Quantcast


Sony's

Did Sony simply follow in Nintendo's footsteps and copy their motion-sensing idea while developing the SIXAXIS for the PS3? We don't know ... that's one argument that will probably never reach a conclusion. Has Sony copied Nintendo in the past? Definitely. Will they do it again? Most definitely.

If I could direct your attention to this page here.

An input device providing users with a pointing capability includes a sender portion and a receiver portion. The sender portion is adapted to be manipulated by a user to specify a target point within a target area. The sender portion projects a light beam including a pattern on to the target area. A receiver portion includes one or more sensor units located in or near the target area. At least some of the sensor units receive a portion of the light beam regardless of the location of the target point within the target area. A processing unit in the receiver portion analyzes the portions of the light beam received by one or more sensor units to determine an attribute of the target point. The attribute can be the location or relative motion of the target point. The receiver portion may be integrated with a display device.

Now, this could just be some sort of a media remote for the PS3. They did say there were firmware updates coming that would enhance the PS3's media capabilities. But then again, if you hit that link above, this is what the first few lines say:

A PS4 will be launched by Sony but not until at least 2010 claims the Vice President of Technology for Sony Computer Entertainment Europe, Paul Holman.

What will happen between then and now is that Sony will introduce a series of firmware upgrades that will give the PS3 more media centre capability while allowing for the introduction of third party applications and hardware "Such as interactive controllers" similar to the Nintendo Wii he said.

Way to be subtle, Sony. I can't wait to check back for the comments on this. 








More gaming stories around the web. Got news? Submit yours to tips@destructoid.com



Post a comment! You can also post a photo below:

Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

38 comments | showing # 1 to 38
prev next

kevvo's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 08:11
kevvo
Ummm yea, release a new system like what 3 years away???? That makes a whole lot of sense. Great photo shop of the wii controller for ps3 by the way
bleep's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 08:13
bleep
Copying is the largest form of flattery. So I guess Nintendo is REALLY flattered that their technology is being stolen from them by one of their largest competitors.... I think I've played this game before!
Ishaan's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 08:13
Ishaan
Not mine, unfortunately. I found it on Google.
Milofo's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 08:29
Milofo
I wonder if there will be a court battle on this. I don't know the specifics of how the Wii remote works but if Sony could make the Siaxis do the same thing as the Wii remote but using a different method; then Sony could probably get away with it. I would think it would be awkward to use a controller like the Siaxis for games that are sword or gun based in the way the Wii could do them.
Cruds's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 08:30
Cruds
The thing that I find odd is that the patent is for Sony but in that story about the firmware update they talk about third-party hardware.

looks like Sony doesn't really know what they want only thing that they do know is that they wanna copy something. That shows you how much trust Sony has in its own product.
Haole Boi X's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 08:32
Haole Boi X
I don't think most people care who did it first, they care who does it best. I don't mind companies copying off each other, it's the gamer's that will benifit in the end from all the competition and one-upmanship. But I am hoping Xbox 360 makes something like motion sensing control, and no I don't mean with the camera :p
Topher Cantler's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 08:36
Topher Cantler
"Sony files new "Remote input device" patent"

I just filed a new patent, too. It's gonna be badass.
It's called the wheel. Totally my idea. I got one for a thing I like to call "chair" too. Don't tell anybody. See, you sit in it, and...
Detry's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 08:37
Detry
It's the brand new, totally original, Sony Pii
some_dude's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 08:41
some_dude
Damn, the harder Sony tries, the less I want a playstation (yep all lowercase, eat it Sony!). It seems like they realize just how big a threat the wii could be in Japan.
xtofuconsumerx's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 08:48
xtofuconsumerx
3 years and already a ps4...wtf thats 200$ a year. I am over it I have trie and tried to give Sony some credit here and there. I quit. Sony you are dead to me now.
1,000,000,000 customers -1.
LxLegend's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 08:53
LxLegend
I maybe wrong but I was always under the impression that you couldn't file patents on tech that was already patent. And if that's the case why is sony all of a sudden a copy cat.

When nintendo is the real copy cat they weren't even the first with motion sensing controls.

