#5 More Masterpieces
When the Masterpieces feature was announced for Brawl, many people thought this could be the greatest bonus in the game. The ability to play even short demo versions of the games where Brawl's cast originated from seemed too good to be true. Of course, that meant that it was.
People hoped to have a playable, time limited version of Lucas' home game Mother 3, which has yet to make it out of Japan. People hoped for demos of Pokemon Red and Blue, Pikmin, and Donkey Kong Country. People hoped, and expected, that if the Ice Climbers could have their crappy game represented in the Masterpieces collection, then more deserving characters like Olimar, Lucas and Pokemon Trainer would too.
People hoped wrong.
All of the Masterpieces have seemingly been unlocked from the Japanese version of Brawl, and the list of titles represented is pretty slim. More so, from my brief period of play with the American version of Brawl, I can tell you that two of the Masterpieces that were are on the Japanese Brawl disk are nowhere to be seen on ours. The first omission, Fire Emblem: Mystery of the Emblem, is excusable, as the game has never before been released outside Japan. But there is no excuse for Mother2/Earthbound's omission. The game was released in the United States and Europe, and even to this day has a rabid fan-base.
Maybe it will be revealed later that like F-Zero, Donkey Kong, and Super Mario World, an Earthbound Masterpiece will also be unlockable on the US Brawl disk. Even so, the fact that we American Brawl fans are having to hope that things haven't been cut from our version of Brawl, coupled with this seemingly unnecessary delay we've had to endure, is enough to grind anyone's gears.
And yet, we dream. Dream that there may in fact be more Masterpieces on our disk than there was on the Japanese version. Dream that the delay was to translate the Masterpieces for Fire Emblem, Mother 3, and Joy Mech Fight. Dream that Nintendo really loves us as much as they love Japan.
Amount of devastation this yet unfulfilled fantasy caused to the Smash Bros. community: Slim. It's not right, but it's ok.
Possibility of this dream coming true: 5%
Why: There is a strange precedent for the Japanese versions of Smash Bros. games having slightly more content than the Western versions.
#4 An Expanded Soundtrack
For the record, I think this one is insane. But still, I must report on it, because it is my solemn duty to post about Brawl as much as humanly possible.
The Smash Bros. Brawl soundtrack contains over 280 tracks. Believe it or not, that's not enough for some people. Many NeoGafers and SmashBoarders have stated that there is still music they wish had made it to Brawl. They want more tracks, from games like the GameBoy Zelda and Pokemon titles from the GBA days, from Earthbound, Mother 3, Fire Emblem, and loads of others. They have even gone loco enough to expect these tracks be made available through Nintendo's upcoming Pay and Play service.
Only the Smash Bros. community could find a way to be disappointed with the largest video game soundtrack in history.
Amount of devastation this yet unfulfilled fantasy caused to the Smash Bros. community: Slim to none. We don't need another hero (hero in this case meaning a song from Link's Awakening).
Possibility of this dream coming true: 0%
Why: Adding more songs to Brawl's soundtrack would be like giving Michael Jackson a nose job. At some point, you just can't take things any further.
#3 The characters revealed through the disk rip
Shortly after Brawl was released in Japan, some clever dick started ripping the files straight from the DVD to take a closer look at them. These files revealed many things, including the revelation that some data on the finished game is dedicated to Melee characters missing from Brawl, including Roy, Dr Mario, and Mewtwo, as well as never before seen in Smash Bros. characters Dixie Kong, Toon Zelda, Toon Sheik, Plusle and Minun.
To my knowledge, this list of data is from the first layer of the double layered Brawl game DVD. the second layer is yet to be seen. Many Brawl enthusiasts have taken to posting nothing more than the worlds "second layer" in response to any nay sayers claiming that there is no reason to hope for any additional content to be unlocked for Brawl. Strangely enough, Dr. Mario has a huge following in the Smash Bros. community, and these followers demand that he make a return.
Amount of devastation this yet unfulfilled fantasy caused to the Smash Bros. community: Enormous. It was a huge shock to the system that Melee characters with completely original move sets were cut from Brawl, while characters that are more or less clones (Falco to Fox, Ness to Lucas) still made the cut. JigglyPuff making into Brawl over MewTwo? Blasphemy.
Possibility of this dream coming true: 50%
Why: Nintendo likes to use its pre-existing successes to launch it's new features. The GBA version of Super Mario 3 had unlockable levels via E-cards. Link's Awakening DX was compatible with the Game Boy printer. It's likely that Pay and Play will involve itself with Brawl in some capacity, and downloadable characters are as good a way to do this as any.
