11:19 AM on 02.21.2007
|
Niero
Here's the original Dugg story from way back. This is a follow-up: In January we ran a story about the retracted Circuit City $40 off coupon that sent everybody who hadn't scored a Wii running into their stores the next morning. I was there to watch them refuse everyone that came in with the printout get rejected at unsuspecting cashiers as managers sheepishly hid behind closed doors: It was industry bullshit in its purest form.
Anyway, we urged affected customers to stick it to the man and file a complaint with the Better Business Bureau and you will die when you read Circuit City's response to Dtoid reader Parrothead Ben:
COMPANY'S RESPONSE:
February 15, 2006
Jennifer Durham
BBB Serving Central VA
701 E. Franklin St., Suite 712
Richmond, VA 23219
RE: Benjamin Hedrick
Dear Ms. Durham:
I am writing in response to your letter regarding Benjamin
Hedrick's complaint to the Better Business Bureau. Thank you for forwarding this matter to our attention. Mr. Hedrick complains
that he has unable to use a $40 coupon for his purchases.
I have reviewed the information provided. I apologize for this
situation. Unfortunately, we were unable to accept the coupon as the terms of usage had changed. (What?!!) We reserve the right to make changes to our advertisments, coupons, etc.
We regret any inconvenience Mr. Hedrick may have experienced.
Sincerely,
Marilyn Pando
Executive Assistant
Circuit City Stores, Inc
O RLY? Uh, no you don't. You don't reserve the right to make us Mastur-bait and switch. I talked to all of those guys that stood out there in line and they could have gone other places closer to their houses like Target or Best Buy but they came their to shop, and due to short supply they had to take it or leave it. (sigh) Gotta say it: SHADY BUSINESS PRACTICES! OH MY GOD THAT IS SO SHADY! SHADY! Could you imagine if these people ran car dealerships?
Luckily, we do have the right to show their snotty little letter to our few million readers so that they know better next time to trust a coupon from Circuit City. Jou' mess with one of us, jou' mess with the whole angry robot army! Digg this sh*t! BAD PRESS FTW!
[Thanks Ben]
| BBcode help |
| [b]Bold text[/b] |
Bold text |
| [i]Italic text[/i] |
Italic text |
| [url]http://www.dtoid.com/[/url] |
http://www.dtoid.com |
| [url=http://www.dtoid.com/]Web link[/url] |
Web link |
|
| [img]http://www.example.com/robot.jpg[/img] |
 |
Post a comment! You can also post a photo below:
Comment with Facebook
Click connect and comment instantly!
|
Comment with Dtoid
New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds
|
54 comments | showing # 1 to 50
|
Comment with Facebook
Click connect and comment instantly!
|
Comment with Dtoid
New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds
|
Comments policy
Destructoid is an open discussion community. You don't need to "audition" to post a comment - just speak your mind. We respect differing opinions on the site, so have at it. Be smart, funny, insightful, clueless, or cute -- but back it up with substance. Keep your cool, keep it fun. We only ask that you act respectfully and above all: don't be a troll and ruin it for everyone else. Don't bring down gamers or we'll, you know, gently shoot you in the face and stuff you into a flaming mailbox. Each comment is your opportuntity to make this community awesomer. Is that even a word?
Avoiding the banhammer only requires common sense: spamming, trolling, racism, NSFW stuff, and other forms of sucking will not be tolerated. If anyone is griefing please report abuse. Be good. Don't suck!
Contest:
http://www.boston.com/business/articles/2007/02/08/circuit_city_set_to_close_stores_center/
"SHADY BUSINESS PRACTICES! OH MY GOD THAT IS SO SHADY! SHADY!"
haha
So where do we petition/digg?
...Murderers?
We must digg!
Internal Investigations FTL.
External Investigations FTW.
No where on that coupon did it say to use it specifically for a Wii. It wasn't even being distributed as a coupon to use in redemption for any one product really. That's the big qualifier for it to be bait and switch. It existed as a coupon to use anytime for anything. Bait and Switch would imply that this coupon had been purposely distributed to CC customers for the intent of purchasing a specified item that particular weekend, like a Wii system. It was just a coupon, one that CC didn't even advertise having out there. It was highly (and overly) publicized thanks to some screwjob on Digg who ruined the coupon's use, but it had been used and reissued at least twice through CC and the USPS moving packet which is where the original coupon came from. Sites like Cheap Ass Gamer and Fatwallet built the use of the coupon up amongst users, but never openly advertised the coupon's distribution outside of their own forums, and never advertised it in partnership with CC.
So, again, what they did was shitty and they deserve some anal sex lovin' from a Chapter 11 attorney, but it wasn't predatory or a self-knowing bait and switch tactic. They would have had to have openly distributed that coupon to people prior to the sale advertising the coupons use to the public, but they didn't. Digg/CAG/FatWallet did.
i still go to circuit city tuesdays to get the new movies for cheap,
but they're customer service really sucks...
though i did see this one hot chick there yesterday and was talking to her, too bad she thought my niece was my daughter.....
i guess i'll be going to best buy from now on.
This isn't the first time stuff like this has happened over the internet. But companies legally can do what CC did.
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,213352,00.html
That's why I think CC thought they were being pro-active about the coupon by canceling it's use on Saturday before the Wii shipments would be sold.
Better still, if anyone noticed or not, but the coupon on the Thursday before had specifications that it couldn't be redeemed for Apple, HP, Bose, or Disney products, and then the next day, after the article got posted on Digg, the coupon was amended to where video game hardware was suddenly no longer eligible either.
They ultimately realized they'd have to cancel the coupon outright when the other coupon from the day prior was still so widely available since it was a lousy PDF/JPG printout.
