The battle rages on: Activision speaks out about PS3 Rock Band patch

Comment with Facebook

Comment with Dtoid

destructoid japanator | tomopop

Destructoid is gaming news, community, videos, and sometimes love. Take the tour or jump in with Facebook:

big news
rumors
originals
releases
reviews
previews
podcasts

faq

Home Guitar Hero

9:59 PM on 12.13.2007, Nick Chester

54 comments | 7791 views

The battle rages on: Activision speaks out about PS3 Rock Band patch photo

#Activision #Guitar Hero #PS3 #Rock Band

When Harmonix finally came out about word that Activision had been blocking attempts to allow the PS3 Guitar Hero III peripheral to work with Rock Band, we knew it wouldn't be long before Activision were ready to comment. (They didn't respond to our initial contact regarding the rumor.)

According to Activision, there are always two sides to a story, and this is theirs:

To Music Gaming Fans:

The recent announcement by MTV Games/Viacom’s Harmonix division that Activision is blocking Sony from releasing a patch and their plea to enable Rock Band software to work with Guitar Hero hardware paints a very misleading picture.

In fact, Harmonix and its parent company MTV Games/Viacom recently declined Activision’s offer to reach an agreement that would allow the use of Guitar Hero guitar controllers with Rock Band. We have been and remain open to discussions with Harmonix and MTV Games/Viacom about the use of our technology in Rock Band. Unfortunately for Rock Band users, in this case Harmonix and MTV Games/Viacom are unwilling to discuss an agreement with Activision.

Activision’s top priority is to provide consumers with a seamless marriage of best-in-class hardware and software. We are focusing our efforts on innovating hardware and software that are designed to work together, work flawlessly and provide an enjoyable gaming experience.

Best regards,

Activision

So who's right? Who knows, but you can bet we'll be reaching Harmonix for comment. In the meantime, pull up a seat and grab some popcorn -- things look like they're about to heat up.

Continue: More Rock Band stories

'Violin Hero' string metal music video blows minds
18 comments

February Guitar Hero DLC brings Sabbath and more
30 comments

Harmonix: Music games haven't peaked
24 comments

CES 2010: Rock out with your stage monitor speaker out
9 comments

next 50 comments

51 comments | showing # 1 to 50

BFeld13

Oh snap! It's been brought!

vexed alex

So basically, "Harmonix and EA are unwilling to give us a fuck ton of money to allow for us to let them patch the game."

WDot

Wow, this is just bizarre. "They won't let us release the patch!" "Nuh UHH, they won't let us let them... release... the patch."

odintal

the conversation in my mind:

harmonix: we'd like your guitar to work on our game

activision: we'd like your drums to work on our future games

harmonix: thats kind of our thing dude

activision: fornicate yourself with a metal pole

saysay

I like this move by activision. Their PR group and Legal reps are clever ;P Using the word "agreement" so vaguely and discreetly you cant even feel it!

ExpertPenguin

Activision's bullshitting everyone. I'll call it, because it isn't the first time they've pulled this.

They started with Guitar Hero 2 on the PS2, locking out all "unofficial" prehipherals (i.e. buy our guitar if you want to play the game), and they're doing it again, which is why nothing but the Les Paul works on GH3.

What I don't understand however, is why they wouldn't want PS3 owners to use their guitar in a rival game, and have it work only on the PS3 It makes little sense from where I'm standing, since Actvision could stand to actually sell more guitars in that fashion.

They couldn't pull it on the 360 due to a specific guitar controller standard that has to be adhered to across the board. the most they could do was a software lockout, which is why the Fenders don't work in GH3.

However, this just screams of a dick move on Activision's part. I find it hard to find fault with Harmonix on this, because sales of the PS3 version are suffering as a result of it. Every store I go to, I see stacks of the PS3 version, and no 360 ones in sight. If anything, they would WANT this patch to get out as soon as possible, since with this lockout in place, it doesn't even make sense to buy a standalone copy of the game.

saysay

I like this move by activision. Their PR group and Legal reps are clever ;P Using the word "agreement" so vaguely and discreetly you cant even feel it!

fluc02

Do they really think anyone is too much of a dumbass to read through the lines of this statement and recognize that "agreement" means "shitton of cash?" Another example of Activision shitting on their customers.

Peronthious

Of course, Activision is trying to come out making themselves the good guys, but what exactly the proposed deal with MTV entails is anybody's guess. It likely involved large amounts of cash monies and/or Viacom granting Activion access to some of their music portfolio.

Mxyzptlk

So now Activision is evil and EA is good? Sounds to me like both sides are being stubborn assholes about this whole thing.

Robert

This is the old "I know you are but what am I?" comeback that I haven't heard since 3rd grade! Ahh!

