games anime toys
Don't just stand there!
Contribute to Dtoid:
Members login
About us RSS  
   All updates PC / Windows Xbox 360 PlayStation 3 Nintendo Wii DS PSP Retro Indie




Staff Columns

Ten Golden Rules
If you disagree ... you are wrong.
Hey Ash,
Whatcha Playin

A teenage girl's video saga
The Great Retro Quiz
Test your retro brain
Games Time Forgot
Great games of the past
Bargain Bin Laden
The best game bargains
The Memory Card
Amazing moments in games
Indie Nation
Killer independent games
Friday Night Fights
Game with us online
An RPG draws near
Remembering great RPGs
You're the
man now, dog!
This fad defies explanation
Nerdcore Culture
Trends in gamer culture
Debate to the death
May the best games win
Monday mind teasers
Do you know your box art?
Art Attack Friday
The artists of gaming
Best of the week
News from our network
Weekend reading
Let it simmer


   
Nick Chester
Editor-in-Chief
Anthony Burch
Features Editor
Jim Sterling
Reviews Editor
Hamza Aziz
Community Mgr
Niero
Robot-in-Chief
Bloggiest this week
Brad Nicholson
Brad Rice
Chad Concelmo
Colette Bennett
Dale North
Justin Villasenor
Samit Sarkar
Associate editors
Conrad Zimmerman
Dyson
Jonathan Holmes
Joseph Leray
Jordan Devore
Mike Ferry
Tom Fronczak
Topher Cantler
Qais Fulton
Contributors
Adam Dork
Charlie Suh
Joe Burling
Jonathan Ross

 
Podcasts
Rev on Podtoid
Chad on Retroforce GO!
Jim on The Podcastle

Elephant Software
Thomas Lackner

Destructoid is made by
ModernMethod



Destructoid review: Final Fantasy XII: Revenant Wings
Aaron Linde11.23.2007 :35 (287 day(s) ago) 40 comments

Destructoid review: Final Fantasy XII: Revenant Wings screenshot

If you're feeling bloated and half-retarded from eating enough starch to make a crude cement mix, a strategy RPG might be the last thing on your mind. But don't let something like feeling disgusted with yourself for stealing a final glass of gravy keep you from playing games; abandoning our pastime in favor of a well-deserved food coma would awaken a terrible anger in the spirits of the long-dead pilgrims whose only hope for their progeny was mounds of oily food consumed by the bucket and damn fine portable gaming.

So, don't pass out just yet, brave reader. Hit the jump for our review of Final Fantasy XII: Revenant Wings

Final Fantasy XII: Revenant Wings (DS)
Developed by Square-Enix / Think & Feel, Inc.
Published by Square-Enix

Release Date: November 20, 2007

Square-Enix's renewed focus on Ivalice was an unexpected but not at all unpleasant change in direction for the RPG giant. Developing and evolving the fledgling universe originally depicted nearly ten years ago in Final Fantasy Tactics, Ivalice has expanded rapidly from its one-shot roots into a world with characteristics all its own. There's a neat sort of cyclical nature to it -- informed by Final Fantasy characters, themes and motifs, Ivalice itself informed and inspired the development of Final Fantasy XII, one of the most wild departures in the series to date and perhaps the most detailed glimpse into the universe we've yet seen. Expanding upon the foundations established in Final Fantasy XII, Revenant Wings is just as surprising a departure from previous standards as its forebearer while managing to capitalize on the magic of its surrounding universe.

Taking place a year after the events of XII, Revenant Wings puts players back in the shoes of Vaan, XII's protagonist and arguably the most underdeveloped character in the game. Inspired by Balthier, Vaan and fellow XII alum Penelo secure a ship of their own to pursue dreams of becoming fully-fledged sky pirates like their comrades. On their first treasure hunting expedition to retrieve the Cache of Galbados, Vaan stumbles across an airship which takes him and Penelo to the sky continent of Lemurés. They meet the denizens of the sky continent, a winged race called the Aegyl, besieged by other less-than-noble sky pirates hunting for the treasure the continent is said to hold. Vaan and crew vow to rid their land of these swarthy bastards, setting them along a quest that will unravel the mysteries of the sky continent and (of course) risk the catastrophic ruin of everything that is, y'know, good. This is Ivalice, after all.