The local CC next to me is a shithole. Looks pretty on the outside, but then you realize that anyone working in the media departments (DVD/Music/Games) doesn't know the fucking alphabet when you start finding box sets of Lost mixed in with Golden Girls Season 2. And MASH is sitting right next to Cheers. Need Monk Season 2? It's sitting next copies of Talladega Nights and Adrian Lyne's version of Lolita.
Or the Urotsukidoji DVD's are found in the Disney section.
Yeah, they are. Good call there CC. Cartoons is cartoons, yep. Bambi = Tentacle Rape.
I complained to management about it when I spent 20 minutes looking for MST3K DVDs and gave up. I told the manager that I'd just be better off going next door to Best Buy if they don't want to bother alphabetizing their DVD's. BB seems perfectly capable of doing it on their own without customers telling them to do so.
5' x 20' Banners with "Mastur-Bait 'n Switch Headquarters" placed at every CC we can find would be a cause I would donate $5 for.
I was going to use this bad boy to get a digital camera, and was quite displeased. Fuck CC indeed, Niero!
I wish they had Circuit Cities in Canada so that I could not go to them.
You are welcome to come to the states and not go to ours!
Now I know that companies are not responsible for misprints in ads but with the constant stream of misprints from Circuit City it's pretty obvious that they are just trying to get you into the store with the ad and then they tell you that the price is a "misprint", after you drive 45 min in heavy traffic to get to their store to save a few bucks.
I can understand an occasional misprint but I have never seen a company with so many misprints consistently week after week like Circuit City.
Plus you can never find anything in there, that store is like a maze. I am the customer and I can choose where to shop, and I prefer to shop in a store where things are easily found and different sections of the store clearly labeled. Their game display's are MESS too, with games just scattered all over the place, so its basically impossible to find the title you want there.
I do not like to see retail stores clearly screwing over the customer for something like this, from now on Circuit City is on my "never will shop at again" list along with Best Buy.
IANAL, but I'd love to see CC make a couple more missteps and get cockslapped by some hotshot fresh Harvard grad with a class-action behind him. I would then buy the resulting movie adaptation on DVD.. from Best Buy.
Is this not the store that also CLOSED their customer service desk on black friday so that no questions or concerns could be raised about any of the products they were selling... thats a questionable business practice in my mind as well!
Why is it that retailers in America have to go through such tactics just to drive customers into their store??? Don't they realize they are just driving more customers AWAY from their stores this way!
A person who came in with the coupon is NOT going to buy the item they came into buy if the coupon is not valid, they will likely go to another store and leave angry and will not return to CC. It's not worth it for the small chance that someone will still purchase the item they came in to purchase or that they will purchase something else while they are in the store, which is the whole point of issuing these coupons in the first place.
Yes it is very dishonest what they are doing, I do not care if it has fine print or not, fine print is also negligible to an extent because sometimes its proven to be too small to read, it has to be of a certain size or else its illegal. I also believe I read that an earlier version of the coupon DID NOT have the fine print on it as well.
If they distribute a coupon they should expect it to be used, they should not be able to revoke it just because its been overpublicized and overused, if you issue a coupon you should expect this.
I wonder why they had to close 69+ stores as well....
le lamezor
You open the Sunday paper and there's an ad for $4000 off "cars." at a dealership. You scan the disclaimer and it specifically says "no Ford cars, no Toyota" and you say hell, I'm gonna go buy that new that new $15,000 Buick that just came out, I can afford it now! Soou wake up early and stand there with everybody that has the coupon 2 hours before the dealership opens so you make sure you get one. And then the car salesman says "nope, can't use that."
You would go postal on him. The least we could do, powerless as we are, is BITCH. Either that or you're a coward that lets everyone walk all over you.
redcard - "You know, every time I read something from Destructoid, I have to wonder if I'm paying for some teenager's new game system through the ads on the site. I don't find anything valuable or informative here, just a "Hey, let's see how many times I can link in a reference to jacking off!""
I personally am proud that we of the Destructoid community offended this fucktard. Also, that is a fantastic contest idea: How many times in a link CAN one reference self pleasure?
Thirty-seven.
Circuit City and Best Buy are especially awful about coupons and promotions, though. Anyone ever buy a 14.99 DVD with a 15 dollar reward zone gift cert? Oh, I guess because the DVD is 14.99, not 15 bucks, I have to spend an additional penny to even use my gift cert, then still get hit with the tax. Just a cheap way for them to sell more pop and gum, or even extra CDs or DVDs or other crap you wouldn't have bought.
Blargh retail.
http://www.foxnews.com
There, that should fix that.
I agree with your last comment Niero, but in the case of the CC coupon, it'd been published and well known through the channels long before the Wii sale happened. Lots of people had used it on other ship dates before this particular one to this same end. The difference here is that CC did not publish the coupon as new or publicize the coupon OR encourage it's use for the Wii or any other purchase. The coupon's original purpose was for people moving needing to pick up a router or TV or some shit when they get to their new shitty rathole apt. (I realize not everyone lives the glorious apartment lifestyle I do...) What happened was one of these sites (CAG/Fatwallet) reported the coupon to the site and it started getting picked up from post offices en masse. They in turn took the coupon, scanned it and started using a digital. At some point the referring company that was paying for the coupon (All Connect?) let them put a digital version online, which is where it caught on even more. The original one that was on CC's site DID have the legalese of being able to be suspended at any time...
Fact remains, CC is full of shitty douche bags that can't spell, can't count, and think that BC on the 360 is a paid service as part of a "professional installation" from techs that think turning sharpness and contrast up to max on a TV is what makes a Hi-Def visual, HD.
"We reserve the right to make hanges to our advertisments, coupons, etc."
I admit, possibly a typo, but I smell conspiracy!
=p