Wedge

Errr no, it sounds like Activision wants money to let their guitar work on the game. This statement kind of confirms that.

slapme7times

ah... lunacy inducing anxiety over accepting blame over this consumer fuck-a-long.

=) how fun!

emotaku

"It's not us! It's them!"

jeep

wow...i do believe that everybody has beat me to the punch in saying that the use of Activisions guitar will cost Harmonix either in the short or the long run...kudos to all those who can cut through the bs with a knife

iliketuna

If only Harmonix agreed to bend over so we can stick these guitars up their asses...

Joe Burling

No matter what happens, Rock Band > Guitar Hero 3

Corak

Manufacturing doubt, what good pr reps do when bad news comes to the company they work for.

Baron Calico

Question for comment-crawlers. Since it seems like a few greenbacks are gonna be required to make this whole stupid thing work, who here would be willing to fork over a buck or two for the patch?

Just wondering. Personally, I'm not sure if I would be willing to if it came to that. Cheaper than buying another guitar, certainly, but the principle of the thing...

Cdewarior

Translation: Activision wants EA/MTV/Harmonix to pay them for the right to make guitar hero guitars usable with harmonix games. EA/MTV/Harmonix is balking at this.

BetaMax/VCR - BlueRay/HD-DVD - Rock and Roll Edition!

Fading Star

:(.

jackdoe

Activision probably wants licencing fees from EA for using their guitar.

Samit Sarkar

This is a sad ploy on Activision�s part to regain trust from their consumers � trust that was lost when Harmonix gave their side of the patch story. I�m inclined to believe Harmonix if they said they already had the damn patch complete and sent to Sony, and that Activision involved their lawyers in stopping the release of the patch. Go to hell, Activision � I should�ve figured you�d let the title of �#1 publisher� go to your heads.

Kinjiro

You have to realize that Activision dedicated a lot of time and money into researching and developing their guitar. Another game company going "Sooo, yeah, we're just gonna take that from you, and let people play our game that is in direct competition with yours, with your peripheral. Don't even think about the fact that we pretty much took your game exactly, made a guitar that has this nasty tendency of failing, and that our guitar isn't compatible with your game either."

I kind of agree with Activision here. A lot of people would buy guitar hero controllers to play rock band, helping rock band gain popularity, with the possibility of detracting from future guitar hero popularity. They are well within their right to do this. If Harmonix is going to charge $200 for their game, they have to expect that it'll hurt sales. It is a financially sound decision to at least ask for monetary reciprocation for essentially giving Harmonix more sales.

It may hurt Activision's popularity by blocking the patch, but only for people who play rock band. This further polarizes the market. I'm willing to bed everybody that opposes this owns rock band, or wants to own it. Thus, Activision is helping to maintain market dominance, despite the fact that they will probably lose customers because of this. It is basically both companies trying to protect an investment.

ironic_name

How can Activision say, "use of our technology". Didn't Harmonix make this shit up?

Kinjiro

but it's attached to the guitar hero franchise, which harmonix left, right?

wouldn't that give activision sole rights and control of the peripheral?

i might be wrong, that was all opinion anyway

Mxyzptlk

The fact is all we're really hearing from both sides is spin... we don't know the real details of why this patch is being delayed, if it has anything to do with money or not.

The reason it doesn't work in the first place is because Harmonix didn't share any technical information with Neversoft regarding the PS3 Guitar controller. If they had, there would have been no need for a patch in the first place. Think about this a second before jumping to conclusions. If this is just a cashwhore money grab, then why does Activision have no problem with the controller being supported in the 360 version? Just because Harmonix bitched first doesn't necessarily mean they're in the right.

Kinjiro

ok, i didn't know that

and thus the pertinency lifespan of my post was only forty five minutes

konchu

Its ones word against the other but I suspect Activision/Red Octane want compensation for using there perphial. This whole thing is silly.

Mxyzptlk

I should have phrased it "Harmonix & Neversoft didn't share any technical information with each other". Btw, I can't find any solid information on this, but does the Rock Band controller on PS3 work with Guitar Hero 3?

Wedge

No the PS3 RB controller does not work on GH III. It was already stated that the GH III controller works on RB for 360 because Microsoft has standards for their controllers they both had to conform to. The RB controller would work on GH III for 360 as well, but GH III is coded specifically to NOT let it work.

There isn't an "spin" from both sides, this is all on Activision being douches. The fact they talk about having made an "offer" is ridiculous, because there shouldn't be any need for such a thing in the first place.

Necros

Wedge has the full story right. Activision needs to realize that it shouldn't take a fuckload of money to help out the poor consumer.

Mxyzptlk

@ Wedge: If there's solid evidence that this is all Activision's fault, please share it. Right now all we have to go on is the various forum posts/press releases from either side, and speculation from the internet masses. It looks to me like both parties are being douches about this whole thing, but everyone seems ready to suck Harmonix's cock and tell them it tastes like candy when nobody knows the actual details.