Shirking the tactical RPG roots of the Ivalice world, Revenant Wings takes Final Fantasy XII's real-time battle system a step further, taking the form of a sort of RTS-lite gameplay model. Those of you familiar with the unfortunate failure of this year's Heroes of Mana, take heart: Square-Enix did some homework and created a fun and functional spin on the RTS genre that actually fits the platform. Using the stylus (natch), the player can control Vaan and crew as well as their summonable cannon fodder, the Espers, with a variety of conventions we've come to expect from the genre. It has its ups and downs, but we'll get to those in a minute. 

Like a certain other alternative RTS released this year, combat in Revenant Wings is remarkably simple, boiling down to what is essentially a rock-paper-scissors sort of arrangement with its controllable units. Vaan and his cohorts, designated by the game as "group leaders", as well as the Espers they summon are all dumped into one of three categories: melee, ranged, and flying. As you might expect, each is strong against one and weak against the other, but Revenant Wings  complicates things further by tossing elemental alignment and special abilities for team leads and the bigger, burlier Espers into the mix. Espers are unlocked via the Ring of Pacts, a curious spinoff of the licensing board in which weaker Espers (chocobos, bombs, et cetera) lead to stronger ones and, ultimately, the beefy Shivas, Ifrits and such that we've come to expect from the Final Fantasy series.

The control functions for the most part, but isn't without its share of shortcomings. Most of your time with Revenant Wings will be spent with the DS firmly gripped in one hand and the stylus in the other, using the digital pad to navigate the camera's perspective over the field of battle while doling out marching orders with the stylus. Team leaders and the Espers in their command are represented by icons in the HUD, and the player need only click on one to select each member of that group and send 'em off to fight, scavenge the battlefield for items and treasure, and so on. But the limits of the control scheme makes it difficult to achieve complete mastery of your units -- selection is limited to everyone, individual groups, or whoever you can grab via a drag selection tool. I can't hold a button and make precise selections -- two diablos, a chocobo and two tonberry, for example -- as units are always paired with a group leader of the same type.

Unit coordination becomes a bit difficult on some of the maps featuring tighter terrain or corridors, which Revenant Wings features fairly regularly. Often times you'll find that your units crowd and glom together, making the selection of a particular ally or enemy for a quick heal or devastating spell a bit difficult. The alternative, of course, would be to send your troops in calculated waves, but often times sheer numbers is the best offense, and tossing three or four Espers at a pack of six to twelve enemies makes for a swift slaughter.

Creating custom groups on the fly -- all flying espers, all group leaders and no espers, or all fire-elemental espers, that sort of thing -- would've been an absolute godsend in the more heated battles later in the game, and is the sort of feature that is standard in RTS for a reason. While you'll certainly get by without it, when you lose hard it likely won't be for lack of proper planning or underdeveloped stats, but rather a giant pit of fury and hell in which an inability to designate attacks or use unit types to your advantage is constant.

Frustrations aside, there's a load of crap to do in Revenant Wings, including optional monster hunts and weapon crafting on top of the plot-advancing main quest. Mission objectives remain fundamentally simple throughout the bulk of the experience (capture summon points, defeat enemy group leaders, destroy all the monsters), and for many of the game's early battles, victory is as simple as selecting the right elemental affinities and sending your horde at opposing forces to take 'em out brute force style. But at the end of the day, Wings plays pretty well and can be loads of fun, especially when the battles get interesting in the latter half of the game and the player is granted access to the optional missions. 

Revenant Wings' closest ties to its predecessor is wrapped up in the aesthetics, particularly the music. The game features plenty of familiar faces, locations and references to the events in XII, but the music was lifted outright from the game -- hardly a detraction, really. Unlike the absolutely soul-destroying dischord featured in Final Fantasy X-2, it was actually refreshing to hear songs that I was already familiar with from the original XII, if only for the way in which it carries the themes and emotional gravitas to the new title. The transition is made pretty well, so much so that it's almost surprising to learn that the music was rearranged and not just piped through crappy speakers at lower bitrates. 

