Quantcast
The Question: Is it time to retire the term 'RPG'? - Destructoid

DestructoidJapanatorTomopopFlixist



The Question: Is it time to retire the term 'RPG'?


4:00 PM on 10.27.2012
The Question: Is it time to retire the term 'RPG'? photo



[Every Friday (or whenever), Destructoid will pose topical a question to the community. Answer it if you want!]

Semantics! As someone that writes and speaks for an audience of thousands on a regular basis, I spend more time thinking about semantics than your average bear. In my time here at Destructoid, I've learned time and time again that the difference between being understood and leaving your readers feeling mislead or confused can lie in the tiniest of details. This issue comes up a lot in the discussion of videogames. With a medium that is constantly growing and changing, it can be hard for conventional language to keep up.

For example, when the term "Role Playing Game" was first introduced to the world of videogames, it was meant to define a genre that serves to simulate the experience of playing Dungeons and Dragons. Turn based combat, character creation, experience point collection, and dungeon crawling were all prerequisites. Back then, it didn't matter if you were talking about something like A Bard's Tale, Final Fantasy, Ultima, or Dragon Warrior/Quest, when you heard that a game was an RPG, you knew almost exactly what to expect.

The same can't be said today. Due to changes in game design allowed by modern technology, the term RPG could mean almost anything. Some think that an RPG is any game that focuses "playing a role" among a group of characters in an adventure story. Others think it's any game that involves exploring a large fantasy setting. Still others think it's any game that involves building up your stats by collecting some form of in-game currency and/or equipment.

Over the years, I've heard everything from Mass Effect 3 (a story-focused third person shooter), Rage (a non-story focused first person shooter), The Last Story (a story-focused third person hack and slash with third person shooter elements) and The Denpa Men (a non-story focused, turn-based, third person dungeon crawler) referred to as a "RPG", though these games have very little in common.

Whew! What a mouthful! Can't we find a more succinct way to categories the games we play? 

Seeing as "RPG" can be tacked on to so many types of games, maybe it make more sense to only use the term as an adjective and not as a genre. Stating that a game has "RPG elements" clearly expresses that it has some form of stat-building system, without making promises about what the player is going to do or how they are going to feel while playing. Still, wouldn't it be less misleading to just say a game has "SBE" (stat-building elements) than to shackle it to a term that carries so many other potential associations? In a world where everything from  Dead Rising to Call of Duty to Farmville involves stat building in one form or another, the term "RPG" feels like it could do more harm than good. It's a relic of a bygone era, one that simultaneously means too much and too little, depending on who you ask.

So that's my perspective. What's yours? Do you think the term "RPG" still has worth, or are there ways to express the same idea that have less potential for misunderstanding?

 






Comments not appearing? Anti-virus apps like Avast or some browser extensions can cause this.
Easy fix: Add   [*].disqus.com   to your software's white list. Tada! Happy comments time again.

Did you know? You can now get daily or weekly email notifications when humans reply to your comments.



Radio Dtoid 042: Nice Hot Mike photo
Radio Dtoid 042: Nice Hot Mike
5:15 PM on 07.28.2014







Win your choice of console from Destructoid! in Destructoid's Hangs on LockerDome

Role-Playing Games

9:30 AM on 07.30.2014
Shin Megami Tensei IV hits Europe in September

Shin Megami Tensei IV will be summoned to Europe this September, Atlus announced today. The role-playing game will retail for €19.99/£17.99 via the Nintendo 3DS eShop. Atlus notes all the downloadable content will ...more



6:00 PM on 07.29.2014
So the Confederate Express developers might just be scumbags

Covering Kickstarter campaigns can be tricky business. Between conflicts of interest, the nature of crowdfunding, and the potential for scams, a lot can go wrong when an outlet like Destructoid highlights a particular campaig...more



4:30 PM on 07.29.2014
Dragon Age: Inquisition combat makes me want to play Final Fantasy XII

Let's be fair, a lot of seemingly arbitrary things make me want to replay Final Fantasy XII. A lack of time coupled with a naive hope for an HD re-release always keep me from doing so, leaving me in a perpetual state of want...more



View all Role-Playing Games






Back to Top




All content is yours to recycle through our Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing requiring attribution. Our communities are obsessed with videoGames, movies, anime, and toys.

Living the dream since March 16, 2006

Advertising on destructoid is available: Please contact them to learn more