i got that feeling within the first few minutes, and quit. thankfully it doesn't look like team ninja will make the same mistake.
I freaking love Metroid Prime though.
This may be exaggeration on your part, but did you truly ever die once from waiting for a door to open? The load times in MP1 were awesome compared to MP3.
The thing that bugs me the most, is that the points you complain about are most of the aspects of the game that are there to make things challenging. Save points giving you ammo would make the game easier, adding more save points would also make the game easier. It was built this way deliberately so that the game would be harder and not just some silly cake-walk like most modern FPS or FPA games. Even after multiple play-throughs on hard mode, I wish the game was even harder than it is, providing even more challenge.
Your point about having to go through the same room with the same enemies 9000n+ times is also moot, considering you don't *have* to fight the enemies all the time. In most cases, you can push through to the next section where you're heading choosing not to engage those enemies, even with minimal damage.
Getting lost in Metroid Prime is another thing that most players should not have problems with, considering it's epic map feature. With HUD hints on it's just too easy to find your way to the next objective. Turning it off is the way to go and provides a much deeper experience.
All in all, I have to say that this is one of the worst Love/Hate articles I've read here. Reason being is that you either are a rubbish player or that you just didn't spend enough time on the title. In either case, it is clear that you don't understand this game anywhere near enough to write an entire article about how Metroid Prime has these "supposed" faults.
Come back when you've played through the original Metroid Prime 6 times, 3 on normal difficulty, 3 on hard; your tune will be a lot different.
For those people, there's the Metroid Prime Trilogy.
Wait, so because he isn't "teh hardcoar" he isn't entitled to an opinion?
Ugh, should I even open this can of worms?
You're sounding a lot like those fanboys we make fun of every Friday.
"WUT!?! 4.5!?! He juz sux @ gaemz lolol!!11"
I'm on board with your main point, when games get stingy with save points when not everyone has all the time to waste that they did as kids....and cheap respawning...you have a right to your opinion and I even agree with those parts, but man!
There was your opinion, here's mine. I hope it's seen as constructive criticism...but have many people in life called you a snob?
Hopefully it was just a mood you were in, but the article comes off really superior and condescending and if it was in a sarcastic way I didn't see it.
Congratulations on your good fortunes if you are as smart and as good at shooters as you imply, but somewhere along the way I think you might have forgot to work on the humble part in life or remembering different tastes from yours don't make people beneath you.
Good points overall, but spoken like a bully and braggart.
I will state reasons as to why his opinion is wrong. I will tell him what he has to do to share my opinion. Depending on my nature, I may make a passive aggressive comment directed at the collective whole. Make no mistake, this comment is intended for the original author. I have felt the need to cover the sting of the insult by claiming it was directed at the majority, so that I cannot be accused of trying to start trouble or picking fights. When I am called out on my insecurity, I will claim that I was just expressing my own opinion, then quietly leave the room. If quietly leaving the room doesn't fit my mood, I will first throw a tantrum.
Sometimes, I'll come back in the room and say the same thing again with different wording.
Hello. I am a person on the Internet. Nice to meet you.
Even more infuriating must be the fact that these games are universally loved by the gaming collective. At least you've got Dyson, right?
I liked the article. Hard to read because it was, uh, really spiteful, but interesting. I became so immersed in the first game, which I played through for the first time earlier this year, that it was hard for me notice any of the flaws that were probably there. Next time I run through it, if I ever do, I'll keep the things you listed in mind. Might change my opinion of it.
If you want a FPS, play one. I'm totally in filt's camp on this one. That and there's nothing worse than some prat babbling about how smart they are.
If he didn't like the game the first playthrough, why the fuck would he play it again 5 more times
Or, in the original version, they could have differentiated between Save Stations and Charge/Health Stations, giving you more of the former, fewer of the latter.
Save Points just suck. And not due to difficulty- due to turning otherwise challenging awesome games into needy b***hes that Require more of your time and attention. "I just can't quit you, baby."
I never originally had these problems, but at many points in the game I would get pissed at the fact that I just fell 150 fucking feet just because one little bee decided it would be funny to charge at me.
Metroid Prime can hog tie me and rape me and in return I will give love.
The part about not having the same time and passion to just endlessly play parts of a difficult game over and over until you finish it really hit home with me though. I hate to admit it, but anymore if I have a spare moment to play something I want to dive in, have fun and feel like I'm getting somewhere, if it starts to feel tedious and hard for the sake of making me buy new game controllers then I'm not as forgiving of it as I would once have been.
