Quantcast


EU follows Germany's bootsteps on road to game censorship photo

According to this story found on Reuters, Franco Frattini (the EU Justice and Security Commissioner) has decided that Germany has the right idea about violent games. Apparently the rest of the EU has been too lenient regarding the sale of games to minors in the past, so Frattini (whose name could only be more Italian if it was "Earnesto Spaghetti-Os") believes the entireity of the EU should create a uniform set of rules regarding violent games. Of course, Europeans still routinely give copious amounts of alcohol to minors, but alcohol has never been proven to cause erratic driving or violent behavior, right?

It goes without saying that the new, uniform rules wouldn't be less stringent than what is currently in place. In Germany, to buy a game considered "too violent", you have to offer sexual favors to a leper and pray that he doesn't steal your skin to replace his rotting carapace. Frattini thinks this kind of hoop-jumping is necessary to keep kids away from the dangerous opiate of video games.

It seems that Europe is sprinting headlong into becoming a continent wide nanny-state. These "morality enforcement" actions, along with some of the more Orwellian things that have been going on in the UK and other countries, have made America's fight against ultra-conservatives seem tame by comparison. The next time the President tells the media that his god backs the war in Iraq, thank that same god that you can still head down to the local Best Buy and pick up a copy of Dead Rising (without getting an itchy rash or a recurring colony of oral crabs).








More gaming stories around the web. Got news? Submit yours to tips@destructoid.com



Post a comment! You can also post a photo below:

Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

25 comments | showing # 1 to 25
prev next

Alex's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 04:54
Alex
I will state my opinion here, because i am German:

We have many laws for younger people, like me, if we want to buy new games or movies.. there are really bick buttons on every dvd which is for 18+ ! But just yesterday, i bought a movie which is 18+ ;) (I am 17).

But: The stores dont care about it at all .. the thing is:
They think violent video games makes us young people to murders. I could buy a softair weapon to injure people and learn shooting without any problems. But they think that the video games teach us to kill people. We have a mouse and a keyboard, so we can kill people? Thats so fucking stupid. I hate this.
There were two (2!!!) kids who killed some teachers and pupils in a school. They both played Counter Strike 1.6.
We have 80 Million People living in Germany, 2 of them are making this shit. i think about 20% of the people in germany already played cs 1.6 or a game like that.. now because of these 2 little asses EVERYBODY IN GERMANY!! will get harder rules for these games.
So, when i am 18, i dont want rules that forbid me to play the games i want. Everybody who is 18 and above, even 50 years old, are not allowed to play these games if germany thinks they can stop it.
The only thing that they are doing is: Everybody will just download the US Versions of the games. Thats all.

God Damn i am so fucking pissed.

(I told you i am from Germany, so i am sorry about the bad grammar)
jimobjambo's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 05:22
jimobjambo

In December Frattini's been already slapped because of his outbursts on this subject. Viviane Reding, commissioner for the information society and media, said: "It is...very unfortunate that my services were not pre-consulted before your letter to the Ministers of Interior was sent out,". She was referring to the PEGI self-regulation system, which actually is been now enforced by Italy as a useful tool in the new law the Italian government is tuning right now. That's why Frattini's new crusade looks pretty odd to me... No one is talking about censorship or "blocks" on contents.

for more informations: http://www.theregister.co.uk/2006/11/24/reding_said_to_frattini/
5lectro's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 05:35
5lectro
"Europeans still routinely give copious amounts of alcohol to minors"

Wait, what?
tehuberone's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 05:38
tehuberone
yeh its odd lectro.
Alex's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 05:40
Alex
yes, you can buy as much alcohol in germany as you want :P no problem. u can get drunk so easy...
Alex's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 05:40
Alex
only problem: i dont like alcohol -.-
tehuberone's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 05:49
tehuberone
Yeh prostitution's legal there.

wait isn't legal in Vegas to?
5lectro's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 05:51
5lectro
Italy's erratic driving finally explained? More after the break.
tehuberone's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 05:58
tehuberone
*isn't it*

damn i need some sleep.
Cruds's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 07:00
Cruds
No prostitution is only legal in the Netherlands so is marijuana and 16 is the legal age to serve alcohol. Anyway this is old news, this the same guy who wanted to ban rule of rose in Italy.< part1 >
< part2 >
Lodin's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 07:03
Lodin
Thank God Norway's not a member of the EU. Hopefully we'll be able to bypass this bullshit.

Or maybe they'll just give us the same watered down titles that the rest of the Euros have to suffer with...
CaffeinePowered's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 08:37
CaffeinePowered
EU - Its ok to give people under 18 alcohol, but no violent videogames

US - No alcohol for you, go run a hooker over in GTA

Both make so much sense
B__'s Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 10:51
B__
If "mature" games are more heavily regulated in Europe, does this change the incentive structure for developers? In other words, how much would sales suffer in Europe?
tonymas13's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 11:05
tonymas13
You know per capita Italy has way less drunk driving accidents and way less car accidents in a year then the US right? Sure it may be legal to drink in Italy but kids are taught to drink in moderation, and only see it as something to be done at the dinner table. Not an all night binge while your parents are away on vacation. Most of the kids there don't even drink or have as much of a desire too as kids here. Kids in the US want to do it or try it just to be rebellious.
DurandalAI's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 12:26
DurandalAI
"Of course, Europeans still routinely give copious amounts of alcohol to minors, but alcohol has never been proven to cause erratic driving or violent behavior, right?"

Damn good bashing.