And for all we know that could be a light gun.

Also

http://www.microsoft.com/presspass/press/1998/may98/devicepr.mspx

http://www.amazon.com/Microsoft-Sidewinder-Freestyle-Game-A17-00001/dp/B00004Z729

I guess I should say something "STFU Sony hating noobs" but I don't think that's needed. :)
Ballistic90's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 09:02
Ballistic90
That isn't even how the Wii controller works. The Wii controller has a type of camera in it that senses infrared light from the sensor bar to determine where it is. Also, releasing a peripheral for the Xbox 360 or the PS3 that is just like the Wii controller is pretty stupid, since that it would required a customer to buy a very specialized controller, and because of that very few games would support it. Notice how peripherals like the PS2 hard drive and the Gamecube Bongos hardly get used.
Ballistic90's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 09:03
Ballistic90
By the way, the controller that Microsoft made for the PC was completely different than the Wii controller. I used that one and they use completely different technology.
Zoex's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 09:03
Zoex
I'm trying to decide if I should sell my PS3 or keep it. Going for about $900 on eBay now.

How much stupid crap is going to be half ass pumped out if I do keep it?

But Resistance is calling me....
LxLegend's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 09:15
LxLegend
Ballistic, nice use of white matter. But the point on the comment wasn't that Nintendo was using the same technology as MS did 8 years ago. It was the fact that the idea isn't original. I know the technology the companies are using aren't the same if they were Nintendo would have to license it and for some reason I don't think the BigN would want to pay MS royalties for every Wii controller they sold.
ZiggyGod's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 09:16
ZiggyGod
Zoex I say sell it. Wait till we get closed to Xmas. I pretty sure they will go back up.
FrogMan's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 09:33
FrogMan
Im going to take the other side of this and say. FUCK YEAH! te Wii with killer graphics, sign me up!
Aaron Mxy Yost's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 09:35
Aaron Mxy Yost
I vaguely recall Sony filing a patent years ago for a gaming interface that would beam images directly into your MIND.
maxx77's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 09:36
maxx77
I don't know what's worse, that Sony is finding a way to emulate how the wiimote works, or that they're planning on a new console in just 3 years when they claimed that the PS3 was "future proof for the next ten years." Honestly I don't think they're able to make a new console that quickly. Sony has shown the world this time around that they can't design and produce a new console as quickly as their competitors. I think they would have taken even longer to release the PS3 were it not for the 360 and Wii.

Someone else already pointed this out, but I'll just throw in my confirmation of what they said. This patent is the opposite of how the Wii works. The patent says that the "sensor bar" would detect where the remote is pointed. The Wii works the other way. The sensor bar just emits light. The remote is actually sensing where those lights are, and then transmitting those coordinates back to the console. Nintendo should have filed a patent for both technologies. They had to have known Sony would steal this idea.
BlindsideDork's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 09:36
BlindsideDork
Stupid Sony....

and who uses joypads or whatever for computer games anyways?
BlindsideDork's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 09:38
BlindsideDork
Does filing a patent mean it has been accepted or just sent in and waiting for approval? I mean maybe Nintendo did file the other patent like maxx77 is saying...
maxx77's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 09:46
maxx77
I just read on Joy... err, some other site, that the "PS4 by 2010" claim was never actually spoken by a Sony rep. So, the PS4 coming out by 2010 most likely won't happen. Sony implementing Wiimote functionality in an attempt to steal the "low end" side of the market that Nintendo is dominating? Believe that. They'd be stupid not to try (again) to steal the Wii's thunder. I don't think they can do it without cutting the cost of the PS3 to $250, but hey, more power to ya, Sony. Nintendo and MS, meanwhile, have things in the pipeline you haven't even dreamed of (stealing) yet.
BlindsideDork's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 10:35
BlindsideDork
It wasn't said but I think they came up with that number indirectly, maybe implied? They said the PS2 had a long live, granted it did but people stay it is still alive, then why kill it?

maxx77, what do you speak of when you say Nintendo and MS have things in the pipeline?
Philonious's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 10:47
Philonious
Stealing the Wii-mote? Um... The xbox controller is a direct rip of the Dualshock, which "stole" the analog stick from the N64 and improved upon it with better placement and having two analog sticks. (Hell, the "classic controller for the Wii IS a Dualshock) The NES and everything since is a rip-off of Atari, Coleco and Intellivision. The last gen of consoles were all direct rips of the original Playstation... My point is that in the console industry this is what they do. They take the other guys' ideas and try to make them better. Sometimes with mixed results.

