GAMESREVIEWS
Rising (10+)
Notable (20+)
Popular (30+)
Promoted (Front Paged!)
People you followTaggedGeneral - Opinion/EditorialCommunity ReviewsOff-topicCommunity PodcastersBloggers Wanted ResponseLetters to Dtoids EditorsGet InvolvedGeneral BadassnessJoin a Live Stream EventListen to CommunitoidJoin a Playdate EventCompete in a Contest
The Visual Effects of Portal: No Escape
You probably didn't notice Jonathan Skabla's name amid the slew of credits at the end of Portal: No Escape, the recently released short by Dan Trachtenberg of The Totally Rad Show. He might be a faceless animator to you, but to me he’s my best pal. He's the guy who’d greet me on Tuesday afternoon with a beer and a copy of Streets of Rage 2. For starters: what's your background in the industry? I have been desktop compositing for 6 years. I have worked in storyboarding, test commercials, full-up commercials, short films, and recently the feature film Tower Heist, directed by Bret Ratner. I worked as an assistant art director in commercial preproduction for over 2 years before I started branching off into shorts, full-up commercials and feature film work.
And how did you get involved in this project? A very good friend of mine, Cesar Kuriyama, saw one of my posts on Facebook one day in May complaining about how I was having a hard time finding more freelance work. He contacted me and asked me if I would be interested in working on a really awesome short, pro bono, since I had free time. He could not continue on the short because he was asked to give a TED Talk and needed the time to prepare. I told him yes, and he handed off some shots he had just started to me, and the director gave some other ones that I started from scratch. How closely did you work with the project leads? I worked very closely with Dan and Jon even though I am NYC based and they are in LA. I got on several calls with Dan Trachtenberg throughout the project and I spoke to Jon Chesson almost daily via GChat. During a phone call, Dan and I discovered we had met many times before and never realized it. We both attended college in Philadelphia. I went to the University of the Arts and he went to Temple University. During his time there he was working in their 16mm film developing room. I used to walk down there all the time to develop my Kodak film. He’d taken over running things after the previous manager left to work at my school. Small world! ![]() What were your duties on the film? I composited 7 shots. Shot 5 (she looks at the barrel and blue light illuminates her face), 8 (she turns to camera with amber portals behind her), 8a (she turns to camera with blue portals behind her), 11 (we see her from behind as she runs into the amber portal), 12 (short shot after the door opens when she falls to the ground), 12a (she is on the ground, fires the portal above the guard and kicks the cot so it falls onto the guard), and 20 (when she first runs out onto the rooftop) What moments are you particularly proud of? Shot 5 and and Shot 12a are my favorites because the blue light cast by the gun was entirely created by me. In shot 5 it was a combination of hand animated paintings that were tracked onto her face, and screened on, and isolating her highlights and tinting them blue. I also used a 3D version of the gun built by someone else on the team to add additional lighting to the gun as well. Shot 12a was strictly isolating the highlights on her skin, and parts of the background wall and tinting them blue. What are the differences between working on a personal project like this versus a big budget picture? Well first of all on a big budget film you are all in the same building! We were all spread out across the country. Dan and Jon were in LA along with other team members, and myself and a few others were NYC based, and I believe our CG guy was in Connecticut. Other than that we all have worked on big budget projects and films, so we know what to do and how to do it. What's your schedule like when working on a project? How long does the average FX shot take to construct? Is there a significant difference between animating a teleportation portal and painting a movie star's reflection out of a window? Well, I created the inside look of the portal but the main particle system used for the ring was made by Paul Griswold. I made some supplementary particle systems to suit my needs (like fly off particles, some dripping particles, and a few loose wispy ones) but all the rings were created by him. As far as how long it took to composite: it was all after hours work. We all have day jobs, so we would pick up work on Portal after we got home. A slap comp takes about a day. Then revisions and sweetening, probably three or four days per shot. With something like painting a reflection out of a window: that’s all about tracking, and just cloning, and copying preexisting pieces over the undesired reflections. In a scene like shot 8 or 8a in Portal, we were adding 3D elements that do not belong. So color correcting, adding light FX, and camera distortions/blurs to really sell it takes longer to do. ![]() Are films where you're gonna stay, or do you have aspirations in games too? What sort of advice can you give to the up and coming artist? I have worked my way up from preproduction to films and that is where I'd love to stay. My advice is never lose sight of your goals and focus on your weaknesses. If you can't make them strengths at least remove them. When I first moved from Philadelphia to New York City I knew I was only going to work in test commercials for a short time. Then I was going to move on. Despite this particular companies best efforts to keep me, I left when I planned to leave. I taught myself the programs I needed to know, studied every second I could (still taking Nuke classes even today) and made lots of friends with people who knew them better! This way I could ask them lots of questions! Also, FXPHD, and Video