Quantcast
Destructoid Japanator Tomopop Flixist
Dtoid Forums now support TapATalk and ForumRunner on your iOS/Android devices. Whoot.

Technical Difficulties: What a difference time makes photo
Want your blog on our home page? Answer this!

[You guys have had about a week to think about March's Monthly Musing. Blogs are starting to come in now, so I'm kicking off the beginning of this month's promotions with manasteel88. He writes about his difficulties in adjusting to a new control scheme when he switched from playing certain games with a controller (boo!) to a fightstick (yay!). We'll be promoting blogs on the Musing topic all month, so make sure you get one written. -- JRo]

Difficulty is something that we as gamers come across often in our hobby. Said difficulty is perceived very differently from player to player. When I find a game like Bionic Commando to be hard, some of you might scoff at my ineptitude. It's all about perception of what your true ability is as a gamer.

Likewise, some games are just inaccessible for some people. I can have a blast in games like Operation Darkness while others just can't wrap their head around the mechanics. This difficulty lies in how we as gamers respond to certain games.

These are all things that we progress through and try to figure out on our own. Something interesting happened to me when I got my very first fightstick in the mail this week. I learned that I had a new found difficulty with games I've never really found difficult.



Like many people my age, I grew up in arcades. I was standing shoulder to shoulder in a dark room with people I wouldn't dare look in the eyes. I wanted to play and I had two pockets full of tokens to take on all challengers. All this to kill time with some buttons and a stick. There was a time where I was more comfortable playing Street Fighter in an arcade than at my house. Wishing to relive this (and to be able to work a shoryuken again) I got a fightstick to replace my standard 360 controller.

As soon as I unboxed this beauty, I opened the tray and plopped in Virtua Fighter 5 as the first test of my new toy. Finding out that my cord is about half of a foot short in reaching the 360, I was forced to sit on my child's frogged-shaped cushion chair in front of my couch. Looking down at this box in my lap, I pushed the buttons for the first time and went to conquer my games. I decided to go through the Quest Mode and take on the beginners for the first time with a character I hardly use. Lau Chan (affectionately renamed King Koopa since he now has green hair) was a struggle to control.

I've been playing Virtua Fighter since the original. While Lau wasn't one of my favorites, I at least knew how to use him. Here though, I went from decent to pushover in no time flat. For those that haven't played the game, the beginner tournaments in Quest Mode are cakewalks. None of the fighters block and they'll stand in front of you for a good majority of the round. I shouldn't lose a round with these, but I almost did on multiple occasions.

This was mainly because I wasn't moving in a way I was preconditioned to move. Playing on my standard pad paired with the lack of any real arcades to practice on had completely neutered my technique. I was left wondering why I just wasn't moving like I should. Out of frustration, I decided to jump in to some easier stomping grounds with Dorito's Crash Course.



Okay, I guess a simple platformer like Dorito's Crash Course doesn't work with the stick. How odd. Even a game like Figment, wouldn't allow me the option to choose between characters.

Sigh.

Back to the fighters. Ooh, Dead or Alive! That's an easy one!

I don't know why I started with Ultimate over Dead or Alive 3, as I prefer the system in the latter, but I had a hard time with the movement. Try to sidestep right, and I duck. Try to sidestep left, and I block. Paired with the fact that I'm splitting my fingers to punch and kick, I'm out of my element. I'd say that, but I dominated my first playthrough against every opponent except for counter-heavy characters like Gen Fu. That's where I saw my button mashing offensive come to a halt.

As I kept playing, my hands kept loosening up. I was getting better at the game. Figuring out the way to move around was getting easier. Even with its unnatural button layout, adaptation was happening. I was thinking of button mapping it to a more comfortable level, but I don't ever remember having an option of doing that in the arcades. Why shouldn't I learn the way its telling me and if it's drastically unnatural, I'll change it up later.