#2 Leaderboards
Leaderboards and Achievements are the bread and butter of most XBL compatible games. It's a no-brainer that every online game is made better by the inclusion of at least one of these two features. Brawl already has Achievements, in an off-line sort of way. Other Nintendo games, like Super Mario Strikers: Charged, have leaderboards. But Smash Bros. Brawl, Nintendo's flagship title for 2008 and proof that they have not abandoned the hardcore gamer? Not so much.
Masahiro Sakurai, Brawl's producer, has said on many occasions that he believes that the inclusion of Leaderboards would actually make Brawl a worse game. In so many words, he has stated that leaderboards are only fun for the top ten players on the board, and for everyone else they are just a downer.
Well I got news for you, big poppa Sakurai. I am more than capable of protecting myself from experiences that are not pleasurable to me, and if I don't like a feature in a game, I just don't use it. If Brawl had leaderboards, and these leaderboards made me sad, I'd make the decision myself to not look at them. However, I doubt they would make me sad, because even if I were ranked 5,000,002 out of 5,000,003 people on the board, I'd still feel good knowing I was better at Smash Bros. than at least one other human being on planet Earth. That's better than I feel now, when the only people I know that will play Melee with me are my friend's kids, and they all kick my ass.
I believe that Leaderboards do not please only the people on the board's top ten. I believe they please everyone but the people in the boards bottom ten. Why is it that all of us have to suffer just to protect the egos of those ten horrible Brawl players?
Amount of devastation this yet unfulfilled fantasy caused to the Smash Bros. community: Moderate. Most people who love Smash Bros. enough to play competitively put on their own tournaments anyway. Most Smash Bros. Fanboys say that Brawl's lack of leaderboards is more embarrassing to be associated with than it is a cause for a genuine nervous breakdown.
Possibility of this dream coming true: 25%
Why: Nintendo of America could make this change in their localization of Brawl. Leaderboards, and online gaming in general, are much more significant to the Western market than they are in Japan. The few people at Nintendo America I've had the privilege of talking to have stated they'd like to see more online features added to Brawl as time goes on, Leaderboards being one of them.
#1 Mega Man

There were so many reasons to think that Mega Man would be in Brawl. He was reportedly the #2 requested 3rd party character in Sakurai's online poll, second only to Sonic. He is the mascot for Capcom's longest running series, and unlike Snake and Sonic, almost all of Mega Man's relevant games were on Nintendo consoles. He'd look right in a Smash Bros. game. Sakurai said there would be "two or three" 3rd party characters in Brawl. Mega Man is one of the most well recognized characters in gaming history, and has appeared in even more core games than Mario. Mega Man has even already been in not one, not two, but three cross-over fighting game series, the Marvel Vs Capcom series, SNK Vs Capcom, and Onimusha: Warlords. The list of reasons why Mega Man was a shoe in for inclusion in Brawl is as long as my arm.
Yet, about a month before Brawl was to be released in Japan, Kenji Inafune of Capcom Japan came out to say that he'd like Mega Man to be in Brawl, but that no such arrangement had been made. There was no trace of Mega Man on the files revealed from the Brawl disk rip. It was the last nail in the coffin for Mega Man's inclusion in the game.
Amount of devastation this yet unfulfilled fantasy caused to the Smash Bros. community: Life threatening. Many more casual Smash Bros. fans stated they were no longer interested in buying Brawl when the news came out that Mega Man wasn't in the game. Hordes of Capcom fans previously interested in Brawl went soft on the title, returning to their marathon sessions of Marvel Vs Capcom 2. Fans of Mega Man were hungry like wolves to see him in Brawl, and there is no one more pissy than an hungry wolf.
Possibility of this dream coming true: 0%
Why: Mega Man is a third party character, the game is already out, and no data related to him was found on the Brawl disk.
So, that's my list. What did I leave out? What omission from Brawl are you grieving about?
Other posts from this series:
Seven days to Smash Bros. Brawl: Hands on coverage of the WPI Brawl Tournament
Six days to Smash Bros. Brawl: Top five Smash Bros alternatives
Waste of a good balloon...
yeah. I wanted Mega Man in Brawl.
Furthermore, I also want Travis TouchDown in Brawl.
Nintendo's giving us a happy fun package, but its unfortunate that the fans see so much potential that isn't being fulfilled.
:[ mega-man..
Mega Man not being in Brawl was a definite downer for me. I freaking LOVE Mega Man.
...still waiting on Legends 3, Capcom!
I think we're all disappointed in the lack of WHY PENIS WHY. Also, the characters need more muscle. LOTS more muscle.
Hell, I don't even play Mega Man, and I felt a sense of loss we he was de-confirmed. He's basically just Samus with a penis, which is something we all want...well, we don't, but...still, he should be in the game.