But there's something of an absence in the original game's epic scope, which is to be expected in a jump to a portable platform, but I believe it to be more closely related to the art style. Ryoma Ito's character design resembles what we've seen in Final Fantasy Tactics Advance and the upcoming DS sequel Grimoire of the Rift, and though the world is certainly an expanded Ivalice as presented in FFXII, a fair bit of emotional weight is lost in the transition to these softer, cuter sprites. I wouldn't mark this as a detraction unless you play Wings expecting the same sort of epic scope as the original; there's a lot at stake in the game's story, but pre- and post-battle dialogue is often spent scrolling adorable exchanges between adorable sprites representing characters we only recently watched unravel a massive plot to destroy an entire kingdom. It's a preference thang, but might irk some gamers the same way the lighthearted shenanigans of Tactics Advance burned gamers looking for another bloodthirsty political epic like Tactics.

At the end of the day, Final Fantasy XII: Revenant Wings is a fine alternative RTS that expands upon an already fantastic universe and one of Final Fantasy's most compelling stories and casts to date. But while their grip on the gameplay end of things has improved dramatically over Heroes of Mana, Wings makes a few mistakes that keep things a little less strategy and a little more mob slaughter. Look past the shortcomings of the gameplay, however, and you'll find a limited yet worthy sequel that stands as one of the better RPG/RTS/WTF experiences on the platform.

Incidentally, did you know that it's been just over a year since I published my Balthier mancrush article? Oh, I still swoon at the very sight of that son of a bitch.

Score: 7.8

 

MORE IN OUR RTS SECTION

Latest comment by mhmdkhamis |view all 40 comments
[/b] ...





generaldane's Avatar
generaldane at 11/23/2007 00:37

1rd
madninja's Avatar
madninja at 11/23/2007 00:49

Great reveiw, got lost because of the names but then I put on my nerd hat. Weird, 7.8, oh well I hate scores any way. Thumbs up.
ShawnKelfonne's Avatar
ShawnKelfonne at 11/23/2007 00:53

I picked this up on a whim when I went to get Trauma Center earlier this week, and have been loving every minute of it so far. That has to say a lot, because I really got bored with FFXII when I got decently far into it, couldn't really connect with Vaan or Ashe, so the story didn't mean as much to me.
Newsworthy's Avatar
Newsworthy at 11/23/2007 01:21

This wasn't even on my radar! Total surprise... Might even motivate me to acquiring a DS. Nice work :)
Necros's Avatar
Necros at 11/23/2007 01:39

Good to know that it's worthwhile. Now I lost track: what was the problem with Heroes of Mana? I heard it was the best Mana game in a while (admittedly, that's not saying much).
Aaron Linde's Avatar
Aaron Linde at 11/23/2007 01:53

Necros, imagine StarCraft, then remove almost everything that makes it fun and reduce the speed by 80%. That's Heroes of Mana. :(
bluki's Avatar
bluki at 11/23/2007 02:29

oh my... i wanted dis gaem...
Crunshii's Avatar
Crunshii at 11/23/2007 02:33

ya sadly... Secret of Mana is a one time deal... everything else after it is poo poo. Same applies to Xenogears, FFT, Chrono Trigger, suikoden. Well prob not suikoden but u get d drift :/ Honestly good review, but doesnt convince me to get it cuz FF12 was more about the visuals than the story, I wasnt to thrilled with the story, so hard to make a bad story go good in a sequel.
Aaron Linde's Avatar
Aaron Linde at 11/23/2007 02:40

bluki: It's still a great game. Square-Enix is just getting a handle on the alternative RTS, that's all. Flawed, sure, but a lot of fun and worth the asking price.
Variable Gear's Avatar
Variable Gear at 11/23/2007 02:43

@ Aaron Linde:

Great review, but I has question:

How do you expect us to differentiate between a 7.5 and a 7.8? Why not go to a slightly different scale that incrementally increases or decreases by 1/2? This may not make games easier to score, but it may make it easier for the Destructoid community to accept scores in general. I would understand completely if you prefer the freedom of the scale that incrementally increases or decreases by 1/10, but can you at least see where I am coming from?

-Variable Gear-
Aaron Linde's Avatar
Aaron Linde at 11/23/2007 03:25

Dunno, seemed appropriate. Looking at our scale I felt like it fell between our 7 (Good) and 8 (Great) or maybe a bit above great, stacked up the pros and cons and felt like it leaned closer to, but not quite, an 8.