With a new found confidence, I decided to switch it up and run a simple horizontal shooter in Aegis Wing. Do you ever get that feeling when you play a simple game and for some inexplicable reason, just keep dying? In embarrassing fashion no less? I couldn't make it to the end of the first level in one of the easier shmups on the system. No worrying about button layouts here, I was just doing awful.

My confidence now shot, I decided to take on some of the better games on my system. Shoot1Up was certainly a much better experience with my talents still downgraded due to my fingers uncertainty of the expand and contract buttons. I got through the first level which boosted my confidence ten fold.

Metal Slug 3 was next and I found out that the shooting button isn't conducive to rapid button presses. My shots would pause in between as if I didn't hit it hard enough. I actually died on the first level which made me sad, but this time I knew it wasn't my fault.



In a trial by fire, I then decided to explore Battle Fantasia, BlazBlue, and finally Marvel vs Capcom 2. Battle Fantasia is the only game I use a charge character in. He's an effeminate choir boy dressed as Harry Potter, and for some reason I can use him. Or maybe that IS the reason I can use him? With my stick, however, the charge mechanics just don't seem to register for me. Down to up and back to forward left me with a 1 in 7 accuracy of attack. It was never completely responsive before, but it worked at a solid rate. Maybe I'm moving my hands funny?

Screw it. Now it's time for some BlazBlue. BlazBlue is a monster of a fighting game. Something that I need a good deal of preparation to get in to. The button layout for the stick is simply perfect and moves feel natural. My Haku-men was better now that I didn't have to mash my hand to get a Barrier move up. I was content that maybe I had gotten better. I mean there is no way that BlazBlue is easier to access than Battle Fantasia, right? Now that I have worked my way up the ladder, I'm off to the sole reason I have a fightstick: Marvel vs Capcom 2.

I've been playing this game on and off for about 10 years on a pad. I wouldn't say I understand the combo system or how to properly swap characters, but I have some experience with it. This game simply couldn't be played without me changing the button layout. I did try, but punch was next to kick which was confusing me to all madness. As a major Wolverine player, I was amazed that my Drill Claw could now work when I wanted it to, but my Berserker Claw didn't. I would get stuck doing a low punch instead. After an hour or so of play, I finally got the hang of it, though it never came naturally. Sure my moves weren't smooth, but at least I could finally pull of what I wanted when I wanted.



Through these battles I've found that I can't play on an arcade stick like I used to. It was saddening, but it just showed how rusty I truly am to this experience. Through adjustments in how I play, I'm finally climbing back on that horse. It isn't however the improvement I was hoping for. My age in this style of play has worn down my abilities as a gamer. I am undergoing a point where I have to sharpen my skills to become mediocre.

It's an odd feeling that I've only really experienced recently. First person shooters have been slightly more difficult just due to inactivity in the genre. I guess I'm getting old. My reflexes are dulling. I guess it's time to buckle down and really sharpen up on my gaming skills.

All this is a bit difficult, but I'm just going to have to knuckle down and get better. It's the only thing I can do.

I'm just surprised by the time it has taken me to run through games with a controller I mastered in 1992.








More gaming stories around the web. Got news? Submit yours to tips@destructoid.com



Post a comment! You can also post a photo below:

Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

16 comments | showing # 1 to 16
prev next

Artless Bread's Avatar - Comment posted on 03/06/2011 05:15
Artless Bread
Great read, emphasizes how big a difference peripherals make when it comes to difficulty, but also to the enjoyment of most games. An issue that isn't talked about nearly enough, I would say. It's really obvious when playing games over an emulator - playing Rock 'n' Roll Racing with a keyboard made me wonder why I ever liked that game.
BulletMagnet's Avatar - Comment posted on 03/06/2011 09:27
BulletMagnet
Funny you should mention this, as I just picked up an EX2 for my own 360, and am also having trouble adjusting after playing on a pad for so long...I bought it more for all my import shmups than fighters (though I've got a handful of those too), but I just can't seem to get the same amount of bullet-dodging precision as with a decent pad. I'm wondering if I just didn't buy a good enough stick, but do I really need to spend 200 bucks for it to work right?

