GAMESREVIEWS
Rising (10+)
Notable (20+)
Popular (30+)
Promoted (Front Paged!)
People you followTaggedGeneral - Opinion/EditorialCommunity ReviewsOff-topicCommunity PodcastersBloggers Wanted ResponseLetters to Dtoids EditorsGet InvolvedGeneral BadassnessJoin a Live Stream EventListen to CommunitoidJoin a Playdate EventCompete in a Contest
First look: The Testament of Sherlock Holmes
The Sherlock Holmes series has been more or less off of my radar completely, and they've been around for several different iterations (six games in total). The series has always been strictly PC, though the most recent title was also a late port to consoles. I love adventure games and have fond memories of many of the really old ones, but it's rare that we see many examples of the genre with its generally slower pacing and plodding story development that turns off many console gamers. When L.A. Noire hit store shelves and managed to top the sales charts in the first month of its release, it became apparent to developers that the face of the market had finally changed. Console gamers had grown a little weary of twitch-based shooters and were willing to try something different. Granted, L.A. Noire didn't exactly carve the niche on deep adventure games as it still relied on driving and shooting segments to keep the interest of console gamers -- though surprisingly the greater number of players grumbled about these segments and found the actual sleuthing and narrative twists and turns of the story to be much more appealing. Those same players may find a lot to like in Frogware's The Testament of Sherlock Holmes; it's being developed as a much deeper adventure experience than anything seen on consoles yet.
The Testament of Sherlock Holmes (Xbox 360, PlayStation 3, PC) The first item of interest I noticed on this hands-off demo is how incredibly detailed the environments in the game are. Frogwares CEO Waël Amr explains to me that in the past, the team has always been limited in reaching the PC market by trying to aim for a middle ground with PC owners, so that the specs have been lowered to match the greater share of the market. With this latest game that is being developed with the current generation of consoles in mind, the development team has finally been able to really focus on polishing the graphics and creating the adventure game they've always wanted to. As Waël takes the controller and guides Sherlock Holmes around the first environment, so many little details are difficult to ignore. A fish tank sits near the center of the room, and light plays across it beautifully. The arched doors leading into the room are intricately woven and incredibly accurate to the era. Everything about the environment demands a closer look, which is certainly a good thing as this is a game all about sleuthing. The character models are quite detailed as well, down to Holmes' layered wardrobe and bemused expression.
Waël shows me a hint system that recalls the help system in L.A. Noire. With the press of a button, small question mark icons pop up in areas where more clues can be found. The hint system cannot be pressed all of the time during an investigation, and it generally takes 15 seconds until it can be refreshed. This is in the interest of bringing the series to a wider audience, as previous Sherlock Holmes games were at times incredibly challenging. The gameplay generally progresses as you gather clues and evidence in every form you're able to discover, from written material and environmental cues to actual objects that you gather in your inventory. As you gather clues, you eventually piece together the evidence to come to a deduction. After briefly meeting an Inspector Banks who is replacing Lestrade as the main competition to Holmes, the case that we've been exploring involving a stolen necklace is wrapped up. Waël skips the game ahead to the next day, in which the first clue to where the story is heading comes about in a newspaper article calling into question Holmes' character by way of the proper return of a stolen pearl necklace. The main premise of The Testament of Sherlock Holmes comes in the desire of the Frogwares development team to truly explore Holmes as a character. In previous games as in Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's books, the cases were always about truly devious criminals. In this game, as you get further into the storyline, Sherlock Holmes takes increasingly darker approaches to solving crimes, up to a point where he commits murder.
Waël tells me that you actually play the game as both Holmes and Watson, and as more events happen that call into question the nature of Sherlock Holmes' character, you take on the role of Watson and are required to figure out if the famous detective is capable of such brutal actions or if something deeper is at play. As this storyline is entirely original, the characters and events found within are also not necessarily canon. This also gave the development team more freedom to depict grisly murder scenes, as the murdered characters are entirely fictional as well. During the next sequence, Holmes tells Watson he has an immediate appointment with a famous bishop. Upon arriving, he discovers that the bishop has been the victim of a murder most foul. This part of the demo also shows where the game has potential to really shine. The grisly murder of the bishop is so incredibly detailed that I almost had to look away. The bishop's fingers were smashed and bent, and that was only the beginning of the torture put upon him. Yet I continued to watch in fascination as Holmes gathered clues and went about his usual sleuthing business. Waël opened up the inventory at one point to show me how you can closely examine every object that your character collects, and I found myself a bit squicked out at the fact that Holmes had collected a mysterious lopped off finger. It hovered in the inventory space with such realistic detail that I really had to wonder who would keep an errant finger just sitting in their pocket.
Though this is still a work in progress and not all of the voices have been put into the game, the voice acting that I did hear was fairly decent. I'm no expert on Sherlock Holmes or on British accents, but nothing the characters uttered stuck out as odd or grating, and fell pretty much in line with how you'd expect the characters in a Sherlock Holmes story to speak. The demonstration was relatively brief and Waël skipped through a lot of dialogue and cutscene material to get to the key elements of the game that he wanted to show. Despite this quick whirlwind of a walkthrough, everything from the game's intricately detailed environments to the intriguing storyline convinced me that this game is definitely a game to keep an eye out for. If you enjoyed the adventure and discovery elements of L.A. Noire's campaign, you will find a lot more to dig into in The Testament of Sherlock Holmes. Did you know? You can now get daily or weekly email notifications when humans reply to your comments.
Legacy Comments (will be imported soon)i hope this turns out better than la noire. which was just a cake walk. and nothing you did changed the story in anyway. i want different endings, out comes etc if i do something wrong. i dont want the normal story to just progress no matter how bad of a detective i am. I love these adventure games. The original Xbox got a lot of these, like Still Life, both Syberia titles, Dreamfall, etc. Sounds interesting. I am getting into adventure games again so I will make sure to keep an eye on this one. Thanks for the preview. I also hope it provides more challenge than Noire did. What I really wanted from that game was a Sherlock Homes adventure to begin with! 10:30 PM on 05.22.2013 Raise your badger children in Might and Delight's ShelterLife as a mother badger doesn't strike me as something that would be particularly easy, but conflict sure does make for an interesting story. Pid developer Might and Magic is going where no one to my knowledge has gone befor...
7:00 PM on 05.22.2013 WildStar's Paths accomodate specific MMO play stylesThe new MMO on the block, WildStar, is gearing up for its release this year, and the developers at Carbine Studios are cranking out new details as we near that. As if making choices in MMO games weren’t tough enough, C...
11:00 AM on 05.20.2013 I want to marathon The Last of Us but I'm scaredI love to play some videogames in a single sitting. Some call that "marathoning." Survival horror games are especially satisfying when played this way. I've done this with all of the Fatal Frame and Silent Hill titl...
11:00 AM on 05.18.2013 Review: The Starship Damrey"This game contains no tutorials or explanations. Part of the experience is to discover things for yourself." Thus reads the disclaimer when you fire up a new game of The Starship Damrey, Level-5's atmospheric sci-fi adventur...
12:30 PM on 05.16.2013 Launch trailer for Guild02's The Starship DamreyThe first in Level-5's Guild02 triple pack, The Starship Damrey, arrived on the 3DS eShop earlier today for $7.99. A new trailer for the moody sci-fi adventure game has surfaced, featuring choice words from game designer Kaz...
12:15 PM on 05.16.2013 Mayhem Bundle spreads the anarchy, indie styleOn the cusp of a number of PC summer sales, Indie Royale has released another mostly-fantastic indie game compilation. Known as the The Mayhem Bundle, players will get five indie titles that sufficiently "bring the pain" thr...
8:00 PM on 05.15.2013 Capcom explains digital-only Ace Attorney: Dual DestiniesWhen Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney - Dual Destinies leaves Japan this fall, it'll be available exclusively through the 3DS eShop. This reality of the publishing business has been met with backlash from some percentage of fans ...
1:45 PM on 05.15.2013 Ace Attorney - Dual Destinies gets a Japanese web demoCapcom has finally slapped a proper localized title onto Ace Attorney 5, hereby known as Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney - Dual Destinies, and will be bringing it out West this fall. Unfortunately, it will be an eShop-only relea...
5:00 PM on 05.14.2013 Review: Reef ShotI've never been scuba diving, though I imagine it can be quite the relaxing affair. Checking out the reefs, the fish, and just marveling at what is essentially a whole other world sounds pretty wonderful. It would stand to re...
5:15 PM on 05.13.2013 Take that! Ace Attorney - Dual Destinies out this fallFormerly known only as Ace Attorney 5 in the west, the upcoming game in the wacky lawyer adventure series has a new name: Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney - Dual Destinies. Not only that, but it will see its digital release in t...
| timeline following: |
| 5:00 PM on 11.22.2012 Review: The Testament of Sherlock Holmes |