It's something to consider, though. In the mean time, I would hope an incremental score like 7.8 would be interpreted as just that: good nearing great, but falling just short. Scoring ain't an exact science but we do what we can.
Aaron Linde's Avatar
Aaron Linde at 11/23/2007 03:33

By the by, if it makes it simpler, just round up in your head. :D
Rainbowblack's Avatar
Rainbowblack at 11/23/2007 03:52

I might pick this up with that SMG gift Card (Yes I still have mine)

But I'll probably wait until after I beat Mass Effect and SMG. 3 game is too much for my plate these days
Orionsaint's Avatar
Orionsaint at 11/23/2007 04:17

2 things are certain in life and you know what they are, but a 3rd thing is certain in life and I bunched it all together. Weird hair, gay lead character, big ass swords and airships in a Final Fantasy universe. Unless you count the FF movie. Then you can exclude all of he above, but really who counts that piece a shit movie as FF hehe.
ShadowXOR's Avatar
ShadowXOR at 11/23/2007 05:05

Reverend Anthony would have given it a 2.6.
Fanatism's Avatar
Fanatism at 11/23/2007 06:57

@Crunshii
Chrono Cross was awesome, maybe not as good as trigger but still a great game.
Def JM's Avatar
Def JM at 11/23/2007 08:47

I did not Heroes of Mana, so I returned it for this, still havent played it though.
king3vbo's Avatar
king3vbo at 11/23/2007 10:33

good review, Im really liking this game, despite its flaws
realyst's Avatar
realyst at 11/23/2007 10:43

Aaron:

I haven't played through an FF game since FF9. I have far less time of late to sit through long console games so I rely more and more on portables.

So my question is: how horrible would it be to play this game if I haven't played FFXII? Is it still something I should invest in or, by lacking the experience of playing through it predecessor, should I skip it?
tarzanell's Avatar
tarzanell at 11/23/2007 10:54

@ realyst:

I'm in the same boat, and have little time for anything other than portables these days. If it helps, I haven't even seen as much as a screenie from FF XII, and I'm really enjoying Revenant Wings. I reckon the best way to think of it is as an "RTS lite," with a few minor flaws.

At the very least, it's a fun, deep, different game for the DS.
BFeld13's Avatar
BFeld13 at 11/23/2007 11:09

Sounds meh
realyst's Avatar
realyst at 11/23/2007 11:11

@tarzanell

cool, thanks:)
braulio09's Avatar
braulio09 at 11/23/2007 12:43

"one of the most wild departures in the series"

wildest, aaron...wildest

maybe i'm the only one to noticed but the parragraph where you explain the basic intro makes little sense and kinda changed how it happened. *backs away*

this is probably the last good game on DS this year.
Aaron Linde's Avatar
Aaron Linde at 11/23/2007 13:24

You know what rocks? That you've illustrated that a late night, a stomach packed with Thanksgiving food and simple human error led me to write a superlative without considering the syllabic count rule -- certainly not the most grievous (lol exception to the rule) error in English grammar, but an error nonetheless -- and managed to misspell "paragraph" while doing it.

Douche.
Necros's Avatar
Necros at 11/23/2007 14:02

@ braulio
Short version: Don't mess with Linde's English.
Enyne's Avatar
Enyne at 11/23/2007 14:34

Aaron, they don't teach the "syllabic count rule" in middle school, so how would braulio09 know that? Paragraph should have been on his spelling test this year tho.
grrza's Avatar
grrza at 11/23/2007 15:02

A little bit of lightheartedness is fine, but if it's anything like Tactics Advance (i.e., written by 5 year olds), then NO. Hopefully it's actually fun unlike T.A. too.
Aaron Linde's Avatar
Aaron Linde at 11/23/2007 15:13

Grrza, I'd rank it as a middle-ground between the two. It's definitely lighter than FFXII, but deals with some pretty heavy situations from time to time. The first ten hours or so of the game is pretty much "Hey awesome! We're Sky Pirates! Let's find some fucking treasure! Wheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee", etc
Vanilla Gorilla's Avatar
Vanilla Gorilla at 11/23/2007 16:05

Vaan's nuts need to drop, imo. I always kinda wished he was a lot less of a carefree street vagrant a la Aladdin. If he was so impressed by meeting Balthier and Fran, he should have matured a lot faster. One of my few gripes with XII. Sounds like it will be one of my gripes in Revenant Wings, too.

