Note: iOS 9 + Facebook users w/ trouble scrolling: #super sorry# we hope to fix it asap. In the meantime Chrome Mobile is a reach around
hot  /  reviews  /  videos  /  cblogs  /  qposts

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 is a videogame, so deal

12:00 PM on 11.28.2011 // Jim Sterling

You'd never have thought that a series as popular as Call of Duty would need championing like some scrappy little underdog, but if you move in the right circles you soon come to learn that Activision's shooter series is battered and dumped upon as if it's the class nerd in an entire nation full of jocks. 

Tearing a lump out of Call of Duty is as popular as mocking Justin Bieber or declaring that you despise Angry Birds, and the motivation for doing so is pretty much the same all over -- it's successful. If Call of Duty had the sales draw of, say, Psychonauts, something tells me we would have a few more people sticking up for it. Conversely if Psychonauts was the game selling millions at launch, I dare say an army of detractors would crawl out of the woodwork. 

Simply disliking Call of Duty, however, isn't the issue. Everybody is of course free to dislike whatever they so wish. It's when that dislike becomes something more -- or at least tries to be -- that we have an issue. 

Recently, John Walker of Rock, Paper, Shotgun encapsulated perfectly the sneering arrogance that has come to accompany Modern Warfare 3 criticism. For the record, I am a starry-eyed fan of RPS and I absolutely love John Walker's editorials, but when it comes to this particular game, I can't help but find his assessment the perfect example of what's wrong with the current critical stance. 

Walker calls Modern Warfare 3 an "un-game", a designation he is undoubtedly quite proud of. He complains that Modern Warfare 3 does not let him choose how to play and restricts him to tight, unyielding corridors. In his latest article, he attempts to argue that linearity isn't his problem (thus freeing him up to enjoy Half-Life without being hypocritical) but he simply confirms that it was his problem. Because honestly, Modern Warfare 3 is about as "open" as the Half-Life series. More importantly, it's as open as Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare which everybody loved before the series became too popular and needed taking down a peg or two. 

Walker exposes the real problem he has with Modern Warfare 3 when he defends his enjoyment of Half-Life, saying: "Corridor shooters have been one of gaming’s greatest genres in all its lifetime, from the joy of realising it was a possibility in mazes like Wolf 3D, to the spectacular fixed-rail rollercoaster rides of the Half-Life Episodes. Not having a choice about which direction to go in is never a problem when there’s only one direction you want to go in."

That is Walker's problem, distilled. It's not that Modern Warfare 3 does anything different from Wolfenstein 3D or Half-Life. It's that he just straight up doesn't like it. Linearity is fine when it's a game he enjoys, but if it's a game he doesn't? Well, that's an un-game. That's something especially bad. But it's not extreme enough to simply state he doesn't appreciate Modern Warfare 3's creative direction, or that he doesn't think it is fun. There is, after all, only one way in which criticism can be leveled at Infinity Ward's latest -- with extreme prejudice. 

I think this is the biggest issue with people who dislike Modern Warfare 3. It's really not enough to simply say you don't like it anymore. You have to discredit it as a videogame entirely. Calling Modern Warfare 3 an un-game is, by gaming standards, perhaps the harshest thing you could do. You are ostensibly saying it is incompatible with your professional standards as a game writer, and has no place in the life of those who enjoy videogames. You are to invalidate its existence as a gamer's product entirely, and since it's intended to be a videogame, you assert that it shouldn't exist at all. 

You are basically putting it on the same shelf as Dragon's Lair, and everybody knows there's only one game that's come close to such an honor in recent memory.

[Edit: Speaking of Dragon's Lair, some people are arguing that Walker is exactly saying that, by claiming the MW3 experience is too guided. Now, I agree that such things can be a problem -- I didn't like Homefront because it made the player a spectator, for example -- but I don't think MW3 can be accused of that. The player is called upon to act and react and be the driving force, unlike Homefront, a game where you weren't even allowed to open a single door. At least COD puts you IN the action, rather than makes the action happen in front of you.

Still, as much as I dislike Homefront, I wouldn't say it's an un-game. If a guided experience like MW3 is not a real videogame, then what the hell do we call The House of the Dead? Think about it -- if you take the ability to move away from MW3, then you have pretty much the same thing as an on-rails shooter, which I believe we would still call a videogame. This leads me to ask: is your problem with Modern Warfare 3 that it isn't a true on-rails shooter? Would you have given it more slack if it was? I don't know Walker's thoughts on House of the Dead, nor do I know anybody else's. I think they're fun if done right, and if MW3 is an on-rails shooter with player-prompted movement, so be it. It's still damn fun, and it's still a game.]

Everybody knows by now that I've dished out some pretty harsh review scores over the years. Naturally, I'm all about expressing dislike when one feels the need. However, Modern Warfare 3 apparently seems to have brought out the monster in some people. Of all the reviews I've written over the years, not one article has generated as much vicious, venomous, shocking anger as the positive review of Modern Warfare 3. You are free to read through the 500+ comments that followed, from people who again couldn't simply dislike the game -- they actively could not bear the thought of somebody else liking it. They didn't want to just express the fact that they weren't fans, they had to take their hatred to a whole new level and invalidate the game to its very core. 

The reasons for this are hypocritical to the highest degree. Some have said it's exactly the same as Modern Warfare 2 -- which is either a base lie or complete ignorance, because it's not. It re-uses assets and the engine, but almost every sequel does. It refines rather than dramatically alters, sure, but most sequels do. There is no extreme level of rehashing going in Modern Warfare 3, not by the standards of this industry. I didn't see this level of abuse when we gave glowing scores to the recent Halo games, for example. 

