i mean when i first started reading i was like wow this sounds a lot cooler then what i originaly thought.
but then reading that its a lot of just grinding. i really hate that. grinding for the sake of making people grind.
also i know the look is whats supposed to make it, but man. i just cant get into it. at least 3D Dot Game Heroes made it look really nice.
this almost seems like its still in pre alpha and some new grfx pack will be released to make it look a PS1 game.
Minecraft is great too, but I don't get the point of an Xbox version. It runs on almost every PC/Mac and has so many more features on there.
Then, the reviews came. Many of the reviews mention the many bugs in its present state. Which really doesn't worry me as I assume these will be addressed sooner than later. Another common disappointment the reviewers have is the simplified crafting system, which I can understand but ultimately could care less. Most of the reviews I have seen give approximately the same score 7/10, which is not terrible, yet bad enough to give me pause. What worries me the most is that the map has been considerably shortened. One reviewer said it takes about six minutes to go from opposite ends proclaiming this is due to limitations of the Xbox; which seems like a pitiful excuse (but I know nothing as far as that is concerned). However, there is hope that these gripes will vanish as the promised (supposedly free) updates will bring the 360 version as close as possible to the lauded PC version. Though, obviously, one cannot judge something by promises (as evidenced by any Fable game).
With the reviews coming out I find myself in an awkward decision of whether or not to skip Minecraft 360. I am a big fan of arcade games, and there are some cheaper games with better reviews I could spend these points on. Yet, I cannot shake that the felling that I'll still enjoy Minecraft 360 despite the somewhat disappointing reviews.
That...might just be one of the best things ever or the worst.
It definitely seems worth a demo if not two.
Puts a whole new spin on the middle ages now, does it?.. Perhaps the idea is that if you share a server with someone, you'd start to think "Gee, I'm bored, time to wage war" or something.
"For one thing, mods and many of the updates are missing, though more features are due to be added over time."
See, I was a little worried about that. Understandable of course, but idk.. weighing the options as someone who hasn't even played the PC version, the PC versions starting to tip the scales in its favor.
Four Player split screen is intriguing though, happy they added that. Means I might be able to get my roommate to play and I can make them my slav-- I mean, we can double team our map. Maybe I'll call them Toby.
Your enjoyment with that game fully depends on how many ideas and goals you have. You've built a fortress. What now, you ask? Anything. Make some farms; hunt monsters to get experience, so you can enchant stuff; build a water elevator; build a portal to Nether. Then re-skin all textures into Xenomorph Prime, live in a cave, throw 100 eggs on the floor and pretend you're a xenomorph queen.
I suggest you to give Minecraft another shot on the PC.
$20 is a little pricey though. I suppose it's because I got the pc version when it was like $12.
No I didn't.
"so you're not reviewing the port but the game itself,"
Not 100% completely.
"then you proceed to make feature comparisons to the PC version."
I made brief notes that were worth making.
"I put it to you that the PC version is irrelevant to the 360 port."
I put it to you that I do not know why I just had to repeat what the review actually said back to you.
Other guy:
"This review doesn't do Minecraft justice, in my opinion.
Your enjoyment with that game fully depends on how many ideas and goals you have."
That is *exactly* what I concluded though. There are more than two paragraphs in these reviews!
I have this odd mental image of you reading these comments in your reviews from people that either don't read fully or read what they want (twisting words). I picture you going all Malkovich, screaming at your monitor. It makes me happy."Final Verdict: 7.5
Good: 7s are well-above average games that definitely have an enthusiastic audience within their *genre*. Some might lack replay value, could be too short, or has are some hard-to-ignore faults. Nevertheless, the experience is still very fun."
1-10 rating scales your way would be better just being percentages or letter grades: 80-89=B(+)(Good) or 90-100=A(+)(Great/Amazing) with anything less than 80 being okay, not worth your time, or terrible.
That, and this review is for everyone, not just prior comic book fans or prior Minecraft fans. If you still don't "agree" well...that's like your opinion man.
I hope I'm not talking to a block.
Also, am I the only one offended by the implication that anyone who doesn't dig this game has no imagination/creativity? Everybody has those things, what everybody doesn't have is the vast amounts of patience needed to grind the ever loving shit out of this 'game'. And I use 'game' loosely because honestly, calling MC a game is like calling Lego a game.
Yes, and I've read them all as always. I find it a bit weird that you reply mostly to people who got you wrong to clear things out or to have a laugh, and for some reason I hate being on that list. My comment clearly lacks any substance, but it's not negative in any way, at least I don't think so.
I still think this review doesn't do it justice.
It was one of your first experiences with Minecraft, you went into the game knowing about all the praise. It was also two years after its initial release, so I'm sure you were aware of most things Minecraft can offer before you played it, therefore you could spot that sense of discovery and write it down, but you weren't able to experience it fully. And to be fair, Minecraft's novelty has wore off by that point. Although Minecraft 1.0 is the official "finished" version, its true release was long before that.
While I played it for the first time when it was an alpha. I showed it to my fiancee, she said it looks like shit, but got into it somehow. First she helped me to build my first house in a cave. She was taking care of the cave, while I was exploring dungeons and mining for iron. We lived like cavemen and it was awesome. The game evolved overtime and our life within its world changed. Seeing how the game changes and evolves overtime is important for being able to judge Minecraft for what it is. That was part of the experience for me.
My experience with Minecraft was very personal, so of course in my opinion this review doesn't do justice to this game. That, of course, doesn't mean I think your point of view is wrong.
On the contrary, I'd probably feel the exact same way, unimpressed. And if you would play it the way I did and shared experience with your loved one, you'd probably feel pretty much like I do.
Different opinions! They're all fine.
It appears there is no such possibility in this version, a real shame.
I can see map size being console-limited.
From what I recall, the PC version is effectively uncapped. You can expand a map as large as your drive can accept, and make it as complicated as your CPU/GPU/whatever can handle. If your world brings your machine to a halt, then you just write it off as not having a strong enough machine to handle it.
But consoles have less power. I don't know if there are limits on how much hard disk space a game is allowed to consume, but XBLA Minecraft was probably designed with a relatively low cap in mind. And then there is memory. Even if you were allowed to take as much disk space as you wanted, there are limits to how much of the world the game can process at any one moment. The Xbox 360 has, what? 512MB? My 8 or so year old desktop had 512MB of RAM, and it had trouble running anything memory intensive until I added another 1GB. The some years old laptop to my side I think has 8GB.
Minecraft, with friends, is arguably the best co-op game EVER!
All my friends (irl and online) are on xbox. So for me this is a big release to a game i already own on PC, but had nobody to play with.
,
To be honest, give a me randomly generated where every thing is built with pieces and all those pieces can be destroyed, moved, or replaced. Give a day and night cycle where monsters come out at night. And let me play it with my friends? Thats sounds like something im going to like.
BTW, its only 8 player per world, and ive got like 12 xbox friends waiting to download the game tomorrow =p. I cant wait.
That's...uh...awful. Very limited resources. Doesn't even appear to have biomes. Yikes.

surf dtoid with 

Rising (10+)
People you follow

































follow












