Destructoid is a gaming discussion community updated nearly every 20 minutes by a tight-knit group of independent dirty uncles. Get involved by creating an avatar to post comments, upload videos, create your own blog, and meet new people that love gaming.   Returning Dtoider? login!
latest posts daily recapnew releases deals features reviews podcasts videos contests  
 previews
Retro Game Challenge, Big Bang Mini, and more
Stoked
50 Cent: Blood on the Sand
The Godfather II multiplayer
The Godfather II
more previews


 reviews
Word Soup
Crayon Physics Deluxe
KamiCrazy
Tatsunoko Vs Capcom
Crystal Defenders (iPhone)
more reviews


 podcasts

Podtoid 82: The Internet: making cannibalism easier with Rev Anthony

RetroforceGO! 74 tonight: Greatest retro boss battles with Chad Concelmo

The Podcastle 25: I can't remember what we talked about with Jim Sterling

More shows from the Gamercast Network

back episodes & iTunes info




 team
Nick Chester
Editor-in-Chief
Dale North
News Editor
Anthony Burch
Features Editor
Jim Sterling
Reviews Editor
Hamza Aziz
Community Manager
Niero
Founder/Webmonkey
editors
Ashley Davis
Brad Nicholson
Brad Rice
Chad Concelmo
Colette Bennett
Conrad Zimmerman
Daniel Lingen
Dyson
Jonathan Holmes
Jonathan Ross
Jordan Devore
Joseph Leray
Tom Fronczak
Topher Cantler
Samit Sarkar
contributors
Adam Dork
Ben Perlee
Charlie Suh
Joe Burling
Justin Villasenor
Mike Ferry
Mikey
Will Maddock

Living the dream
ModernMethod


9:11 PM on 09.29.2007

28 comments

God himself may have laughed, but Neil Diamond and Sony are no fans of parody

Gameboi on Controversy

God himself may have laughed, but Neil Diamond and Sony are no fans of parody screenshot

If there's one thing that's a given in life, it has been to expect the unexpected. Live long enough, and you'll see pairings of people, places, and things that you'd never dream of being mentioned in the same sentence. Such is the humorous case of a small blog called the Hardcore Christian Gamers Association, a 70's music icon, and Sony.

While I can't officially confirm anything at this point (damn Internet Matlocks insurance), the story goes a little something like this: Drew Koehler, host of the podcast for the above mentioned site, decides that it would be humorous to create a parody of Neil Diamond's "Hello Again" song as a way of joining in on the Halo hysteria.  One of the podcast's listeners does the usual thing and uploads the song to YouTube with some Halo footage, and viola... all the ingredients for a great controversy are accounted for.

From here, the exact details get a little fuzzy, but it appears that Neil may have been offended by the content, and uses Sony as a proxy to send one of those nice cease-and-desist emails that our very own PR Nightmare could travel the circuit giving lectures about. On what grounds? Well they are going with the obvious one of "copyright infringement."

Hit the jump for more details, the supposed email response from Sony, and one nagging question that begs to be answered.. is this for real?

Not having viewed the video in question (or even heard the song), I have to wonder what the big deal is surrounding this. Is Neil upset that Weird Al Yankovic didn't think of it first? Does this really in any way infringe on an actual song (other than a similar title and words that rhyme with the original)? Do you think Sony's legal team sheds any tears at the thought of crushing something even remotely associated with a competitor's product? Most of all.... is this for real? I still have some doubts, but this is too damn good to pass up. See the reponse letter for yourself:

Dear Mr. Koehler,

Sony/ATV Music Publishing, on behalf of Stonebridge Music, is the exclusive administrator of 100% of the musical composition entitled “Hello Again” (Diamond, Lindgren) (the “Composition”).  It has recently come to our attention that you have created a parody version of the Composition entitled “Halo Again” (the “Parody”) and have subsequently distributed the Parody as a download via your website www.christian-gaming.com (the “Site”) and as part of a video currently streaming on YouTube (the “Video”).  

Please be advised that your unlicensed and unauthorized use of the Composition constitutes a serious infringement of Stonebridge Music’s copyright.  Demand is hereby made that you immediately cease and desist from streaming and/or distributing the Parody and the Video, via the Site or otherwise, and destroy all copies of the Parody and/or Video in your possession.  Failure to comply shall result in Sony/ATV pursuing any and all remedies available to it including, without limitation, litigation.

