Sully: A Very Serious RPG was almost hidden on the PAX East show floor. It was in the same booth as Dragon Fantasy Book II and was easy to overlook if given just a quick glance. I'm glad that I gave it more than that, because Sully quickly became one of my favorite games on the show floor.
This game doesn't have a super gripping plotline that has a teenage amnesiac waking up to find that he and his band of buddies must use their unique abilities to save the world from an ominous evil. In fact, the first quest I actually managed to complete was to help solve a West Side Story-esque rivalry between the crabs and the jellyfish.