Heck you can extend it to games and point out that Gears of War is a ripoff of Wolfenstein, etc, etc, etc.
maxx77's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 11:07
maxx77
Blindside, I was just making a point that while Sony is just getting caught up with their competitors (namely, trying to emulate what the Wii does with controls, what the Xbox 360 does with online functionality, for example), the competition is baking up something else that Sony will most likely have to copy to stay competitive. Who would have guessed, just a few yeasr ago, that Nintendo's next console would have turned out like the Wii? Who knows what Nintendo's brain trust has in mind for their next systems. You can be assured that they're working on some crazy new innovations that we won't see for another 5-10 years. Innovations that Sony hasn't even thought of yet. MS, I'm sure, is probably drafting up some crazy plans for their third Xbox as well.
Vigor's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 11:50
Vigor
A ps4 in 2010 its gonna take ppl half a year until the ps3 is readily available in stores. Plus people have to wait for titles that appeal to them if they are skeptical about getting the ps3.Sony is making the stupidest decisions that could ever be made.Is sony really just run by 5 year olds or is it just me.
arcthemonkey's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 11:51
arcthemonkey
People seem to love missing this, and I'm sure it's likely due to people needing to masturbate their flame gland, but Sony filed this patent almost half a year before Nintendo revealed the Wii-mote.

May 27, 2005 was when it was filed. The Wii-mote was revealed in September that year. - some 4-5 months later.

some_dude's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 12:00
some_dude
So are you assuming that Nintendo cobbled the Wiimote together in 4 months just to be Sony to market, and Sony didn't sue them? Bzzzzt!! So sorry, please insert another quarter in the Fanboy-Excusatron and try again.
arcthemonkey's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 12:03
arcthemonkey
No, I'm not suggesting Nintendo stole it from Sony, I'm saying Sony didn't (Read: Couldn't have) directly or subversively try to patent it out from underneath them.

I'm saying nobody but Nintendo knew about this when this patent was filed - not to mention the fact that this patent may very well be referring to their multimedia controller, or any other number of things.

What the hell?

jkgohan's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 12:05
jkgohan
Well, they stole everyting in the past why not steal everything in the new.
some_dude's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 12:31
some_dude
The ideas behind the tech are not new, but since Nintendo got this to market in a high profile fashion first, most will always see Sony as copying them. That may not be the case, but that's how most will pecive it it Sony comes out with a similar device, even if it's not for gaming. ZOMG, tehy copy ninty! $0ny iz teh suxxors!

@arcthemonkey

I wasn't attacking you, just trying to understand the point you were making. I could have worded my post differently, but what fun would that be... :)
Ishaan's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 12:39
Ishaan
I've changed the headline, since it seemed to be causing some confusion. The patent was filed a while ago, but they seem to be planning to incorporate it now into the PS3. And of course, I'm not saying companies don't rip each other off. It happens all the time, and it is a good thing, despite what any of you might say (the Dual Shock was much better than the N64 pad, for example).

The thing is, Sony's rep of late has been shit. And if they start shelling out Wiimote-like devices right now, it isn't going to help their reputation one bit. Sure, I like the idea of having motion-sensing AND "next-gen" graphics, but I don't know how well that'll work for the PS3, considering that developing for the platform is already hard enough.
Holyetheline's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 12:44
Holyetheline
Dude I hate Sony. They're like a bunch of starving leaches trying to latch onto whatever they can so they don't die or something. Stupid bastards.
Azrael's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 12:48
Azrael
Hmm.. guys, you need to stop being childlish and realize this is a Business, there is no place for an honor system where a company goes succesful with a novel idea and everybiody stays away. If it were we wouldnt have FPS and FIGHTING as "generes". Actually nobody but a single company could have 3d games or consoles.

