Are you using the standard box art for BioShock Infinite, the reversible Songbird cover, or something else entirely? Developer Irrational Games has provided even more custom covers should you want to go the latter route, and I must say, the one shown above stands out to me like none of the others have been able to.
At this page, you'll find the covers that did not garner enough votes to win as well as some bonus box art. See any you like? "Elizabeth 2" is a strong second for me, though I don't know if I'd go to the trouble of printing cover art unless I was prepared to do it for most of my game library.
Download Your Alternate Covers Today [Irrational Games -- Thanks, JohnnyViral]