Mxyzptlk

It also can be reasoned that Activision stands to lose money by not allowing GH3 controllers to work with Rock Band. Since there's no way for Rock Band players to get a 2nd guitar outside the bundle, the most obvious option is to buy a GH3 guitar. Blocking that potential revenue source doesn't make sense, there has to be more to this.

The Microsoft standards thing doesn't make any sense to me. The reason GH controllers work with RB on the 360 is because the peripheral already was released and Harmonix was familiar with it from GH2. There was no prior PS3 GH control they could reference. Why RB controllers don't work with GH3 could be explained as Neversoft not being given access to the tech specs of the new guitars (which came out after GH3 was released), hence not being able to support them. Why didn't MS force Harmonix to share that information to ensure compatibility if there are such standards in place?

JtheYellow

The unobvious option is to get a GH2 rig, but that's only an option for Xbox 360 users who don't mind having a Explorer model instead of a Les Paul.

Harmonix/MTV are the ones trying for new IP here. Activision is the one trying to push the existing IP that Harmonix got started, they've been out a month longer than Rock Band and have a smaller price point overall.

But I fucking called this. Everyone thought this was going to be sooooo copacetic.

Syn

That's lame, they didn't even explain anything, they just said "No u!" and left it at that. They aren't making themselves look very good.

PraiseChaos

I've seen in several places that Harmonix wants to have an open-standard for these controllers. If Harmonix has set forth an open-standard for guitar controllers, how exactly does that make them unwilling to cooperate? That's why I have a problem with Activision's response.

Personally, it really irritates me that I can't use my Rock Band controller on my 360 version of GH3. I can't imagine how angry PS3 owners are over this.

That final paragraph from Activision is so full of fail that it reminds me of my ex-girlfriend. Truly Epic.

Mxyzptlk

If I'm not mistaken, the "shoddy hardware" statement was in regards to Activision not making it a priority to patch GH3 to work with Rock Band guitars, not the other way around.

cryocide

Money, its a crime.
Share it fairly but don't take a slice of my pie.
Money, so they say
Is the root of all evil today.
But if you ask for a raise its no surprise that they're
Giving none away.

DeusPayne

"Agreement"? You mean they didn't give you all the money you wanted? Fuck off activision. Harmonix rules you. And not just because they're based in my state.

snapperdragon

Hmm, here is my take:

First, RedOctane wanted to sell guitar peripherals. Got Harmonix to make the GH game. Sold games and guitars.

Now Activision is selling the game and guitar. IF, and that is *IF* the periperal makes money, why whould Activision NOT want to have as many sold as possible? No need for additional fees, unless they are just being scrooges.

The only other thing is that they know EA/Harmonix are behind the 8 ball since they don't have separate guitars for sale. Knowing this, they must figure it should cost them to get out of the jam.

These two are competitors, so they want to stick it to EA/Harmonix with additional fees for using their controllers, even though they may $$ regardless of who buys the LP guitars.

GREED!

bubuli

wow. cleverly worded.

they didn't even address the fact that THEY BLOCKED THE PATCH.

why? because Activision WANT MOAR MONIES (licensing fees) for using their guitar on their game.

i hates dem. I'm definitely NOT buying any GH games until they come clean about this issue.

Drunken Haze

"recently declined Activision�s offer to reach an agreement"

Replace reach an agreement with GIVE US CASH

Rancor

Also as to the fender on gh3 issue, in windows they both work exactly the same, each button works with the exact same function in each guitar, so both vresions of gh are specifically blocking the fender. Harmonix said in a statement that they wouldn't work in gh3 because they "weren't there" for development, although they were for gh2. I am inclined to agree with odintal about the drum/mic thing activision probably wants. Also rock band is really kicking gh's ass with downloads. Cheaper, with more options to play, and alot more regular. Although im still waiting for the full album's and ea hasnt said a thing about them yet. Also they should make it so you can have songs just be played by the computer like a concert mode where you pick the chars and venue. . ., or maybe its just My fantasy to have a hendrix, mercury, flea, meg white super band doing david bowie covers?

Tull

Welcome to the Thunderdome! Two devs enter...one dev leaves!

Holyetheline

If both sources aim for the same goal they'll reach it some day.

loki d20

I would love to hear the specifics of this agreement that Activision said was declined. And, this in no way negates what Harmonix says since the agreement they presented could have easily have been ridiculous in its requirements that it was seen as a blocking method.

I don't see why there's an issue with allowing controllers for use in any other game. If people like your controller enough, they'll buy it, which means money in your pocket. If RB people want to buy your guitar for use in Harmonix's game, that can only be a good thing.

