Destructoid is an independently-run gaming discussion community updated nearly every 20 minutes. Get started now by creating an avatar to post comments, upload videos, meet people, and create your own blog. Returning Dtoider? login!


all platforms pc/windows wii xbox 360 playstation 3 ds psp retro indie  
most recent
most popular
editors' picks
twitter updates
buy Dtoid gear
RSS feed



Dtoid staff
Nick Chester
Editor-in-Chief
Anthony Burch
Features Editor
Jim Sterling
Reviews Editor
Hamza Aziz
Community Mgr
Niero
Mr. Destructoid
Associate Editors
Brad Nicholson
Conrad
Zimmerman
Jonathan Holmes
Chad Concelmo
Dale North
Colette Bennett
Joseph Leray
Justin Villasenor
Samit Sarkar
Brad Rice
Ashley Davis
Dyson
Jordan Devore
Mike Ferry
Tom Fronczak
Topher Cantler
Qais Fulton
Contributors
Adam Dork
Charlie Suh
Joe Burling
Jonathan Ross

 
Podcasts
Rev on Podtoid
Chad on Retroforce GO!
Jim on The Podcastle

Elephant Software
Thomas Lackner

Destructoid is made by
ModernMethod


GDC is full of 'ultimately stupid' ideas says EA's Barnett
Jim Sterling07.07.08 - 7:33 AM 19 comments

GDC is full of 'ultimately stupid' ideas says EA's Barnett screenshot

EA Mythic's creative designer Paul Barnett has criticized the annual Game Developers Conference, slamming it for being a "combative" experience where narrow-mindedness and boredom runs riot. He also wants GDC to be hosted by a dancing bear wearing a fez. He never said that bit, but who doesn't want that?

"I'm not going to GDC because it's combative, it's a peacock display and it's full of people who do what I do or want to do what I do or are doing what I do and don't want me to do it anymore. It's not open-minded. It's very narrow-minded. We're all talking about the same thing. We've all sharpened our knives for years at it, so we get into … well, not a fight, but it's always about the same things.

We talk about design, mechanics, philosophy of design. All I was going to hear about was: WoW and the Activision merger. Whether Spore is going to be any good. How do I get into the games industry? Would you like a job? You're going to be fired. Why don't you start a label?

While that's interesting, it's not interesting enough. It confuses me. I have to start to explain things I find blindingly obvious. I have to listen to people who say things which I find ultimately stupid. And I have to pay attention to people I don't want to pay attention to.
That's a huge lump of disillusion if I've ever seen one. So, GDC = boring and stupid peacock display. That's surprising, as I always felt we had some good stuff coming out of that conference, and really, are other shows any better? I can't imagine E3 being anything less than all of the above. That said, until the GDC organizers get a dance instructor, a bear, a fez and the desire to make all our dreams a reality, GDC will never live up to its potential.


MORE IN OUR I got sand in my everything SECTION

Latest comment by Blue Ryd3r |view all 19 comments
I read some of the comments of people looking down on this guy and I have to wonder if any of them have ever gone to a conference before. I think this guy is just giving a frank account of his o......



Aurvantoid's Avatar
Aurvantoid at 07/07/2008 07:38

Dear Paul Barnett,

If EA Mythic would hurry the fuck up and release something actually tangible on Warhammer Online then people might actually talk to you about stuff other than the crap you just mentioned. Your going to hear about Spore and WoW (and the merger) because your section of EA hasn't done jack shit regarding WAR.

Well, except continuously delay the hell out of it. How's that for combative, ya prick.
shaun's Avatar
shaun at 07/07/2008 07:54

whats with EA this days,its like they have a opposite opinion on everything these days,and may i say that it is pretty ironic that that this "critism" comes from a company that has nothing actual good releas in a while now,so what is it what you want to show to us at the GDC mr bartnett???
i thought so...
poor sterling to write this newspost
shaun's Avatar
shaun at 07/07/2008 07:57

i meant released,jesus im so pissed that im writing engrish
glipe's Avatar
glipe at 07/07/2008 07:58

Seems to me you talk about what you want to talk about. If he's not getting what he wants from GDC it's probably a good thing he doesn't go. Other people get a lot of inspiration and knowledge from GDC and it'd be a shame to drag the party down.

