct Looking Glass Studios' crowning achievement gave me much to talk about. Its art direction, level design, and mechanics ooze atmosphere, despite the low number of polygons that date the game's engine.

While Fraser Brown looked toward the future of the franchise, I'd like to take this opportunity to discuss Thief's past. With the reveal of Thief 4, I am unsure of what to expect but I do know what I love about the original games. These are also the things that I'd like to see Eidos Montreal embrace.

Handmade maps

Immersion can come from many things, but it doesn't often come from maps. Maps in games, especially in the Doom era, are pristine things composed of perfect lines that magically appear as the player explores. In Doom, everything except hidden items are displayed for the player. It serves as a tool in navigating the environment but one that often took the player out of it.

Thief, on the other hand, gave the player mingy, torn, and often illegible maps with incomplete info. You can imagine someone concealing these between their cheeks, handing the poo-ridden map to master thief Garret in a back alley. Thief is a game about being resourceful with what you have, and nowhere is this truer than the maps that left enemies, starting position, direction, and items to uncertainty.

There may be handwritten notes that will guide you, but maybe you can't read them. There may be a detailed section on one page, but you're not sure if you are near it. Thief 2 made this a bit easier, since it highlighted your position (but not direction). It'd be great if Thief 4 kept this unorthodox element but let players draw on their maps and add notes.

Abstract level design

Games have become more realistic, to the point that Thief's architecturally-challenged levels resemble Quake more than Half-Life. As exciting as it was to explore the city streets and taverns of Thief, it was the labyrinthine estates and caves that left the biggest impression on me. I worry this element may be lost in Thief 4, as abstract level design is no longer favored by critics and consumers who desire realism.

I'll never forget The Sword (mission) in Thief Gold; it's one of the most haunting, surreal levels I've ever come across in a videogame. It reminded me of the novel House of Leaves, in which homeowners find an abyss below their house that goes on and on. Sexual moans echo throughout the level and surprise traps lay behind certain doors, making the mansion an uncomfortable, threatening place to be.

If it were mapped out like a level from Dishonored or Deus Ex: Human Revolution, it wouldn't be the same. It wouldn't capture that romantic feeling of adventuring into the unknown with great uncertainty. It gave players a glimpse of what a game designed by Stanley Kubrick would be like.

Ambiance

Silence is hard to find, these days, even in games. Orchestras swell, indicating an incoming enemy, and rooms bustle with noise that make the environment feel more animated. But, in Thief, you'd only hear the patter of your footsteps, encouraging the player to crank the volume up in order to catch the echo of a distant guard -- only to jump out of the seat when one appears right behind Garrett.

Thief is a series with a great amount of style, between its steam punk setting to its gorgeously lit (for the time) locations. Developer Looking Glass exerted a great amount of restraint in the design of the game, creating a world that feels dangerous and all too real at times. While console titles offered more bombastic, cinematic adventures, Thief offered something much more personal and frightening.

Sandbox approach and environment

A thief is nothing without tools and Garrett has plenty of them. More so than even Deus Ex and System Shock, Thief is a series that gives the player a wealth of options in approach. The environment offers many alternative paths and Garrett's tools offer many different approaches to dealing with guards. A crafty player can use moss arrows to silently walk across metallic surfaces, while a more patient player may douse hallway torches with water arrows.

There is no better feeling then skipping an entire floor of troubles with a well-placed rope arrow that Garrett can shimmy up. I worry that Thief 4 may offer more aggressive approaches that will ruin the tone and pace of the original games which offered many approaches but all of which require stealth and careful planning. Approaching with a sword only gets you so far in Thief. Let's hope it remains this way.

High tension

Thief often feels like a survival horror game to me. You have the dimly lit, foreboding locales, item management, and most of all, nail-biting tension that comes from hiding inches away from enemies that can kill Garrett in two or three blows. By its very nature, Thief is a game best played with your fingers constantly hovering over the quick-save/quick-load buttons, as the repercussions for being caught can be drastic. Something that Eidos seeks to change, to my chagrin.

Due to a sense of tension that can become very unnerving over time, there is nothing all that pleasant about playing Thief. The player doesn't unlock abilities or increase stats; there is never an advantage beyond becoming more cunning and aware. The onus is on the player to adapt and improve, slowing down the pace of their steps and always looking for hidden passages. It's something that games just don't do anymore, and I don't think Thief 4 will buck this trend.