It seems as if Sherlock Holmes is more popular than ever; whether it's Robert Downey Jr.'s slow-mo charmer, Benedict Cumberbatch's gruff genius, or Johnny Lee Miller's American-based version of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's detect...more
| 8:30 PM on 12.21.2011 Testament of Sherlock Holmes vid has a lovely ambiguity |

I love a good mystery and, as a result, I'm a big fan of Sherlock Holmes stories. I haven't played a game yet which I felt did a truly great job of putting me into a Holmes mystery, but The Testament of Sherlock Holmes ...more
| 6:15 PM on 08.30.2011 Have more Sherlock Holmes screenshots |

Round two of the Testament of Sherlock Holmes screenshots are in and the game still looks good. The Testament finds the detective unable to solve a crime that paints him as the main suspect. As he begins to look more guilty h...more
| 3:00 PM on 07.24.2011 Sherlock Holmes reveals himself in 4 new screenshots |

The fine fellows of Focus Home Interactive have seen fit to share with us four new screenshots for The Testament of Sherlock Holmes, the new detective game being developed for the PS3, 360 and PC. Developer Frogwares wo...more
| 7:39 AM on 05.23.2013 Grand Theft Auto V collector's edition, pre-order bonuses |
Rockstar has today announced the obligatory collector's edition and pre-order bonus offerings for Grand Theft Auto V. All pre-orders will gain players an Atomic Blimp, a blue and yellow atrocity in which one can soar above th...more
| 5:00 AM on 05.23.2013 Far Cry 3's map editor updated with Blood Dragon content |
Mark IV style mutha f*ckas! Far Cry 3's map editor was just updated to include Blood Dragon's neon packed designs. This is just for the buildings and stuff, and doesn't include the creatures like the actual Blood Dragons. The...more
| 1:00 AM on 05.23.2013 Poker Night 2 now available for iOS |
Telltales' Poker Night at the Inventory 2 is now available for iOS devices. The poker title will work on anything iPad 2 and up, or iPhone 4 and up. And like the PC counterpart, this one is going for $4.99 as well. On the fence? Go read our official review to see what we thought of Poker Night 2.more


surf dtoid with 