Um, I'm not sure what a Rhythm Heaven anime would consist of, Colette, but I'm sure it would be awesome. And I would love a Persona 4 anime ^.^

Why is iDOLM@STER on that list? They had their chance with Xenoglossia and they completely ruined it. I do agree with P3/4 and Muramasa getting anime adaptations though.

I want an Okami anime soo bad. Backstory for Chibiterasu? Yes Please!

Why wouldn't the Metal Gear anime be number 1? There's so much story to tell, it could span multiple TV series, OVAs, and movies.

Also, I agree with kapshhh: Phoenix Wright feels like an anime on the DS already! Perfect!

I'd really like to see an anime on a notable Western property like Fable. God knows that needs a better story ;)

@BGFUSAB: Tetris would need to be combining Super Robot Show. It just seems too perfect. Seperate they come close to losing, but then L-Shape shows up and helps them finish their combination as everyone announces VIBRANTLY.... TEEETRRRIIISSSS!!!!

Seriously, Colette? Persona: Trinity Soul transferred well? I'm going to have to get your clarification on what exactly you mean as you say that. My opinion is clearly not God, but I thought that show was a mess. Persona didn't seem to behave in any remotely similar fashion, the story lacked any genuine meat or detail, and the climax was just plain confusing with all of that "whale" stuff.

I mean, above all else the thing was just boring, with you having to sit through several episodes to get any real next key point to the plot. Dot.Hack was less secretive than that, another game anime.

I mean, if anyone can tell me how the story and premise of Persona 3 and that anime tie together I'm genuinely interested, but as far as I can see they didn't even get the absolute bare essential aspect of the Persona being mythological in origin. It just struck me as an excuse to use the Persona name on an anime that had almost non-existent connections.

So again I ask, what did you mean by transferred well? I apologize if I'm coming off as overbearing.

To clarify, I thought there was no transfer to begin with, making it impossible to really know if the transfer works well or not.

EDIT: Baring that, I want Okami or blazblue.

I'd really dig an anime starring all the wacky characters from Warioware.

@Wry Guy - Yes, you definitely came across as overbearing. Chill! :) We're just talking about ideas here. As for Persona: Trinity Soul, I thought the atmosphere and look that Persona fans enjoy transferred well. I liked what I saw, but I did end up not finishing for some of the reasons you stated -- I found it wasn't engaging enough in the end to hold my attention.

@Colette: It's most certainly true that they managed to get the atmosphere fairly down. Were it a straight adaption of Persona 4's story that does add to the argument it could go well. Apologies for seeming strung out. It's a pet peeve of mine when a show takes a series name and has no real relation, because if I'm a big enough fan of the property I keep on watching in hopes that it eventually does.

I'm a sucker like that. :[

The list is fail. Where is [i]50 Cent: Blood on the Sand/[i]?

I don't think Persona 4 would make a good anime. The story is built around the RPG itself and wouldn't really work on its own. A lot of the game is spent getting new members, which really boils down to "someone disappears, go into dungeon, YOU'RE NOT ME, fight, wait a few days, new team member." It doesn't really become dynamic until later on once you have every recruit and certain character gets kidnapped.

Plus, way too much of it is mundane stuff like working at Junes. We don't really realize how stale/repetitive some chunks of the story are because they're punctuated by spurts of gameplay. I'd maybe argue that Persona 3 would be a better fit, if only because the full moon scenarios are varied and change the dynamic of the battles. You'd have to yank out a large chunk of Tartarus crap, but I think the story works a little better, and since the shadows directly affect the real world, you have some flexibility to create original stories and conflicts.

Ultimately, though, I think this is another case of video game stories not working well in other mediums (and vice versa), the medium is the message, etc.

I think I was one of the only people who liked Trinity Soul for the most part, although it was really slow. I wouldn't mind seeing a Persona 4 anime.

GOD HAND IS THE ONLY REAL ANSWER FOR AN ANIME SERIES

ALL OTHER IDEAS ARE FOOLISHNESS

@Wry Guy - It's all good, but I can understand your reaction at the same time. I'm with you -- I've been deeply disappointed by many a borrowed series name that did not live up to my expectations myself!

They should make an Okami anime, and use all of the voices from the game. A good BlazBlue anime would be nice, to help make sense of the story.

haha an idol master anime

BlazBlue please! I wanna see the story in a more coherent fashion!

Earlier this year I read a onslaught of great reviews and comments about the game. I was a fan of the first two Persona's on the PSX, though I never tried or even knew about the third. From what I read, the 4th perfected everything from 3, so I figured I would just play 4. Skip 7 months later when a copy finally became freed up on Gamefly, and they sent it to my mail box. I was so excited and so eager to play the game. I held my breath in anticipation. It finally arrived and I was overjoyed. I popped that sucker into my PS3 (1st gen, yeah, you're jealous) and it was on! A day later I couldn't mail it back fast enough muttering "good riddance you piece of shit, garbage game". The story was lame, the characters I couldn't care less about, the repetitive jpop music was awful even for jpop, and the gameplay I'm sure could equate as second best to jerking off with sulfuric acid as lube. I enjoyed nothing about this game. Anime fanboys really should to broaden their horizons instead of praising every lame thing Japan squirts on them.

I want Tales of Vesperia to be an anime show instead of a movie.Just like 20+ episode Tales of Abyss series.