Also you can NOT patent ideas or designs you can patent "METHODS" thats all, if sony (or anyone) finds a way to imitate the Wii with a different Method, they legally can do it. And believe me THEY will, MS is also researching on a "control XY wand" or something like that.

For us gamers it only means a Wiimote with better graphics and less "family friendly games" so Im all up to it. Just think ten seconds WiiMote + gears of wars + mgs4 and then we will talk.

In all fairness Nintendo pretty much knew this was going to happen, so they probably ahead ways to counter it. As in keeping the lowest console price (a $100 Wii? it could happen) and targetting a broader audience. If the Wii loses the motion sensing exclusity (which pretty much they already had) it wont be the end of the world for them. (specially due their DS income)

P.s. Dont expect this to hit anytime soon though, other companies wont risk on this decission (since Nintendo offered as a pioneer) so the system will have to prove "stable on a financial basis" to get the green light. Expect this to hit sometime next year (maybe xmas), after the fiscal year results are in.

ceark's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 13:08
ceark
happens all the time in every other industry and no one seems to bitch about it. goes to show that fanboys are just sissy ass whiners.
Jelster's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 14:41
Jelster
I'd say it is to be expected. But the biggest worry I have about this and specifcally with Sony (although I'm still watching you MS) is that they DO NOT innovate, they're happy playing power-up catch-up because they're damn good at it.

The problem comes when Nintendo says screw this we're going 3rd party and Microsoft pull the plug. You then end up with a company in charge with no imagination and little enthusiasm to push gaming along the evolutionary scale.


On the subject of the tech, Nintendo never said it was new, actually they said it had been around for a while, just that nobody had tried to do what they were doing with it before. Which given the pointer & motionsensing is fairly true if you cut them some slack.

Twiggy's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/06/2006 14:50
Twiggy
Further on the subject of the tech, it's two different things! The Sony patent is for a pointing device which sends a beam of light at a surface, picked up by a nearby sensor. Okay, that's a Super Scope. Or maybe a Sega Menacer. This is just one more evolutionary step, possibly to be used with something completely different, like a new form of TV remote with on-screen pointer or some kind of media center device. Sony does make stuff other than Playstations, after all, and most of their 'new tech' doesn't go into freaking videogames. Watching the patent office to see what companies are coming out with is like watching the post office to see if your spouse is cheating - ineffective and misleading.
questworld's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/07/2006 02:03
questworld
For me, any annoyance about this is placed squarely on comments that belittled the concept of the Wii remote as "gimmicky" be it Sony reps or Sony fanboys (mainly the jerk variety and not all Sony fans mind). If people were less rude around here and anywhere else on the internet (or world), but no, they have to be trolls and encourage trash talkers. Alas, such people were quick to mock but when Sony's doing the same thing, well, are these same people suddenly going to try to tell us Sony's been "working on a similar concept all along" or perhaps even "it's not like Nintendo invented it?" I think some of them would, that is unless they really think it is gimmicky and mock Sony for the sake of fair play. I think this is what gets some people's goat. It's okay if one was skeptical but when their behaviors became more insulting and fanboyish on a rude for rudeness sake POV, well, you better watch out 'cause some people just might want some verbal payback.
prev next

Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

Comments policy

Destructoid is an open discussion community. You don't need to "audition" to post a comment - just speak your mind. We respect differing opinions on the site, so have at it. Be smart, funny, insightful, clueless, or cute -- but back it up with substance. Keep your cool, keep it fun. We only ask that you act respectfully and above all: don't be a troll and ruin it for everyone else. Don't bring down gamers or we'll, you know, gently shoot you in the face and stuff you into a flaming mailbox. Each comment is your opportuntity to make this community awesomer. Is that even a word?

Avoiding the banhammer only requires common sense: spamming, trolling, racism, NSFW stuff, and other forms of sucking will not be tolerated. If anyone is griefing please report abuse. Be good. Don't suck!