Logo
Returning members: Login      New to Dtoid?   REGISTER NOW and join our community of gamers -- you might win these things. Its all free and takes sec.

Did you know? Destructoid is independently owned and updated by a tight group of friends, most which met online. Drop us a line and keep us busy.
 

    all updates

   pc    xbox 360     wii    ps3    ps2    psp    ds    retro    mobile    indie

top searches:
grand theft auto IV   wiiware
age of conan   metal gear 4

New Posts
Best of the week
Contests
Reviews

 

UPDATE
 
Monthly Musings: If you love it, change it
Reverend Anthony
\\ 05.01.2008
26 comments

erere

I was overwhelmed by both the quality and quantity of the Monthly Musings articles of April; I've gotta say, you guys posted some really kickass stuff. I can only hope that this month's theme is strong enough to keep you guys going the way you have been: it's called "If you love it, change it," and it's about finding and fixing the flaws in your favorite games.

Since no game is truly perfect, there are always flaws to be fixed or untapped potential to be achieved. No matter how much we may love a certain title or series, there are always improvements to be made -- that's what this month's theme asks.

Take a game or series of games you adore, then find a way to improve it. Think Castlevania should lose all the backtracking? Does Zelda need a complete overhaul? Talk about it, and talk about why that'd make the series better.

Hit the jump for further clarification of the theme, and posting rules. 

This isn't about finding a flawed game or series and then saying how it needs to be better -- that's way too easy. We could all talk about why Halo needs a better story, or that Assassin's Creed needed to have actual gameplay. The challenge of this theme comes in looking at a series you personally love, and finding ways to improve upon it.

As unlikely as it may initially seem, every game can be bettered in some way; you've just gotta find the changes that need to be made, and discuss them. This theme is just as much about developing personal skills of critique as it is initiating informed, intelligent discussion (which will undoubtedly happen if your changes make sense).

As always, title your post "If you love it, change it," make sure it's well thought out, and don't hesitate to add some pretty pictures. If your post rocks, we'll shove it onto the front page. 

Any questions? 



26 COMMENTS, LATEST BY Eques-Ardor
Does this topic at all relate to the horrible things that are happening to the layout right now? I like the new topic format, but I don't like that the tag is above the title of the post, and th... -    view discussion




There are 26 comments about this post:
liquidninja's Avatar
Great where do I submit it?
Passionate Styos's Avatar
Ready to make about Castlevania, nobody steal it damn it! Or I should just do something else, this MM is perfect for me.
Jerkbutt47's Avatar
Halo could use a clearer cut story without all the alien backstabbing, but then again I did enjoy the Arbiter's story in Halo 2.

Well now I guess that the Halo games should have given us dual perspectives on the war. I guess that would have made the story more emotionally involving and provided an understanding of what made the individual characters do what they did.
razerangel's Avatar
Hmmm could be interesting
Hamza CTZ Aziz's Avatar
Halo has a good story, it's just horribly told in Halo 2 and especially in 3.

AND HEY GUYS, HOW ABOUT ALL NOT WAIT UNTIL THE END OF THE MONTH TO MAKE YOUR BLOGS?!?!!?!?!?
Reverend Anthony's Avatar
liquidninja:
The cblogs.
Tubatic's Avatar
Cool Cool. This is one I can see people having very different things for the same game. I've got a couple clearly flawed favorites, but I'll definitely try to find some fault in my highly regarded favs (Megaman at least). Good Times!

@Hamza

I didn't :(
The Bez's Avatar
can we do cblogs on non-videogame games?
hammburglar's Avatar
@the bez:
like mousetrap?
Char Aznable's Avatar
Hopefully most of these won't devolve into flame wars in the comments, with people getting pissed off that their cherished games are being torn apart.
king3vbo's Avatar
Oooh great idea
Tubatic's Avatar
agreed Char. But I think, since its coming from someone that loves the game in question, it'll probably soften the hate. maybe.

Then again, who actually reads articles before commenting. pff! :)
Holyetheline's Avatar
Rock Band needs more Radiohead. I think I'll write about that....
Dexter345's Avatar
Here's my article:

If you love it, change it: Mother 3

They should make the Japanese text English instead, and then get it to run on my American GBA.

DONE!
Reverend Anthony's Avatar
The Bez:
You can write one, but I doubt it'd get frontpaged.

Dexter:
I see what you did there.
NihonTiger90's Avatar
I have an entire list of these. In fact, I already did two.

I'm gonna go revise those first... then it's time for new ones.
SWE3tMadness's Avatar
All right! A Musing that I actually have a great idea for! I just need to made a funny picture to go with it. >.>
impetus's Avatar
Call of Duty 4: Start Menu option to reload last save point (instead of restarting the entire level). I intentinally grenaded myself many times simply to start a section over.