Copilot are your best friends! So basically: work your ass off, make lots of friends, be willing to wade through shit when necessary. Exactly. You are never too good for a project. Ever. Now, if you’ll permit me to sass you: did you actually PLAY portal? No. A long time ago when I worked as an assistant editor, I watched an editor, Rob Aiello, beat the first one (he has no relation to Danny Aiello. I think I have asked him that over a thousand times). The song at the ending credits always made me laugh. Knowing your internet habits (or lack thereof), you’re probably the only person in the world who doesn’t know how big of a meme that song became. Alright then, when you're not working, what games keep you busy these days? My heart belongs to Survival Horror (Silent Hill, Resident Evil, Dead Rising, Alan Wake) however I find myself playing a lot of Fallout 3 and Fallout: New Vegas. I have been known to also play games that no one in their right mind will play (Kingdom Under Fire: Circle of Doom, Deadly Premonition, God Hand, Alone in the Dark) Some people might take umbrage to you calling some of those games bad! If I can scrape together fifty bucks will you start production on a God Hand feature film starring me? Ha. Well I am not a Director, nor am I a DP. So if you can find them, a camera man, a camera, get a set crew, find somewhere to shoot, and figure out whose going to do the DI then sure. I’ll comp it. ![]() What's next on the block? I know Hollywood brings in the big bucks, but don't abandon game-related films right after you've started! I am most definitely not! I would rather like to make a Fallout short. I talked to Jon and Dan about it but with everything going on like it is with Portal I think it will be a long while before we can actually sit down and have a proper conversation. I also told them whatever short they move onto from here that I would love to be a part of. My pipe dream is someday when I get much more established and I get the right plot going I'd love to write a script for a Silent Hill movie. I know I already promised fifty bucks to Godhand, but I’m willing to go as high as sixty for any Silent Hill script better than Silent Hill: Origins or Homecoming. That won’t be a problem. Well, thanks for talking about the film! And tell Dan and Jon and the rest of the team that we thank all of from the bottom of our hearts. I will! They will love to hear it I promise you! Did you know? You can now get daily or weekly email notifications when humans reply to your comments.
Legacy Comments (will be imported soon)Good read and great job on the film. I'm sure you'll find plenty of people here who play Deadly Premonition and God Hand. Also, sorry to hear you've had to work with Brett Ratner. Skabla did a really great job with the effects, I recall being impressed as I watched the short too. 11:00 AM on 05.15.2013 Sonic is a pirate! Covers for Sonic Universe #55As much as it pains me to say, Sonic and Mega Man's fun times together in "Worlds Collide" won't last forever. But hopefully enough new readers will be ready and willing to stick around for what lies ahead for both heroes. Th...
8:00 PM on 05.14.2013 Sid Meier says core gamers should not be forgottenSid Meier is a legend to PC gamers for strategy games he lent his name to but the man himself admits that the Meier name doesn't mean much to mobile players. In an illuminating interview with GamesIndustry, Sid revealed his n...
12:00 PM on 05.10.2013 How the new Disrupt engine gives life to Watch DogsWatch Dogs is giving us a huge open world full of life, all alongside some innovative new multiplayer concepts. And it's all thanks to the new Disrupt engine. The team had some grand visions they wanted to pull off when they ...
1:00 PM on 05.08.2013 Archie's Mega Man hits the 25-issue milestone!While Capcom continues to laze on announcing any proper plans for Mega Man, Archie Comics has been propping up the Blue Bomber as an important pillar of its comic book empire. Now with the arrival of issue #25 on newsstands t...
10:00 PM on 05.03.2013 Two new games from Krunch devs: Binge and Chihuahua LibreLast Sunday's Sup Holmes (now on iTunes) was slightly intoxicated foray into the mind of two tattooed barbarian warriors who just happen to make videogames. Though I don't get the sense that Vieko Franetovic ...
7:00 PM on 04.29.2013 Founder Andrew Tsai on the future of PCGamingWikiWhen it launched last year, the PCGamingWiki attempted to solve those technical headaches that can still blight some PC releases. As the current console generation grew longer and longer, the PC had a resurgence as a gaming p...
4:00 PM on 04.29.2013 This is not an article about David CageThe first twelve paragraphs are about David Cage. AKA David De Gruttola. AKA Composer-turned-game designer. AKA Founder of French developer Quantic Dream, responsible for excellent implementation of David Bowie (see: Omikron)...
2:30 PM on 04.28.2013 Sup Holmes crunches and shrugs with LeGrudge and RuggedThis week on Sup Holmes we welcome Mike and Vieko of LeGrudge and Rugged, creators of recent indie hit Krunch. We'll be talking to them about what it took to create Krunch (their first game), if the industry is entering ...
8:00 PM on 04.22.2013 PixelJunk Inc. is a game about soup and friendshipIn case you aren't aware, PixelJunk Inc. looks to be the raddest game ever. Imagine Castlevania, Metal Slug, Pikmin, and a tower defense all rolled into one. Also, soup everywhere. Naturally, when I got the opportunity to ta...
10:30 AM on 04.21.2013 Sup Holmes mates for life with WayForward's Tomm HulettTomm Hulett started working in the game industry at age 12, play testing for Virgin Interactive. Since then he has headed up his own studio, worked on games like Persona and River City Ransom for Atlus, Contra and Silent Hill...
| timeline following: |
| 7:00 AM on 04.30.2013 Behold, Portal 2's freakish Frankenturret brought to life |