@Crunshii - Seiken Densetsu 3!
Wedge's Avatar
Wedge at 11/23/2007 17:33

So... the real question. Better or worse than Lost Magic?


Wait, what do you mean nobody played Lost Magic? =<
DanoftheDawn's Avatar
DanoftheDawn at 11/23/2007 23:31

I think it's easier if you (the reader) go off the text alone than in addition to a score, because obviously a game is inevitably what you yourself make of it. Reviews are great for information, but the flaws they observe are usually beyond this reader's mind (confirmation bias?).

Coincidentally, the terms "Ivalice" and "portable" were enough for me. It sounds awesome, for a DS game. I'm getting this in addition to Metal Gear Solid 2 & 3 for Christmas (the six-week Australian one), so my average time spent in a euphoria during the holidays should be nigh incalculable.
Enyne's Avatar
Enyne at 11/24/2007 03:29

[Aaron, they don't teach the "syllabic count rule" in middle school, so how would braulio09 know that? Paragraph should have been on his spelling test this year tho.]
DTwirler's Avatar
DTwirler at 11/24/2007 07:58

Bathier FTW
Eschatos's Avatar
Eschatos at 11/25/2007 08:58

Looks decent, but pass.
Dexter345's Avatar
Dexter345 at 11/25/2007 14:25

I've been looking for a game to get on my DS now that I'm almost done with Trials and Tribulations... Would you recommend this to somebody who, though a fan of the FF series, has not yet played FFXII?
Aaron Linde's Avatar
Aaron Linde at 11/25/2007 21:55

Dex, it's a fun game regardless of the background, but I'd definitely recommend having a pretty decent grasp on the FFXII story before playing -- Wikipedia it and you should be all set. That being said, argh dude play FFXII, it's fucking brilliant. :O
braulio09's Avatar
braulio09 at 11/25/2007 22:41

@ aaron

i'm gonna go ahead and pull the "english isn't my native language" card

[insert cool msn smiley i cant be bothered to find and post]
Fading_Star's Avatar
Fading_Star at 11/26/2007 05:40

Great job Aaron. I need to finish playing Final Fantasy XII.

You must be logged in to post a comment. Click here to login or create a user account now.

RELATED ARTICLES

Kefka and Sephiroth in Dissidia: Here they are, fap-cannon GO!
38 comments

Yuffie to join the cast of Avenue Q
30 comments

Square-Enix talks the future of Final Fantasy (hint: it may go on forever)
25 comments

Final Fantasy returns in concert: two new dates announced!
21 comments

Final Fantasy XIII Agito will take A THOUSAND YEARS to release [confirmed]
12 comments


Post a new community blog
This month: FEEL THE HATRED
Game with us: Friday Night Fights
Meet Dtoiders near you

DTOID CONTEST ALERTS
Contest: Win a custom Mushroom Men bass guitar signed by Les Claypool and more!
Contest update: Congratulations to N-48, you've won the N-81!
Show your ninja skills to win a DS Lite and N+
Japanator Contest: Win tickets to New York Anime Fest!
Contest: Win some loser's Nokia N-81 Multimedia gaming phone contraption
MORE CONTEST ALERTS

GAME FIGURES & TOYS
more video game toys and collectibles

     
Codemasters delivers first Fuel screenshots, promises blizzards and sandstorms
MS offering sneak previews of movies via new 'Xbox LIVE Film Club'
The Week in Rock Band DLC: All That Remains three pack
Gritty trailer for The Life in NBA 09 The Inside brings the streets to you
Codemasters delivers first Fuel screenshots, promises blizzards and sandstorms
The Week in Rock Band DLC: All That Remains three pack
MS not cocky enough to think they can beat Nintendo this generation
Every Guitar Hero World Tour rumor is true: Sting and Tool tracks confirmed
Destructoid review: Mario Super Sluggers
 
     
Game Debate to the Death!
Bubble Bobble VS Punch-Out!!

Game Debate to the Death!
Paperboy VS Bubble Bobble

The Great Retro Olympics!: Closing ceremony
DS: I <3 Geeks gets a teaser and release window
PSP: Midnight Club: Los Angeles hits the brakes, release date pushed back