Best of luck in your trials, friend.
manasteel88's Avatar - Comment posted on 03/06/2011 11:13
manasteel88
@Artless

Yeah, I'm planning on getting the Sonic Ultimate Genesis Collection to see how a stick holds up with games like Space Harrier. Should be interesting.

@Bullet

You shouldn't need a $200 stick for simple games. It's probably an adjustment thing. When I started playing Shoot 1 Up, my movements were crisper and the gameplay worked than say Zeit2 or Aegis Wing. I just wasn't used to the longer movement of the stick and how it reads.

Keep practicing it and you should eventually see some improvements. For import shmups (I'm assuming Cave stuff) it's going to be a lot harder as movement is precise. I'd try getting some demos of the lower end American shmups and work your way up. It's kinda what I did with my 2d fighters. I started with Battle Fantasia and moved up to BlazBlue which has much more defined movement. Finally I ended with MvC2 which is much more frantic in pace.

Start low with the stick and remember that this one is specially made for 3d fighters like Dead or Alive 4 and Virtua Fighter 5. You may need to learn how the stick compensates for it.
Kaggen's Avatar - Comment posted on 03/07/2011 04:31
Kaggen
Nice read! I can relate to this even though I didn´t grow up in the arcades! Because I trained my ass off as Blanka in SF4 before I went to my Aunt in Scotland so I could show of my skills in the arcades , the problem was however , I had never played it with a arcade stick before so my confidence got hypercombofinished in no time :P
AwesomeExMachina's Avatar - Comment posted on 03/07/2011 12:14
AwesomeExMachina
You've got an exceptional gamer self-awareness. Where tons of people see difficulty as a scale, going from easy to not easy, you've got it right in saying that it's a actually much more complex. Games mix and mash talents. If a player struggles in one genre, they may flourish in another. Hell, they may do the same in just a different game. I've encountered gamers who flounder helplessly in Street Fighter but can tear others limb from limb in every other fighter and vice versa. It's all about where, when, and what game your skills come alive.

A superb read, sir.
Epic-Kx's Avatar - Comment posted on 03/07/2011 19:17
Epic-Kx
/claps.
egnaro412's Avatar - Comment posted on 03/07/2011 19:31
egnaro412
Awesome read. I play fighters more than any game out there but my entire I've been using a standard controller... ever since original Street Fighter 2. I recently picked up a madcatz SE stick and I'm having a bit of trouble with movement specifically. Goin to stick with it though.
Hell Hammer's Avatar - Comment posted on 03/07/2011 19:43
Hell Hammer
This is a great read. It's interesting to note just how much difference a controller VS a stick can really make, especially in fighting games. And as someone who has used sticks to play streetfighter my whole life, I'd like to point out something even more interesting, to me anyway, is how much difference a 'high quality' stick can make VS a run-of-the-mill stick.

I used to play on a $20 PS1 stick, and simultaneously scoff at my friends who were importing Hori stuff or paying $150 for SFIV-TE sticks...now I know better.
Wedge's Avatar - Comment posted on 03/07/2011 20:18
Wedge
Those Hori sticks are really bad. A good stick is usually $80-100 on sale or maybe even less if you can get it second hand, not $200.

But anyways, you're just doing this stuff for amusement, so w'ever.
Shinta's Avatar - Comment posted on 03/07/2011 20:24
Shinta
I never could play on an arcade stick honestly. It's just not at all for me. I'll take a solid d-pad any day. I remember going to tournaments for Soul Calibur 3 and I was the only one using a SF controller instead of an arcade stick. Everyone looked at me like I was crazy, but I got to the 3rd round.
Wrenchfarm's Avatar - Comment posted on 03/07/2011 20:43
Wrenchfarm
Fun musing manasteel! It took me awhile to get used to a stick again after so many years of just playing fighters with a dualshock pad, but now that I have adjusted I wouldn't want to go back. I tried out one of those SF pads but the floating D-pad felt terrible.

