Impressions: Plants vs. Zombies: Garden Warfare (Xbox 360)



Jordan Devore

Managing Editor

5:00 PM on 03.08.2014

A downgrade, but still absolutely worth playing

It's as if we slipped into some alternate dimension. The long-awaited Plants vs. Zombies 2 went straight to mobile, passing over PC fans, and while it wasn't bad -- not at all -- I sure lost interest.

Instead, it's PopCap's third-person multiplayer shooter Plants vs. Zombies: Garden Warfare, a thing which inexplicably exists, that has been dominating my free time. And I do mean dominating.

Chris reviewed the Xbox One version, but I've been wanting to share my thoughts on the cheaper, less-pretty Xbox 360 version since not nearly enough of you are playing Garden Warfare.

Plants vs. Zombies: Garden Warfare (PC, Xbox 360 [tested], Xbox One)
Developer: PopCap Games
Publisher: Electronic Arts
Released: February 25, 2014 (Xbox 360, Xbox One) / TBA (PC)
MSRP: $39.99 (Xbox One) / $29.99 (Xbox 360)

Now, Chris already went over the primary differences between the Xbox One and Xbox 360 versions in his review. Let's dig into those and other inconsistencies in-depth.

The big disappointment on Xbox 360 is a lack of split-screen cooperative play in the Garden Ops base defense mode. Even then, its implementation on Xbox One left a lot to be desired: co-op is only playable offline and player two can't earn coins, the currency of unlocks in Garden Warfare, or Xbox Live Achievements, the currency of life. A shame to have no co-op on 360 nonetheless.

Another lost feature is SmartGlass support. Xbox One players can influence matches from an all-seeing, all-knowing overhead view in Boss Mode. It's essentially Commander Mode from Battlefield 4, which I found to be way less entertaining than simply playing as an on-the-ground soldier. I'm sure it's the same with Garden Warfare -- fun for a few rounds and that's it.

Visual fidelity. The obvious one. While the game doesn't look as good on Xbox 360, that's not to say it doesn't look good generally speaking. Garden Warfare uses the Frostbite 3 engine, after all. The attention to detail and personality present in character models is impressive.

There are issues with texture loading, however -- when first entering maps, much of the environment will appear blurry until the textures "pop in." While this isn't always the case, when it happens, it's ugly as sin and takes you out of the experience.

I can live with all of these just fine. My big issue with Garden Warfare, and the reason I wish I were playing on PC instead, is the time spent not playing the game due to load times.

Team Vanquish, a deathmatch mode in which plant and zombie teams race to 50 kills (err, knockouts), is usually over in less than ten minutes. Many of the matches I play take five to six minutes. Then you hit a loading screen and have to wait in the lobby for a full minute, followed by another load into the next match. This adds up. Gardens and Graveyards, the final, more tactical mode in Garden Warfare tends to last longer, thankfully.

With all of that said, I don't feel like you can go wrong with any of the platforms. For its faults, the Xbox 360 game is $29.99, down from the Xbox One version's $39.99 price point. And while Garden Warfare hasn't been dated for PC yet, that'll likely be the superior version in terms of performance. (If you don't mind playing via Electronic Arts' Origin, that is.)

Do you enjoy Mass Effect 3's multiplayer or count Team Fortress 2 among your favorite online games? This is worth looking into. And for those of you with children, Garden Warfare is an excellent choice if you aren't comfortable with them playing more mature titles. But, for the love of all things holy, tell them to not permanently leave their mics on. Dumb kids...

Get comment replies by email.     settings



Unsavory comments? Please report harassment, spam, and hate speech to our comment moderators

Can't see comments? Anti-virus apps like Avast or some browser extensions can cause this. Easy fix: Add   [*].disqus.com   to your security software's whitelist.


More Plants vs. Zombies: Garden Warfare  updates:

review ( ! ) news ( 80 ) galleries ( 25 ) videos ( 25 )

I keep forgetting about EA Access. Perhaps you can say the same. It's a $4.99-per-month service for Xbox One that gives unlimited access to select games from you-know-who along with other perks like early demos. One of my fav...
Plants vs. Zombies Garden Warfare has already done right by its users by providing good post-launch support via free downloadable content, and it is continuing on that path with tomorrow's Legends of the Lawn update. The DLC...
I was prepared to get mildly annoyed at this Cheetos partnership with Plants vs. Zombies: Garden Warfare, despite the fact that it's not the first time the game has dabbled in brand-sponsored character variants. (There were ...
This week's free new update for Plants vs. Zombies: Garden Warfare adds Suburbination mode, a capture-and-defend game type in the same vein as Battlefield's Conquest and Call of Duty's Domination. Gardens & Graveyards is...
I played a ton of Plants vs. Zombies: Garden Warfare on Xbox 360, and now I'm getting into it again on PC. Still super fun and arguably one of the best shooters of the past few years. On August 19, the game comes to PlayStat...
Plants vs. Zombies: Garden Warfare comes to PC on Tuesday and if you ignored everything Chris and I said about the Xbox One and Xbox 360 versions of the multiplayer shooter, hear this: it's really good. This video showcases ...
This week, PopCap will add microtransactions to Plants vs. Zombies: Garden Warfare. We knew the day would come and, you know what? It's not a big deal. For those of you not playing this wacky third-person shooter (you're miss...
Third-person shooter Plants vs. Zombies Garden Warfare is already on Xbox One and Xbox 360, but now it's shuffling over to PC, with a North American launch date set for June 24, and Europe to follow on June 27.  The PC ...
I'm not sure which alternate dimension Plants vs. Zombies: Garden Warfare came from or how it got here but PopCap's wacky third-person shooter has been a pleasant surprise. Against all odds, the game keeps on giving: another...
I really enjoyed Plants vs. Zombies: Garden Warfare, which was a pleasant surprise amidst a sea of "me too" shooters. I enjoyed it so much in fact that I still play it, and I find myself spending more time with it l...