As for complaining about the soundtrack, while I can't defend the quality of all the songs on there, do we need to repeat that there are over 300 tracks featured in the game!? And there are some fantastic tracks in their too (see: Stickerbush Symphony, Butter Building, Yoshi's Story Ending, Tetris A/B, and many more).
It will still kick ass.
Doctor Mario must return. They take out both of my best characters (MewTwo and Doctor Mario), and replace them with ANOTHER fox clone and King Dedede? Its a travesty.
Two minor quibbles:
1. "The GBA E-reader had unlockable levels via E-cards." I believe you meant to say Super Mario Bros. 3 instead of E-Reader.
2. "Link's Awakening DX was compatible with the GameBoy camera." Replace Camera with Printer.
The lack of Mega Man certainly tops my list. It wouldn't be so bad if friggin' SNAKE weren't in the game. Not that I hate Snake's inclusion at all, I'm glad he's in, but seriously, you spelled out quite clearly why Mega Man makes much more sense from a fan perspective.
Shoot!
While I think the mourning of Mega Man is universal, you could probably just make number 1 "My personal pet character that I would always mention in Brawl threads."
Mine was truly a pipe dream, with ~0% chance of happening from the very beginning, but I really, really wanted Magus of Chrono Trigger in on this action.
I would have been happy about Mega Man...but you know, I've wanted Pit in Super Smash Bros. since the first of the series. So my dreams have already been fulfilled.
Want to make my day brighter? Bring in Mega Man, Simon Belmont, and Arthur (Ghouls N' Ghosts version). I'm a happy bastard then.
I plan on loving my gift horse for many years.
Let's see. I'm in mourning for:
Metroid II DX on GBC
Commander Keen: The Universe in Toast (It was scheduled for release in '92).
More Mario Bros. 3 E-Reader cards.
The Metroid movie.
Sheng Long.
MKII Kano.
Jigglypuff was so much better than Mewtwo it's not even funny. Mewtwo was too similar to Samus and worse in almost every way. Puff's closest match was Kirby and only because of the number of jumps and their pink marshmallowy appearance.
I sincerely weep for the lack of Gusty Gardens music from Galaxy in Brawl. It boggles the mind.
i agree with tears, but i would have liked geno/megaman a million times more than "ROBOT"
This countdown... it's vaguely familiar to me... I've seen something like this before somewhere, but where?
I wanted megaman so bad :(
Extra downloadable characters at some point would be gold
The fact that there is only 2 3rd party characters in Brawl is a downer for me.
My number one would be Little Mac.
...I shouldn't complain, (well, those who seen my blog seen that I have </shameless plug>) but I was really hoping for Little Mac's inclusion. Hell, even I thought the Animal Crosser had a chance.
Oh well, you can't win them all.
Jaren, you saw this, right?
You'll get yours, Sheep. I promise you that.
Tribute will be paid, to both you and Blindside your your ultimate Smash fandom.
Also, now that you've gone back and corrected those, GameBoy Printer should be 3 words.
A New Challenger Ranked Cpt. Dick
Totally agree with number one. Samus vs. Mega Man = Win
Challanger, next time I screw up that badly that many times, gmail me at tronknotts@gmail.com and let me know direct.
The children shouldn't have to see us fight like this.
"JigglyPuff making into Brawl over MewTwo? Blasphemy."
LOL, wrong. Jigglypuff deserved to be in. So did Mewtwo, but not Ice Climbers. I'll show you how wrong you are when I rip you apart with the 'Puff, Holmes.
I like how you used gmail as the verb there. (Someone pass the butter because I'm on a roll!)
Haha, will do. I'm not trying to be a dick but nitpicking in the comment makes me feel like one, and isn't relevant to the convo.
I think what's really disappointing about Brawl and online Wii games in general is that online play in general is much more of a hassle on the Wii than on the DS. This seems counterintuitive to me.
@ Nihon-You're on!
And yeah, come to think of it, I was a little ruff and stuff on that Smash Bro Puff.
See what I did there?
Megaman in SNK vs Capcom?
lol wut?
i guess maybe you're reffering to that turd of a card game "Card Fighters clash"
but games like that don't really count, do they?
You know what dark horse I thought would make it in, and I guess this makes my actual pipedream MORE FEMALE BRAWLERS:
Lip!!! I thought she'd get in for sure!!! At least her theme is pretty wicked in Brawl.
-sigh-
@ RAB: I think he was referring to Zero in SVC Chaos, though Card Fighters is another possibility, while not really a fighting game.
What SchickOuttaShape said. Too many penii, I think it's called.
@ a new challenger
well i mean...
thats zero tho
AHHH--HAAAA!!
You're Tron Knotts.
I AM ON THE BALL.
enter requisite slowpoke picture here
@ RAB:
True. Does this mean I look like a dick for a 3rd (4th?) time in the comments?