I'm not condemning what he's said, a lot of it seems to be quite true, but I'd be trying to change it rather than walking away.
Cowzilla3's Avatar
Cowzilla3 at 07/07/2008 08:07

Yea but E3 is supposed to be a peacock display GDC is supposed to be where developers discuss the FUTURE OF THE INDUSTRY (load echoing voice), kind of sad if they don't get anything out of it.
RJG's Avatar
RJG at 07/07/2008 08:14

Well, EA would say that. They're not a developer, they're a purchaser, and when they've purchased, they become a whipper, and when the whip stops, they grind them, and when the actual developer is broken over the wheel of yearly sequels, they say the market has changed because the fifth game in a row didn't sell as well as the last one, so people must not like it anymore, and they dissolve the team that had so much potential in the first place, and then they buy another team, and begin again.

The only reason Wright hasn't broken yet is because he's bigger than EA, and they know it, and he sets his own terms.
loki d20's Avatar
loki d20 at 07/07/2008 08:54

Gotta agree with Paul here. Nothing comes out of GDC other than just slap in the face or slap on the back commentary that is discussed on a daily basis on the Web. It's a face-to-face version of all of the developer blogs, honestly. Kind of, hey, we're developers, we should have a conference for developers, cool! Some of them like it, cool, some of them don't, whatever. But it's not like GDC has really lead to anything greater in the MMO industry, just more talk.

And, as far as EA/Mythic releasing information on WAR, there's tons of crap out there already with almost every gameplay element other than specific class abilities spelled out in detail. And, pushing it back because they don't think they're ready is about the smartest thing any MMO company can do today. Heck, and I don't even like the game.
BattyAdroit's Avatar
BattyAdroit at 07/07/2008 09:26

So one guy's negative opinion warrants a news article?
Jim Sterling's Avatar
Jim Sterling at 07/07/2008 09:28

"So one guy's negative opinion warrants a news article?"

Yes.
Mxyzptlk's Avatar
Mxyzptlk at 07/07/2008 09:41

Will the bear's name be State 'o Maine?
Malovane's Avatar
Malovane at 07/07/2008 10:15

"I have to listen to people who say things which I find ultimately stupid. And I have to pay attention to people I don't want to pay attention to."

Welcome to the real world Mr. Barnett. Nice of you to visit.
Seamus's Avatar
Seamus at 07/07/2008 10:41

Well, EA would say that. They're not a developer, they're a purchaser, and when they've purchased, they become a whipper, and when the whip stops, they grind them, and when the actual developer is broken over the wheel of yearly sequels

LoL Paul and Mythic both are a recently bought developer, he isn't high on the totem poll in EA, it's his opinion not EA's, which he is entitled to, just how many GDC's have any of us been to, to know exactly what he is talking about.
Alexradl's Avatar
Alexradl at 07/07/2008 10:46

Dear Paul Barnett,

EA is full of ultimately stupid ideas.

Sure, he might have some relatively good points about GDC, but all of the division of EA are pretty much the same. They complain about everything.

Well put, RJG, well put.
cchance's Avatar
cchance at 07/07/2008 10:58

holy crap that guy sound arrogant as hell
timtheterrible's Avatar
timtheterrible at 07/07/2008 11:31

Is that the Blaster Master in that pic?
13thDragon's Avatar
13thDragon at 07/07/2008 12:32

That's a big ass frog.
Milkman519's Avatar
Milkman519 at 07/07/2008 13:50

More EA flamebait. Hooray! Jesus christ guys, give it a fucking rest.
listereo's Avatar
listereo at 07/07/2008 15:01

I love how one man represent EA around here.

Going back into the article, it seems that Barnett's dig is that people at GDC act like they know it all, and all that's left to work out is the details, when the industry is, at best, in a turbulent adolescence, isolated from the rest of the world. He opted to go to a completely unrelated conference his friend ran, and it was more about the kind of creativity that seems crazy and stupid to most people. And he like that more, because it gives him something new to chew on instead of muttering about network code and microtransactions.

