Around the time of the Oscars every year, I often hear people say things like, “Who picks the winners, anyway?” When I explain that it’s the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, an organization with 6,000+ “motion picture professionals,” a few people say, “They should let the people pick ’em.” Frankly, I think it’s a good thing that life doesn’t work that way, as the general populace often doesn’t know what the hell it’s doing (e.g., American Idol).
Here’s some more evidence of that. Last night, X-Play aired an hour-long special on its “G-Phoria 2008” Awards, which are purposely set during the summer so “gamers can find respite from the heat and take advantage of time off to engage in their passion.” To be eligible, a game had to have been released between July 31, 2007, and July 31, 2008. All 19 awards were selected by viewer votes (online at G4tv.com and via text message), so I guess it’s not entirely fair for me to bitch since I didn’t voice my opinion. Whatever, I’m going to do it anyway.
You’d think that, with the window shifted to include the first seven months of this year and the last five of last year, people would’ve gotten over the whole “ZOMG Halo 3 IS THE BEST GAME EVAR!” thing -- but apparently not. So they picked it as the best game released in the past twelve months. *Sigh* Personally, I could name at least five games that are better in my opinion, but obviously, the massive cultural phenomenon that is the Halo series doesn’t give a damn about what I think.
Anyway, other winners included skate. as the Best Sports Game; Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare as the Best Online Multiplayer Game; and Turok as the Game Most Deserving of an Uwe Boll Movie. Hit the jump for the full list, and then debate its contents in the comments.
The “G-Phoria 2008” winners include:
Game of the Year
Halo 3
Favorite System
Xbox 360
Best Graphics
Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots
Best New Character
Niko Bellic - Grand Theft Auto IV
Best Party Game
Rock Band
Best Strategy Game
Sid Meier's Civilization Revolution
Best Sports Game
skate.
Best Action Game
Grand Theft Auto IV
Best Shooter
Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
Best Racing Game
Mario Kart Wii
Best Role-Playing Game
Mass Effect
Most Original
Portal
Best Online Multiplayer Game
Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
Best Downloadable Content
Rock Band
Best Handheld Game
God of War: Chains of Olympus
Best Voice Acting
Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots
Best Soundtrack
Rock Band
Game Most Deserving of an Uwe Boll Movie
Turok
Longest Lasting Game presented by Stride
Grand Theft Auto IV
But then again, what does the game industry have that's equivalent to the Academy? The ESA?
Excuse me while I throw up.
Mass Effect"
Why is that the only one I whole-heartedly agree with?
irony not intended
Because it is actually impossible to please everyone. No really. It's impossible.
It's particularly sad that Bioshock doesn't appear anywhere on that list.
I should probably pick that up sometime, though.
R.I.P. TechTV
How many times is G4 going to jump the shark?
Except this time the shark is a penis.
And they sucked it. With their mouth.
http://www.escapistmagazine.com/videos/view/zero-punctuation/8-Halo-3
I'm sure the people who watch G4 mostly are the guys who freak out over Halo and Madden, and finger bang tons of chicks, brah.
@Nand69: What's with the hate for Mountain Dew. It's a perfectly good beverage. Well, it's kind of gross, and it looks pretty gross, but come on.
Ugh.
False, Halo 3 does NOT kick ass.
I was actually half-watching while star hunting in Braid and remember hoping that anything of the other nominees not named Halo 3 would win game of the year. This is why popular vote should not be used for awards, even if the award doesn't mean anything.
I also would have picked Persona for best RPG but, again, it wasn't popular enough.
btw, thumbs up for the pic, Niero. :)
You don't give a game with entirely licensed music best soundtrack. The award should go to a game with actual music composed specifically for that game. Mario Galaxy, BioShock, Metal Gear Solid 4....all had amazing music deserving of an award.
Call of Duty 4 FYI
i voted! i voted true crime streets of la game of the year. i was gonna vote for super empire strikes back, but i figured that would be the most popular vote.
If Call of Duty 4 was the best Shooter of the year...
And Call of Duty 4 was also the best Online Multiplayer Game of the year...
....what the hell made Halo 3 get the Game of the Year title?
Then again, it's Halo. Bungie and Microsoft could put a dog turd in a box, call it Halo 4 and the fanboys would still buy it.
EPIC FAIL.
Halo 3 is a good game but is so overated and there are far better games than it.It's essentially the only worthy first-party title the Xbox has ever offered.
Why does G4 continue to do this horrible video game awards show when every year the results are disappointing ? Man, they're almost as bad as Spike Tv's.
There's no more hope left for the industry.
I was watching a bit of the replay this afternoon, the show sucked. Morgan Webb was dressed in a boring dress, which made it absolutely worthless at that point.
BASTARDS.