Wind Waker: saaaaaaaailing, sailing... yawn.
shit-polka's Avatar
I've got a better monthly theme; menstruation.
EternalDeathSlayer's Avatar
This is a great fucking idea! There are so many things that could be changed for the better in gaming, so many stale franchises and ideas.

This is awesome.
Wexx's Avatar
This could be interesting, need something good inspiration though. BEE ARE BEE!
RJG's Avatar
Zelda. Take away the need to do everything in a linear fashion. Give me a sword, a horse, a bow and an overworld, and just let me loose. Let me find shit myself. Don't lead me from on point to the next. If I don't want to finish a dungeon, that's fine, I shouldn't have to. That just means I don't get the item or the power ups and I make the game harder for myself. Make it more like the original, where everything was hidden and shit, because Ganon had taken over and everyone was hiding and living in fear, and I have to find the survivors to get their help, if I need it. Failing that, let me do it without any help, all by myself if need be, for a real challenge and a real "garden I can put away in my drawer" not a "point a to b to do list I suffer through because Nintendo can't figure out open-endedness".
NegFactor's Avatar
I might be quite interested in posting a couple blogs on this.

But can you really improve Contra? I mean...removing the *F* and *R* power-ups doesn't really seem like much of an improvement. I just ignored them normally anyway. :P
Linkoman's Avatar
@RJG: they did that. its called The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
Droll's Avatar
Absolutly love this topic for blog entry, Reverend Anthony! I was so excited upon reading the idea that I, in what can only be described as a fit of madness, wrote my take on the topic over a 5 hour period! I didn't stop till 2 in the morning!
Love to see what people think about my "If you love it, Change it!" entry on Sonic the Hedgehog! It's a fever dream design doc of genius!
Maybe :)
Eques-Ardor's Avatar
Does this topic at all relate to the horrible things that are happening to the layout right now?

I like the new topic format, but I don't like that the tag is above the title of the post, and that there's only ONE. And I'm not so fond of the 'boxes floating in space' look.

You must be logged in to post a comment. Click here to login or create a user account now.

DTOID TOP 5 - May 16, 2008
Artsy fartsy Mirror's Edge artwork for your fapping delight
[18753 views]

81
BEEG AMERICAN TEETEES! Rent Roman and hear that line day in, day out ... forever
[15576 views]

70
Way to go, advertising geniuses....meet 'Thumbcock'
[10767 views]

102
WiiWare first impressions: LostWinds (double time!)
[10173 views]

51
First gameplay footage of Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts
[10104 views]

154
more top stories

Post a new community blog
This month's theme:
"If you love it, change it"
Best of the community this week
Game with us: Friday Night Fights
Meet Dtoiders near you

DTOID CONTEST ALERTS
Reminder: PS3 and Deca Sports contests ending, get your entries in!
Contest: Win a chance to play Assault Heroes 2 with the game's developers!
Big fat raffle: Win one of 100 Deca Sports demo discs for the Wii
Win a PlayStation 3 and Casino Royale on Blu-Ray by playing Bond: Top Agent
The winners of the Insecticide contest announced
MORE CONTEST ALERTS

DTOID PODCASTS
Podtoid 53: The Blogocube
No RetroforceGO! this week, you make Mikuru cry
Podcastle: Dtoid's UK video game podcast
download back episodes


LATEST GAME REVIEWS
SNK Arcade Classics Vol. 1
Boom Blox
Fatal Fury: Battle Archives Volume 2
Teenage Zombies: Invasion of the Alien Brain Thingys!
R-Type Command [update]
NBA Ballers: Chosen One
Persona 3: FES
Mario Kart Wii
all Dtoid reviews

ORIGINAL COLUMNS
Games Time Forgot by Anthony Burch
Bargain Bin Laden by Jim Sterling
The Memory Card by Chad Concelmo
Indie Nation by Anthony Burch
Friday Night Fights by Grim
An RPG draws near by Colette Bennett
You're the man now dog by Hamza Aziz
Nerdcore Culture by Dtoid Staff
Debate to the death by Tom Fronczak
Monday mind teasers by Tom Fronczak
Miniboss Monday by Mike Ferry
Art Attack Friday by Tiffany Chow
Best of the week by Hamza Aziz
Weekend reading by Brad Rice

XBOX 360 NEWS
Friday Night Fights: GTA IV edition, part deux
The week in Rock Band DLC: European bonus tracks come to North America
LucasArts says no Force Unleashed PS3/360 multiplayer, I practice my Force choke
The Protector: Generic-looking and -sounding action comes to PC and 360
Beyond Good & Evil 2 for Xbox 360 and PS3
Xbox 360 Spring Showcase: Hands-on with Too Human
Developer game notes: Top Spin 3
2K Sports reveals Rick Nash to be NHL 2K9 cover athlete
more Xbox 360 games, news and reviews