Can't blame him. It's a wide world full of wild and new ideas, and when you've gotten used to the ebb and flow of the industry, you'll get bored by people tooting their own horns for a week. He's the kind of guy who needs to be refreshed, shuffled up. To keep the fire in his belly, he needs fresh fuel, and not spent ash.
Blue Ryd3r's Avatar
Blue Ryd3r at 07/08/2008 03:53

I read some of the comments of people looking down on this guy and I have to wonder if any of them have ever gone to a conference before. I think this guy is just giving a frank account of his own personal experience.

Also he isn't the first person to voice their displeasure for the event. It's supposed to be a place to discuss new ideas and gain new perspectives and instead it's just full of assholes trying to make it into another E3: "Lets discuss dynamic AI by talking about the game I and my studio have been working on for the past year during this entire panel"
And so you now sit through a three hour Ad. Whoopiee!

They guy had a miserable time, don't ride his ass because he told you about it.

You must be logged in to post a comment. Click here to login or create a user account now.

RELATED ARTICLES
Got gaming news?   Email:   tips@destructoid.com


community blogs (28235) members strong

Post a new community blog
October call for entries: The fear! THE FEAR!
Game with us: Friday Night Fights
Meet Dtoiders near you

popular right now
ContestsMega Man 9 giveaway contest and introducing the Mega Man Boss Maker!
326 comments + 26575 views
Things gamers doRamblings of a colorblind gamer
143 comments + 10515 views
HAHA Weird!Sony did NOT win an award for SIXAXIS
56 comments + 10090 views
Final FantasyLittleBigPlanet user creates a tribute to Final Fantasy X
62 comments + 9920 views
MusicIt only took three months, but I think I finally get Wii Music
38 comments + 9075 views
More top stories

contests & giveaways

Little Red Riding Hood BBQ winners announced: it's a man in a dress!
Mega Man 9 giveaway contest and introducing the Mega Man Boss Maker!
Final reminder: Show us your arts and crafts skills, win Mushroom Men prizes
view all contests and previous winners

games reviewed   more games

NHL 09 review

de Blob review

B-Boy review

Kirby Super Star Ultra review

Fracture review

Lock's Quest review

Dragon Quest IV: Chapters of the Chosen review
view more game reviews

new podcast shows   free on iTunes

Hey, Podtoid records tonight

RetroforceGO! episode 62: Mega Man 9

The Podcastle episode 20: Podcastle LIVE II
download back episodes

game figures & toys  via Tomopop
more video game toys and collectibles

     
Behind the wheel of Midnight Club: Los Angeles
Destructoid review: NHL 09
Xbox 360 gets two exclusive downloadable chapters for Tomb Raider: Underworld
Behind the wheel of Midnight Club: Los Angeles
Destructoid review: NHL 09
Second official trailer for NBA 2K9, which you can now play in demo form!
Nintendo waited on Wii MotionPlus tech for three years
It only took three months, but I think I finally get Wii Music
Muramasa: The Demon Blade confirmed for Wii-exclusive release
 
     
Mega Man 9 DLC round-up: Proto Man and Endless Attack mode
Cave Story coming to WiiWare this holiday season
Punch-Out!! returns! First screens and video of new Wii sequel
DS: Buy Rune Factory 2: A Fantasy Harvest Moon, cuddle free squirrel
PSP: Destructoid review: B-Boy
PHONE: Peggle to go mobile, batteries to die mid-call
Silent Hill: Homecoming misses its PC release date
Fallout 3 to respect consumers and use less evil DRM measures?
Piracy not the reason for Gears 2's Xbox 360 focus anymore?
 
         
Contribute

Post a blog
Submit a news tip
This month's theme
Video game forums
Support

Login issues
Community Blogs
Report abuse
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
Keep in touch

RSS Feed
Facebook
Myspace
Flickr
Game with us
Meet ups
Seriously

Advertising

Our software
Jobs - We're hiring!
Our Network

About Destructoid

Japanator
Tomopop
ModernMethod Publishing