Of course, Americans still let you drive vehicles without any proper instructions whatsoever 5 years before they deem you mature enough to handle a bud and sell you a sniper rifle 3 years before you can have your first Tequila shot. But Guns have never been proven to hurt poeple and no one was ever run over by some 16 year old high schooler, right?
maximum0v3rdriv3's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 12:31
maximum0v3rdriv3
wait just a second. is this really censorship or are they just trying to limit exposure to minors? Cause if it's the latter i have no problem with minors not being able to buy "mature" games. i don't see this as a problem.

however if it'sjust broad bans. then i have a problem. Limit exposure to the kiddies. i'm 22. i should be able to play games were a brutally kill people. Cause thats my reward for putting up with 22 years worth of bullshit.
Darren Nakamura's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 12:47
Darren Nakamura
As I understand it, maximum0v3rdriv3, the way Germany handles violent video games is they require that they not be displayed in the stores, so that you have to go up and ask for the game in question in order to be sold it. This leads to significantly lower sales, and because of this, many publishers choose not to release the game at all in Germany. So in effect, Germany has the games banned.
maximum0v3rdriv3's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 12:55
maximum0v3rdriv3
@Dexter

I see. They won't even allow the "porn room" type deal where all the "adult" videos are in a room where only adults are allowed to go? Thats shitty. I suppose that does drop sales.

Still I haven't heard very many people throwing up better ways to keep children from getting these games. It's all neat to bitch and moan about censorship. But if you don't like how things are you need to make a better way of doing it and present that way to the people in charge. Cause obviously they don't want kids to have this stuff and they don't care how thats done.
DurandalAI's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 13:00
DurandalAI
This is correct Dexter, to circumvent this a lot of publishers choose to alter games. Blood gets removed. Or for the Example of San Andreas they removed the blood, people did not drop any money when you killed them and other stuff. While this sucks, there is actually no problem whatsoever to get your hands on an european copy of a game when your 18. If all this would apply to the whole EU though it could get harder. As long as there are loads of countrys in Europe which are not in the EU though it will be not much of a hassle to grab one of those PAL Copies. Small Retailers here make a living out of importing anyway so for the serious Gamer there will be no change at all.
DurandalAI's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 13:13
DurandalAI
@ maximum: You CAN show the Games in Adult-Only Areas. You just cannot advertise them or sell em @ Malls and such which are accessible to minors. Which basically kills the success chance of a game.
maximum0v3rdriv3's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 13:38
maximum0v3rdriv3
@DurandalAI

I don't see a problem then. Children shouldn't be exposed to it. It may inconvice store owners into droping the product, fine. The system needs to change. You don't show barebreasted titty mags in public areas, you don't need to show gore fests video games there either. The industry will just have to cope and evolve. Finding out ways to advertise other then just sitting on a shelf. However i don't see this shelf advertizing dying out since adults could very well still into into adult entertainment areas if the store has enough fore-thought to make one.
DurandalAI's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 13:47
DurandalAI
Im with you all the way here m8. This censoring hype is as overrated as the whole gaming makes you a killer fad.
brad drac's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 14:12
brad drac
I said this the last time someone posted this topic, I'll say it here again. Europe is not one country. Every memeber state has completely different laws, and there are fairly few that are legislated for the whole union. Most countrys here have the age of drinking set at 18, which I think is reasonable. I see little problem with having it at 16 though, seeing as most people are drinking at that age anyway. In some ways it's better, as the main cause of underage drinking is kids wanting to rebel.

As I also said before, I'm not worried about this. The EU's legislature system just isn't for this kind of thing, and I don't see many people taking this guy all too seriously. He probably just saw how popular anti-gaming crusades were in the states, and tried to hitch a ride on their coattails.
Jelster's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 15:46
Jelster
If you have a ratings system people should be held accountable for sticking to it. As its difficult for parents to monitor their children 24/7 it makes sense that retail should bare the brunt of the enforcement.

BTW - USA isn't in an Orwellian nightmare already? Just because you can buy Dead Rising and don't see camera's on the street you actually think your privacy and freedom is secure. Guess you're lucky they can't vote Bush in for a third term and get the draft reinstated.
Akujiki's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/11/2007 18:22
Akujiki
Perhaps the point is being missed that very few people in the EU are speaking against videogames. The proposed legislation is just that. As mentioned by Jimobjambo, Frattini did get a slap on the wrist for his comments. The general consensus is that games have no worse an effect than any other form of media. Check out the BBC website (especially the radio4 section) for some very interesting and balanced articles on the subject. The legislation regarding videogames is very far from a reality and at best the ramblings of a rather sidelinded politician trying to grab some of the limelight, whereas not a week goes by without a new bill to limit the sale of videogames being drafted in the US.
The rise of the nanny-state has in all fairness been (in Britain at least) a greater leaning towards American ideals. Only since the ill-fated war on terror and Blair's love affair with Bush have such ideas as a constitution or Britishness tests entered discussion. These are the things that encroach upon our freedoms, yet they are the foundations of American society.
prev next

Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

Comments policy

Destructoid is an open discussion community. You don't need to "audition" to post a comment - just speak your mind. We respect differing opinions on the site, so have at it. Be smart, funny, insightful, clueless, or cute -- but back it up with substance. Keep your cool, keep it fun. We only ask that you act respectfully and above all: don't be a troll and ruin it for everyone else. Don't bring down gamers or we'll, you know, gently shoot you in the face and stuff you into a flaming mailbox. Each comment is your opportuntity to make this community awesomer. Is that even a word?

Avoiding the banhammer only requires common sense: spamming, trolling, racism, NSFW stuff, and other forms of sucking will not be tolerated. If anyone is griefing please report abuse. Be good. Don't suck!