NINTENDO WII NEWS
Sega Gamer's Day 2008: new Samba De Amigo screenies
Capcom reveals Ken and Morrigan costumes for Western We Love Golf!
Wii Fit tells a 10-year-old that she's fat, Nintendo responds
MadWorld: The most awesomely violent Wii experience yet
Taiko no Tatsujin coming to the Wii, I take off my pants
Nintendo ordered to pay $21 million for patent infringement
Fun for the whole family: Cornholing comes to the Wii
Lil' Sims returning to Wii and DS with MySims Kingdom
more Wii games, news and reviews


PLAYSTATION 3 NEWS
Friday Night Fights: GTA IV edition, part deux
The week in Rock Band DLC: European bonus tracks come to North America
LucasArts says no Force Unleashed PS3/360 multiplayer, I practice my Force choke
PlayStation Network Update: double bogey edition
Beyond Good & Evil 2 for Xbox 360 and PS3
Developer game notes: Top Spin 3
2K Sports reveals Rick Nash to be NHL 2K9 cover athlete
New Madden 09 trailer is painful to watch...because it's all about tackles
more PS3 games, news and reviews


PC NEWS
Friday Night Fights: GTA IV edition, part deux
The Protector: Generic-looking and -sounding action comes to PC and 360
WoW expansion coming this year...polar bear mounts included?
Velvet Assassin slated for release this fall on Xbox 360, PC
She hasn't put clothes on yet: New X-Blades screenshots
BioWare removes 10-day validation from Mass Effect PC due to backlash
Friday Night Fights: What would Destructoid be without FNF edition
Pandemic and EA reveal Lord of the Rings: Conquest
more PC games, news, and reviews


DS NEWS
Ugly Betty and American Idol winner to shill for new 'Metallic Rose' DS
Konami Gamer's Night '08: Castlevania: Order of Ecclesia details and screens
Lil' Sims returning to Wii and DS with MySims Kingdom
Let me show you Pokemans Platinum: My Pokemans Platinum, let me show it to you
THQ announces Viva Piņata: Pocket Paradise for Nintendo DS
EA announces that you will Skate whatever 'it' is on the DS, Wii
Learn how to run a convenience store with your DS!
Nintendo eats the Big Mushroom, nearly doubles revenue
more nintendo ds news and reviews


PSP NEWS
Destructoid review: SNK Arcade Classics Vol. 1
Captain Obvious: Sony admits PSP needs more games
Mario Kart Wii and Monster Hunter 2nd: Japan's top sellers for three weeks
Talk nerdy into Sony's new PSP headset
Covers and screenshots shown for PS2 and PSP versions of NCAA Football 09
Destructoid Review: R-Type Command [update]
Secret Agent Clank gets date and snazzy bow tie
Word: SouthPeak Games officially announces B-Boy for North American release
more psp news and reviews

RETRO GAMING NEWS
Sega Gamer's Day '08: Golden Axe: Beast Rider screens
No Balls, No Glory: Super Dodge Ball soundtrack remixed
The Little Convention That Could: A look back at TooManyGames 6
Activision preps Pitfall Harry's 'big adventure' for the Wii (Update)
No RetroforceGO! this week, you make Mikuru cry
Run like a raptor! Pixeljam Games' Dino Run released
RetroforceGO! Episode 48: The retro renaissance?
RetroforceGO! recording episode 48 tonight: Upcoming retro revivals
more retro gaming news

tokidoki anime


Japanator - Anime Blog  | Tomopop - Vinyl Toys Blog  |  Poprox - Pop culture blog  |  MiamiNights - Miami Blog
Be Famous! Sort of. Submit a news tip to Dtoid  | Advertising  |  Privacy Policy  |  Powered by Elephant


NOT THE SURGEON GENERAL'S WARNING: The stuff overheard on Destructoid's community blogs do not yet quite personify the sound of wounded dolphins mating nor reflect the opinions of Destructoid LLC, the Webby-honorated group of promiscuously jolly associate editors that update our home page daily. Read our manifesto and see what we're all about. Participating in Destructoid contests gives us permission to impregnate with your wives and horses, drink all of your beer, and eat all of your nacho dip. Anything submitted becomes the property of the public Internet under creative commons and may end up on some emo kid's arm. Some rights reserved, etc, keep your filthy lawyers tucked away in their sad oak-furnished offices saying things like WHEREAS in all caps and as far away from us as possible or we may hurt them and their vulnerable pets. Please tell a friend about DTOID and contribute: help us keep it fresh, higly accurate and relevant, fun, honest, never too stuffy, and always independent. Also, cocks.