Knowing about the data for old but unused characters left on the disc is kinda interesting. It's like KOTOR II all over again, except I can't see how any reasonable person would feel like this roster was seriously lacking. I'm sure those characters were cut early on and not primarily due to budget/time/other business constraints. Except for Mewtwo, the cut Melee characters are all clones as well. Yeah, they brought some clones back, but there were good reasons for cutting the ones they did (representation of series among them... sure, Mario is big, but does he really need another clone when there are a good number of other Mario Bros. characters playable?)
I understand people not liking leaderboards but wouldn't most people playing brawl want to see themselves competing against others around the world? as big as this game has come, i'm sure no one would even feel bad if they were last. They're still reconized and it's for more improvement for them to get better...which leads to more brawl playtime. Something nintendo wants at this point.
And the Mega Man diss is by far the biggest Brawl disappointment. It's in a way, a shitfest of Sakurai's head for not even bothering to try to get some Mega Man action in Brawl. If anything, he probably should've been announced way before Snake was considered. Even if Kojima begged the man to put him in. I will enjoy Brawl, but not as much as charging up the Blue Bomber's buster gun. I mean come on, turning into MMX would've been a easy final smash. or calling out his good ole K-9 robo friend to dash around the stage (or any of his many forms.) Hell. Even Protoman could've made an appearance in his Final smash...or as an Assist trophy.
All in all I agree on all of this besides the soundtrack bit. I kinda wish they added a better list of Sonic tracks from the original 4 games.
Mega Man blows.
That said, I'm sad he's not in the game, because I was looking forward to beating the crap out of him, with every single other character in Brawl.
@ a new challenger
i mean...
1st time I noticed
also, where the FUCK is my BANJO??
thats what I'M mourning about
[img] http://www.freewebs.com/kongo_jungle/Banjo%20and%20Kazooie.jpg [/img]
Dexter, I think there is something wrong with you. I think I need to have an intervention with you regarding your feelings towards Mega Man. Seriously, the fact that you don't like Mega Man 2 means something. Did you have a good relationship with your mother? :)
Um..... the masterpiece series.... are demos of the games..... thrown in there as 'commercials' for the available games on the virtual console
the soundtrack is SO so big that it seems ludicrous to complain, some songs would HAVE to be omitted, its just a matter of priority...
Not all characters made the cut, mewtwo is by far the only one that boggles me.... but he would have been similar to lucario.... right? in any case the DLC is not really a possibility what with the minute wii hard drive and everything
leaderboards ranks etc.... um go pick up a book or get some outside air...
megaman's exclusion does NOT upset me in the elast....
mach rider
black shadow
black knight's exclusions do....
PLUS.... Ryu would have been the nominal capcom rep...
Needs more Geno.
Mega Man would have been cool but I would just feel like im Samus...but shorter and blue....and something else i cant quite put my finger on.
GENO on the other had would have just made the smash series like 100x better just because he showed up. =D
damn oh well BRAWL will still be fun =D
WOW 50% chance for MOAR CHARACTERS!!!
I really hope this dream comes true. I want King K. Roll in BRAWL.
King K. Roll vs. Bowser = EPIC!!!
wow..
I must be the only one not caring for a Geno appearance.
Kirby looks damned good in that magaman hat he should steel it.
Then again nintendo ddi not listen or take the option to add the most important feature of the game.
Put characters and Stages for brawl on the wiiware store.
nintendo could have charged like $5 for smash bros brawl characters and poepl would pay they would have made tons of money but they did not do this.
Nintendo can not be that stupid to not charge people wii points cards to download characters it is free money.
Every body would pay $5 for 3rd party characters or at least some money. Mega man Bonk bomberman what ever nintendo could partner up and make tons of cash chargeing to download smash bros content.
ANd one more thing on the offical bionic command page podcast the megaman creator him self said nintendo never asked him to let megaman in brawl and all they had to do was ASK him. but they did not.
(listen here it's the christmas 2007 episode http://bioniccommando.com/en/podcasts)
IF nintendo added code to let download and expand content in the game(and they should have that option unless they are stupid and do not want free money) Megaman could be downloaded.
Shin Oni i totally agree about the Sonic songs that made it into Brawl...
Masterpieces - We're lucky to have any, honestly
Music - Are you fucking kidding me? This game is like a smorgasboard of fanboy audio goodness
Disk RIp - Sorta spoiled all the hope
Online Leaderboards - A better online strategy to begin with would have been a good idea
Mega Man - Now this I agree with
Number 1 for me was NO RIDLEY for playable character
Don't worry, I'll always be your 5,000,003
I'm with Chad. Disliking Megaman is a sign of mental illness.
P.S. When will all this Brawl crap be over? Overrated game is overra