10:20 AM on 08.27.2010 |
|
|
PR firm Reverb Communications has come under fire from the FTC for getting its employees to anonymously write reviews on iTunes without disclosing their working relationship with the title. The company was sneakily giving its own games glowing summaries, and that's apparently considered quite shady.
Reverb has become the first "victim" of the new Internet endorsement guidelines imposed last year. The guidelines require advertising agencies to be open about their connection to the products they're endorsing, be it on a blog, via Twitter, or on iTunes. Basically, PR companies can't pretend they're "average joes" giving an honest review, like people did back in the days of snake oil salesmen.
The company has not been fined or otherwise punished, but has nonetheless agreed to remove all of its reviews from iTunes. A victory for the FTC, but should the Internet be regulated like this? It's a knotty issue, that weighs Internet freedom against consumer protection.
What do you reckon? Should Reverb have been smacked down, or should the Internet be an "anything goes" kind of place?
PR Firm Charged with Faking Game Reviews on iTunes Store [1UP]
[Update: Reverb has made an official statement. Read below for the PR firm's comments]
“During discussions with the FTC, it became apparent that we would never agree on the facts of the situation. Rather than continuing to spend time and money arguing, and laying off employees to fight what we believed was a frivolous matter, we settled this case and ended the discussion because as the FTC states: 'The consent agreement is for settlement purposes only and does not constitute admission by the respondents of a law violation.'
This issue was specific to a handful of small, independently developed iPhone apps that several team members downloaded onto their personal iPhones in their own time using their own money and accounts, a right and privilege afforded to every iPhone and iTouch user. Any iTunes user will understand that each time a product is purchased you are allowed to post one comment per product. Seven out of our 16 employees purchased games which Reverb had been working on and to this the FTC dedicated an investigation. These posts were neither mandated by Reverb nor connected to our policies. Bottom line, these allegations are old, this situation was settled awhile ago and had nothing to do with the clients that many outlets have been reporting. The FTC has continuously made statements that the reviews are “fake reviews”, something we question; if a person plays the game and posts one review based on their own opinion about the game, should that be constituted as “fake?” The FTC should evaluate if personal posts by these employees justifies this type of time, money and investigation. It’s become apparent to Reverb that this disagreement with the FTC is being used to communicate their new posting policy. We stand by the statement from the FTC that: 'The consent agreement is for settlement purposes only and does not constitute admission by the respondents of a law violation.'”
How does Nintendo go about promoting Donkey Kong Country Returns 3D? By scaring the hell out of little kids. SEGA and Gearbox have been slapped with a class action suit for Aliens: Colonial Marines, accused of lying about the game to get it sold. It was only a matter of time.
Edelson LLC has taken the case, which alleges that ... [Minor update: I moved my CPM real-world stats from the comments to the post so that its more visible]
Whether you're an aspiring writer, an established games critic, or a hopeful webmaster building your first gaming site it ...
A new advertisement for Injustice: Gods Among Us is starting into circulation and they're heading right for the comic fans by bringing in one of the more famous enthusiasts of (and contributors to) the medium, Kevin Smi...
Typically, when it comes to videogame ads at least, actors don't usually do a good job of promoting a game. That's not the case here with these SimCity ads, thankfully. Actor Adam Devine of Workaholics fame did a few promos for the game and they're all pretty funny. Fancy that.
SimCity is out this week for the PC. Are you planning on picking it up? The biggest achievement in free simulation obstacle course games featuring Xbox Live Avatars, Doritos Crash Course, has received its very own downloadable content today. Doritos Crash Course City Lights adds two new area... ZombiU is, by all accounts, a pretty decent game that uses the Wii U's GamePad in some interesting ways. It's helped breathe new life into a genre that's been in decay for the better part of a decade. And hey, if nothing else... I'm pretty sure I've lamented in the past that I don't know what the kids are into with the music anymore. So, understand that I have no idea who this "Skrillex" person is, but I'm getting the idea that he's kind of becoming ...
I enjoyed watching Robot Chicken on Adult Swim back in college, but it never felt like it had true staying power. Why new episodes are still being made, I have no clue. Then again, this is the same network that is still chur... According to a promotional ad in France, the PlayStation Vita is comparable to a woman with no head and four breasts, two of which jut agonizingly from her back like a pair of malevolent tumors.
What are we to glean fro...
|
|