The Frankenturret, as they're officially called, are the Portal 2 turrets merged with a weighted storage cube. Wheatley had fun creating them in the game, and I'm sure artist corroder666 had fun making the Frakenturret in re...more
| 6:00 PM on 11.01.2012 Portal 2 In Motion DLC arrives on PSN next week |

As announced on the PlayStation Blog, the In Motion content for Portal 2 that was originally playable using the Razer Hydra motion controller will be releasing on PlayStation Network this Tuesday, November 6. You might recall...more
| 4:30 PM on 10.22.2012 Steam Workshop's one-year anniversary has arrived! |

In one year's time, what started off as an easier way for players to access new user-created content for Team Fortress 2 has grown to encompass more than just sweet hats and guns, with a touch of J.C. Leyendecker or...more
| 9:00 PM on 08.16.2012 Valve update adds co-op puzzles to Portal 2 level creator |

Aperture Science's "Perpetual Testing Initiative" has just undergone a major expansion. An update for Portal 2 released today which allows users to now create puzzles requiring cooperative play to add to the more than 17...more
| 10:00 PM on 06.20.2012 Valve brings Portal 2 to schools via 'Teach with Portals' |

Thanks to Valve's newly released education program "Teach with Portals", schools will now have the opportunity to teach their students through Portal 2. No, really. Valve has taken Portal 2's recently released Perpetual ...more
| 5:22 PM on 06.05.2012 E3: 'Portal 2 in Motion' DLC supports PlayStation Move |

Portal 2's latest DLC installment, "Portal 2 In Motion," is being shown on the E3 show floor today. It includes the same levels from the DLC for the Razor Hydra controller and offers players a more tactile experienc...more
| 2:00 AM on 05.11.2012 Portal 2 Perpetual Initiative serves 1.3 million tests |

Released just this week, the Perpetual Testing Initiative expansion to Portal 2 has already resulted in a success of some kind. No, no. Don't tell me. I'll figure out the appropriate adjective eventually. More than 35,0...more
| 11:00 PM on 05.08.2012 A message to all Aperture employees from Boss Man Johnson |

Mr. Cave Johnson, CEO of Aperture Science, recently issued a message to all his employees, confirming the existence of the Perpetual Testing Initiative (PeTI), and its status being operational as of now. In the message, rath...more
| 2:30 PM on 04.26.2012 Valve to release Portal 2 level editor May 8 |

Starting next month, the possibilities for portal puzzles become as infinite as spaaaaaaaaace. Valve has announced a new update for Portal 2 which will arrive on May 8. The "Perpetual Testing Initiative" will give player...more
| 3:30 PM on 04.02.2012 Chell yeah! Dark Horse announces Portal 2 art book |

It's time for some more Portal for your porthole! Yeah I don't know what that means either. What I do know is that Dark Horse Comics, the folks behind the Mass Effect graphic novel series and others, have just announced their...more
| 7:00 PM on 05.09.2013 The cover art for Dragon's Crown is decidedly safe |
George Kamitani's female character designs for Dragon's Crown have received a rather surprising amount of attention -- that's ... that's still going on, isn't it? -- but at least for the game's box art, the presentation is fa...more
| 12:45 PM on 05.08.2013 The original 151 Pokemon as imagined by 151 artists |
Peter Le and Amy Kim thought it would be cool if they got 151 different artists to each take on one of the first-generation Pokémon, and present the collection in an art gallery called Rare Candy. Then they decided to ...more
| 12:30 PM on 05.07.2013 Streets of Rage, ESWAT art for reboots that never were |
Backbone Entertainment once pitched a reboot of Streets of Rage to SEGA, which SEGA apparently rejected, because SEGA hates everybody. Artist Arvin Bautista is keeping the dream alive, however, by sharing concept art cre...more


surf dtoid with 