Comments not appearing? Anti-virus apps like Avast or some browser extensions can cause this.
Easy fix: Add   [*].disqus.com   to your software's white list. Tada! Happy comments time again.

Did you know? You can now get daily or weekly email notifications when humans reply to your comments.





timeline following:
Thief



4:45 PM on 07.09.2014
The people behind the Hitman movie want to make a Thief movie

Prime Universe, the minds behind 2007's Hitman movie adaptation, has their eyes on a movie based on Thief. Adrian Askarieh and Roy Lee are behind the project as producers. Askarieh is also working on a Kane & Lynch adapta...more



7:00 AM on 03.05.2014
Now that Thief is out, Eidos Montreal lays off 27 people

AAA development works, the large studio tells you. "Yes it is true we've let 27 people go today," its press release reads as you imagine it dabbing crocodile tears with a fan of c-notes. "Unfortunately it's something that ev...more



7:00 PM on 03.04.2014
PC Port Report: Thief

The Thief series began on the PC, and it's one of those games that old people like me say has its spiritual home there. So it's no surprise that the new Thief reboot/remake would come under scrutiny as to how well it performs...more



8:00 AM on 02.24.2014
Review: Thief

The original Thief was one of my favorite PC games of all time. It was unique in that it completely focused on stealth -- a mechanic that wasn't used often at the time outside of a few select games like the original...more



12:00 PM on 02.20.2014
Watch what Thief is all about in this new launch trailer

Thief is almost here, and you can get a glimpse of a bit of gameplay (but not much) from its launch trailer above. As expected, there's tons of looting, sneaking, and swooping, compliments of the master thief and hero o...more



4:15 PM on 02.18.2014
Not this again: Thief is 900p on Xbox One, 1080p on PS4

Just yesterday we learned that yet another Xbox One game is going to have a lower resolution than its PS4 counterpart, and here we are again with Thief. Square Enix has recently noted that Thief will run at 1080p on the ...more



2:45 PM on 02.18.2014
Steal everything in sight in this Thief gameplay video

There doesn't seem to be any doubt about it, Thief will certainly live up to its namesake. In this 17-minute video that shows the game's first mission, Garrett gets his klepto on and does his best magpie impression, as ...more



11:30 AM on 02.04.2014
New Thief video teaches how to steal in style

The title of this Thief video calls it a trailer, but I'd be hard-pressed to classify it as such. Not many trailers run six minutes, but whatever this is, it remains interesting the whole time. I guess badass thievery a...more



4:30 PM on 01.27.2014
Let's look at the customization options for Thief on PS4

We already knew that the upcoming reboot of Thief was going to have lots of customization on PC, but it's good to see the PlayStation 4 (and presumably all console versions) will have those options too. From the start of the...more



8:00 AM on 01.24.2014
Preview: The first four hours of Thief

Back in October, I got the chance to sit down to chat with members of Eidos Montreal after a lengthy session with the new entry in the Thief series. Since the reveal in 2009, the game has gone through many different iteration...more




Action

11:00 AM on 09.02.2014
God Eater 2: Rage Burst coming to PS4 and Vita

Namco Bandai announced a touched up God Eater 2, God Eater 2: Rage Burst will be coming to PlayStation 4 and Vita in Japan.  God Eater 2 came to PSP and Vita last year in Japan. Yes, PSP. It was also insinuated that the franchise would continue, perhaps with a proper God Eater 3 down the line. more



8:00 AM on 09.02.2014
Persona, Dragon Quest, Gundam, Disgaea, Bloodborne -- Sony's whole pre-TGS conference

Sony Japan's pre-TGS press conference took place in the wee hours of Sunday night in North America. In case you missed it, the entire conference, where we saw our first trailer for Persona 5, is up on YouTube. There was a gr...more



5:09 AM on 09.01.2014
Bladestorm PS4 and Way of the Samurai Vita trailers

A lot of sort of random games headlined Sony's pre-TGS conference.  As we previously reported, Bladestorm: The Hundred Years' War (PS3, 360), from Koei and Dynasty Warriors developer Omega Force, is getti...more



View all Action






Back to Top




All content is yours to recycle through our Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing requiring attribution. Our communities are obsessed with videoGames, movies, anime, and toys.

Living the dream since March 16, 2006

Advertising on destructoid is available: Please contact them to learn more