This just doesn't make any sense. May be their holding out until the Holiday season is over, thinking they can get more people upset over Rock Band since a lot of the ones purchased haven't been opened yet (they're gifts) and they want Harmonix to feel the backlash of bad publicity when they are opened.

crowebert

how iiiiiiiiinterestingk. I didn't expect this, but it's a fabulous move on Activision's part. Almost makes them seem like less of a douche to the casual observer. I'm inclined to side with most of the community in that when Activision says they tried to reach an agreement, they probably tried to license out usage rights for their peripheral for a fee.

So petty. So entertaining! I can't wait to see what happens next!

SourGr8pes

Activision & Harmonix:

Neither of you invented video game instrument controllers. Konami did. So please stop acting like you revolutioned videogaming, and make them universal for their respective systems.

manta

Sounds to me like Activision's "offer" included Harmonix/MTV Games paying Activision some cold hard cash or something along those lines. Assholes.

prev	next 50 comments

Click connect and comment instantly!

get involved

register or login
post a blog
post a forum
enter a contest
contribute a news tip
suggest a feature
be a guest editor

support

new member's guide
login assistance
tech support
report abuse
email our editors
read our dev blog
nuclear crisis?

keep in touch

RSS feed
Twitter
Facebook
Myspace
Flickr
Game nights
Meetup+play online

seriously

about Destructoid
advertising
terms of use
privacy policy
jobs at MM
buy our crap

our network

Tomopop
Japanator
Despingation?

Destructoid is an independently-run publication forged by our love of video games and the gaming community's need of accountable enthusiast press
living the dream since March 16, 2006

New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

Comments policy

Destructoid is an open discussion community. You don't need to "audition" to post a comment - just speak your mind. We respect differing opinions on the site, so have at it. Be smart, funny, insightful, clueless, or cute -- but back it up with substance. Keep your cool, keep it fun. We only ask that you act respectfully and above all: don't be a troll and ruin it for everyone else. Don't bring down gamers or we'll, you know, gently shoot you in the face and stuff you into a flaming mailbox. Each comment is your opportuntity to make this community awesomer. Is that even a word?

Avoiding the banhammer only requires common sense: spamming, trolling, racism, NSFW stuff, and other forms of sucking will not be tolerated. If anyone is griefing please report abuse. Be good. Don't suck!

Got news? tips@destructoid.com | Dtoid Twitter

New Videos

What happens if you hate BioShock 2?

A look at Supreme Commander 2's 'The Kraken' in action

Why not? Cloud Strife hacked into Smash Bros. Brawl

Sonic the Hedgehog 4 already exists on SNES

Finally! Plants vs. Zombies on iPhone ready for next week

Mega64: Say no to blue alien sex censorship

Rebellion tells you how to play Aliens vs. Predator

more videos

- The Dtoid Army is 56707 strong -

Showing Cblogs with 3+ faps show all

Call for entries: the Areas of my Expertise

New to Dtoid? Read the survival guide

Originals

Jonathan Holmes: Analyzing No More Heroes 2, part 2: The bosses, part 2
Destructoid interview: The music of BioShock 2

Indie games don't have to act like indie games

The art of The Journalism Show: Episode 03

Analyzing No More Heroes 2, part 1: The bosses

Ten things I didn't love about Final Fantasy XIII

Wah wah wah Sonic the Hedgehog 4!

Ten things I loved about Final Fantasy XIII

Rev Rant: Paragon/Renegade

Counterpoint: Mass Effect 2

The ugly truth: I may not be good at videogames

Is Heavy Rain doing videogames a disservice?

iPad: Likely to change gaming, just not yours

Rev Rant: the Wrex Paradox

The best indie games of '09 (that I forgot to mention)

Beyond Dead Space: Sledgehammer Games

How Darksiders is blatantly better than Zelda

The making of The Journalism Show: Episode 02

The simple math of review scores

The art of Once Upon a Pixel: Mega Man

More Destructoid Originals

We are Destructoid tips@destructoid.com
	Nick Chester Editor-in-Chief	Niero Founder, Big Boss
	Jim Sterling Reviews Editor	Hamza Aziz Community Manager
	Dale North News Editor	Rey Gutierrez Destructoid Video EIC
	Anthony Burch Features Editor	Brad Nicholson Managing Editor
	Tom Fronczak	Colette Bennett
	Ashley Davis	Ben Perlee
	Conrad Zimmerman	Chad Concelmo
	Jonathan Holmes	Jonathan Ross
	Brad Rice	Jordan Devore
	Will Maddock	Matthew Razak
	Josh Tolentino	Joseph Leray
	Topher Cantler	Samit Sarkar


	Adam Dork Daniel Lingen Hollie Bennett	Joe Burling Mikey Turvey