The foregoing shall not be deemed to limit or prejudice Sony/ATV or Stonebridge Music’s rights, all of which are specifically reserved.

Sincerely,

Sean Melia

Director

Business Affairs & Licensing

 

Want to know the real kicker behind this thing? Neil might have been none the wiser had he not been "supposedly" emailed a link to the song in question by the site's admin, SOG KampsAlot. Check out his comments on the page, under the original story:

September 28 2007 16:26:55
Before we take it out on Sony, who I really don't care about much at all, there is some background info everybody needs to know about this.

I've held off until I got the details of what and how everything went down regarding this; but now that I know, here goes my confession:

I found an email address that was supposedly for Neil Diamond himself, and I then emailed Neil Diamond with the link to the MP3 and a link to the YouTube video with a whimsical email stating something along the following,

<blockquote>
"We are in need of Neil Diamond to sing his song “Hello Again”, with just a few minor changes ... A rough draft of the song found here ... But it just doesn’t have that Diamond touch!"
</blockquote>

I wasn't even sure it was Neil Diamond's email address (it was "something"@Large-ISP.com"). But I took a chance, thinking it might get us some exposure, and, well, I guess it did :-(

Apparently, it was indeed Neil Diamond's address, and Neil Diamond was not amused, as I thought he would be.

I think there may be an important life lesson here, so gather 'round kids. Nintendo doesn't like its employees blogging negative stuff about the workplace, and Neil Diamond/Sony might very well not be the best place to show off your Halo parodies. Contrary to popular belief, the Internet is serious business. Now if someone would kindly send us a copy/link of the video in question. Surely it must be grand!

[TheGeekMedia, Via N4G


28 comments   |   latest by Fading_Star
Help us Weird Al, you're our only hope.... read more


 

RELATED ARTICLES

Sony: Xbox 360 is too expensive, Wii lacks features
71 comments

Sony confirmed as Killzone fanboys, thinks game will fare better than MGS4
36 comments

Sony partners with New York Yankees to put PS3s in new Yankee Stadium
22 comments

CES 2009: MTV and Sony partner to bring 'Rock of Love Bus' to PSN
16 comments

Sony bigwig wants better episodic content
10 comments



 community blogs  (32178 Dtoiders!)
post a community blog
Game with us: Friday Night Fights
Meet-ups: Dtoiders in your city
New to Dtoid? Read the survival guide



 features next 20 features





 new videos next 20 videos
CES 2009: Prototype is 'all crunch, but no munch'
CES 2009: Digital Experience! overview video
CES 2009: Sixense one-ups the Wii remote
EA anounces four MySims games, we report
Someone hasn't learned: Cooper Lawrence talks videogames on FOX again



 popular stories last month's picks
HD DVDMod your useless HD DVD Drive to BURN PEOPLE'S FACES OFF!
21 comments + 95764 views
A boot to the headEconomics or stupidity: 1UP podcast firings to save UGO $2.5 million annually?
75 comments + 22348 views
Mortal KombatMortal Kombat vs. DC Universe: More fatalities revealed
70 comments + 18826 views
Also, bewbsDirty Lara Croft gets clothes off, this is videogame news
54 comments + 14632 views
ReviewsDestructoid Review: Crayon Physics Deluxe
24 comments + 13144 views
AliensA brief and bloody history of Aliens videogames
32 comments + 12904 views
AdsPenny Arcade promotes their game with flamebait from their biggest critic
79 comments + 12880 views
Halt, criminal scum!Left 4 Dead star suspected of robbery, shot by cops
47 comments + 10966 views
Street fighterCammy screens are not intellectually stimulating
30 comments + 10960 views
Featured articlesPlaying With Others: The act of betrayal
26 comments + 10438 views



 game figures & toys  via Tomopop

more video game toys




get involved

register or login
post a blog
post a forum
enter a contest
discuss a review
contribute a news tip
write a guest editorial
support

new member's guide
login assistance
tech support
report abuse
email our editors
read our dev blog
nuclear crisis?
keep in touch

RSS feed
Twitter
Facebook
Myspace
Flickr
Game nights
Meet-ups
seriously

about us
advertising
terms of use
privacy policy
jobs at MM
buy our crap
our network

Tomopop
Japanator


Destructoid is an independently-run publication forged by our love of video games and the gaming industry's need of accountable enthusiast press
Living the dream since March 16, 2006