I've never played Prime 1 & 2, and I hated MP3, but not for any of the reasons this article stated.
@Shinryu108: This is where I hop up and down angrily pointing out how hugely exaggerated your complaints are, except you did it in a really funny and entertaining way, so WELL DONE SIR.
For all we know, he finished the game 50 times on Hard mode. Or not. Thing is, it isn't relevant.
Just most of this article was complaints about "problems" I barely noticed, or were minor. It's your opinion, sure, but I'm going to have to disagree this time.
i wont lie, im a as big a fan of the metroid series as they get, but yo do hit some good points.
yes, perhaps the game is a bit stingy with the savepoints, but then again, if you want more dificulty, dont use some of the save points, or all for that matter.
i will concur with the controls issue, because, yea, they suck.
i for one would like to have a keyboard and mouse set-up, but thats just me ofcourse.
however, i must disagree on points such as going trought the same area over an over, i mean, yea, sometimes i hate the dam game for making me go around town like a dam carrousel, but other times, i realy enjoy it. i think that part is realy up in the air.
also, very few games have the stuff to define a new genre, just as doom defined fps, and age of empires defined rts, we have metroid prime to defing fpa.
unless u have can recommend a better title for it(in which case i would surely play), i find none other than metroid prime for it.
pardon my grammar, i was too busy paying attention to the very atractive teacher i had during school as well.
You mention that he should not use some save points, or any of them, in order to increase the difficulty and better enjoy himself. While there is a little bit of merit to that, honestly, if his perspective is that the save points make the game too easy, subjectively speaking, that's bad game design.
It's not the players job to work around the design of the game to alter its play style to something that would work better. Now, whether or not it would work better isn't something I'd really like to debate, I'm just putting that out there.
See, personally, I'd recommend Bioshock. That's a damn fine first person adventure game. I mean, "FPA" is a sub-genre that didn't exist before Metroid Prime though, and we're getting into semantics here.
I apologize if I'm misunderstanding, and take the following as a general complaint: Why is it that everyone on these here Internet's has trouble accepting a difference in opinion? It seems to me that anytime anyone comes along with some sort of unpopular opinion, everyone rushes to discredit it and defend their own opinions as if this stranger's disagreeance somehow invalidates their own view point.
Especially on gaming websites. Hell! Just look at Jim's review.
Just some thoughts. Don't mind me, I'm not important. I'll go back in my cave.
you have a very good point on the save points, and pretty much everything else for that matter.
btw, jim...jim merits his own "genre", i mean, theres stiring up the hive...then theres jim stiring up the hive...
Aye, sir. He is the best at what he does. There's an air about his writing style that provokes commentary, usually from people who don't realize he's being sarcastic. I'll defend his right to give Assassin's Creed II a 4.5 wholeheartedly, that's not him stirring the hive.
His tone is what does it, and that is absolutely fine. Actually, I find it entertaining. Even when we disagree.
I wish more people felt the same.
I played through the entirety of Metroid Prime 1 and really enjoyed it - to a point. It was really great to see this developer's interpretation of classic Metroid upgrades in the 3D, "FP*" realm. The control felt a little Goldeneye-esque, but bearable enough since the weapon and visor switching and ball-rolling was pretty interesting at the time. I never bothered to scan much if I didn't have to and I hated the fetch quest for artifacts at the end, but overall I had a pretty good time.
I got Prime 2 and hated it. Hated how absolutely everything I hated from the first game was still intact and all of the fun stuff I was excited to see in the first game was just boring this time around. I think I played maybe an hour of this game in total.
I played a bit more of 3, but mostly because I found the Wii controls interesting. Until I started to having to backtrack and the controls started to be a pain in the ass and I realized this was exactly the same shit as Prime 2.
So yeah, awesome essay.
Thank you Poe. I don't completely agree with the article either but what kind of bullshit reason is "You're just not good enough,"? Kid had an opinion, he presented it well, and I think he deserves props for it.
Filt if you come through and lurk I wasn't trying to start an argument but I have to say I'm very disappointed by the apparent fanboyism in your post. I mean just because you type all your words correctly and use proper doesn't dispute the fact that you're claiming his opinion is null because he isn't good at the game. Bull. You disagree with him but you didn't just disagree. You flat out called his opinion invalid.
Anyway this was well written. It kind of makes me want to play through Prime 1&2 again since I rushed through them and never really formed a solid opinion other than "It looked pretty," and "Blonde Samus still sucks."
Fun fact, I played through 1 and 2 before school when I was a kid. I had exactly 30 minutes to do so each day. There was a save point every 30 minutes every time.

surf dtoid with 

Rising (10+)
People you follow















follow