You have a good outlook - when things get difficult its time to buckle down rather than toss in the towel.
manasteel88's Avatar - Comment posted on 03/07/2011 21:58
manasteel88
@Awesome Epic Kaggen
Thanks

@egnaro
yeah, I had to play around a bit to get the finesse down and I'm still not at the same level. I can see improvements however and that's where the promise lies. I can always go back to my 360 pad if I ever need to.

@Hell Hammer
Oh I have no doubts that the right kind of stick can change the world, but for my level of play, I just needed an improvement over the 360s horrible d-pad. Especially for BlazBlue.

@wedge
Bullet brought up the $200, which honestly isn't far fetched with some of these sticks. G4TV just ran a little episode with Clockwork's custom $240 stick, which looks completely worth the money. However, a stick like this isn't unusable and can be adjusted to any style of play. It's meant for 3D fighters as it was packaged for DOA4 and Soul Calibur, but like I've said, BlazBlue works pretty well with it.

If I want to get into the $100 range I can start modding this (even if it's a bit more difficult), but I'm pretty sure I can change my style to work with this stick.

@Shinta
I'm a big fan of solid d-pads, but I don't have one for the 360. I was itching for a long time to get the Blanka Mad Catz pad, but the floating d-pad left me wondering how it would play out with everything on my system.

@wrenchfarm
That's exactly why I was always hesitant to the SF pads. At least with a fightstick I can physically throw my stick in position to get a shoryuken out.
MinusO1's Avatar - Comment posted on 03/07/2011 22:45
MinusO1
Great read. Like most people that played at the arcade growing up I had a definite dry spell for years when it came to using a console arcade stick. I picked up a Sanwa modded Madcatz SE stick last year and couldn't do a damn thing on it thanks to the muscle memory caused by using a controller for more than ten years. It just takes practice and effiort to learn how to play all over again.

Also, my friend has an Hori ex2 and he's really good with it in every fighting game. (Even SSFIV and MvC3)
Elsa's Avatar - Comment posted on 03/08/2011 09:58
Elsa
"where I have to sharpen my skills to become mediocre." LMAO! I love that line! So true for many of us.

Awesome article and it's great to see it promoted. I've had it in an open tab and kept meaning to read it, but the promotion was the added boost!
manasteel88's Avatar - Comment posted on 03/08/2011 12:45
manasteel88
@minus
You give me hope that I can one day be as good as your friend. I'm definitely stuck right now having to figure this all out, but I feel like I'm getting looser in my movements. Though, I probably have to change my Battle Fantasia main right now out of frustration.

@Elsa
thanks for keeping it open.
Outrider42's Avatar - Comment posted on 03/08/2011 17:45
Outrider42
Your point with age hit me. Sometimes I'm left wondering if I still can keep up with people.

Sometimes when I crank up an emulator, I wonder how the heck I beat this game back in the day. But then sometimes it comes right back. The Xbox live arcade version of tecmo super bowl was a blast. Without any practice, I destroyed the season mode and even earned the #1 ranking in total points scored. The first time I've ever been #1 on any board.
prev next

Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

Comments policy

Destructoid is an open discussion community. You don't need to "audition" to post a comment - just speak your mind. We respect differing opinions on the site, so have at it. Be smart, funny, insightful, clueless, or cute -- but back it up with substance. Keep your cool, keep it fun. We only ask that you act respectfully and above all: don't be a troll and ruin it for everyone else. Don't bring down gamers or we'll, you know, gently shoot you in the face and stuff you into a flaming mailbox. Each comment is your opportuntity to make this community awesomer. Is that even a word?

Avoiding the banhammer only requires common sense: spamming, trolling, racism, NSFW stuff, and other forms of sucking will not be tolerated. If anyone is griefing please report abuse. Be good. Don't suck!