And to the idea that it's not a videogame because you think it's too restricting? Surely we should also invalidate the existence of, say, every single point-and-click adventure game in the world. By the standards put forth, they're un-games as well. Surely Telltale should call itself something other than a game studio, because it doesn't make games at all, right? 

No ... Telltale makes games. So does Infinity Ward. They may not be games you like, and they may not be games you think ought to be so successful, but it's excluding arrogance of the highest order to say it's not a true game. I played Modern Warfare 3, I had a lot of fun with it -- the exact same kind of fun I have had with plenty of linear shooters, Half-Life included. Because Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 is a videogame, plain and simple. To say otherwise is to be Roger Ebert, declaring that videogames aren't art because he's afraid that if he admits they are, then he'll have to deal with their existence. 

You can dress up your disregard for the series with a sense of artificial intellectualism, but Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 is a videogame. Nut up and deal with it.

Jim Sterling, Former Reviews Editor
 Follow Blog + disclosure JimSterling Tips
Destructoid reviews editor, responsible for running and maintaining the cutting edge videogame critique that people ignore because all they want to see are the scores at the end. Also a regular f... more   |   staff directory

 Setup email comments

Unsavory comments? Please report harassment, spam, and hate speech to our community fisters, and flag the user (we will ban users dishing bad karma). Can't see comments? Apps like Avast or browser extensions can cause it. You can fix it by adding * to your whitelists.

destructoid's previous coverage:
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3

View all:powered by:  MM.Elephant

Ads on destructoid may be purchased from:

Please contact Crave Online, thanks!

Cblogs of 11/29/15 + Scott Pilgrim You Nefarious Swine!

Sexism in video games culture: social science says it’s real

How YOU can save DOAX3 (with diagrams)

Recap: Metal Gear Solid 2

Backward Compatibility Is More Important Than Ever (Maybe)

My beef with Sony

It's beginning to look a lot like censorship.

Solar Pony Django's Review on: Animal Crossing Amiibo Festival

Indivisible exposes why forced diversity and its proponents keep failing

Steam Controller Review

 Add your impressions

Status updates from C-bloggers

extatix avatarextatix
It's the best time of the year again! Finally we get to listen to Wham and Chris Rea over and over again!
MeanderBot avatarMeanderBot
The Unofficial Destructoid Christmas Card has been ordered. If you claimed one, you should probably PM me your address now.
SeymourDuncan17 avatarSeymourDuncan17
Started playing Wonderful 101 and it's good, but pretty overwhelming. Think I'll put it down for now. Also sad that there is no penis formation. [img][/img]
Terry 309 avatarTerry 309
What the hell happened to Arcade racing games?
EdgyDude avatarEdgyDude
Red from Transistor has joined Indivisible! many thanks to Supergiant Games for their support to this game.
JBroXNari99 avatarJBroXNari99
Does anyone know if Advent of Indies is happening this year? I looked it up today and didn't find any updates on their Twitter since January.
FlanxLycanth avatarFlanxLycanth
I brought that cake I made into work and it disappeared fast. Maybe if I lose my job I can just make a living selling cakes on the end of my street.
James Internet Ego avatarJames Internet Ego
My review-in-progress of Just Cause 3: Explosions - good. Grappling hook - good. Flying - good. Driving - an abomination. 8/10.
SirDavies avatarSirDavies
Well, ugh, this is awkward. A year ago I wrote a cblog about cool indie games coming in 2015, and not a single one of them has been released :/
SeymourDuncan17 avatarSeymourDuncan17
I was happy to have never spoiled myself the final boss of Splatoon's campaign. That was one of the best boss fights ever and I absolutely love the credits track. So relaxing. [youtube][/youtube]
Niero Desu avatarNiero Desu
Today's kids will never know the struggle of putting an encyclopedia on top of an NES Max to auto-buy 99 potions before heading into Terra Cavern
CblogRecaps avatarCblogRecaps
Sometimes, on more dreary days, I make a smiley face with sliced-pickle eyes and bacon grin in my lunch-burger. It fills me up all the same, but I feel a warm sense of accomplishment, achievement and satisfaction on top of it.
Shinta avatarShinta
[youtube][/youtube] Isn't this the greatest thing ever?
Pixie The Fairy avatarPixie The Fairy
Well, my Bloggers Wanted post is up, but it timetraveled back to Sunday behind Zetta's blog or will only post two days from now otherwise. Mrgrgr.
The Dyslexic Laywer avatarThe Dyslexic Laywer
Yeah I still can't take the new Batman and Superman seriously, Batman just looks so stupid with his cowl lol.
Amna Umen avatarAmna Umen
This near final build of Nuclear Throne is going to bring back my eye twitch.
OverlordZetta avatarOverlordZetta
When I was a lad, I loved this game something fierce. [img][/img] Anyone else ever play the tie in Small Soldiers games? Maybe it's nostalgia, but I remember them being not too bad.
Torchman avatarTorchman
Finally got my surface pro 3. Holy shit I love this little guy. And Windows 10 is better than I thought.
Putting more effort into iOS game review than African American history book report. This is not what Dr. King died for. Or maybe he did, I wouldn't know because I'm not doing the book report. Wha-hey!!
Lawman avatarLawman
More info and footage on that cancelled first-person THQ Avengers game is shown. The heartache's still real.
more quickposts



Invert site colors

  Dark Theme
  Light Theme

Destructoid means family.
Living the dream, since 2006

Pssst. konami code + enter

modernmethod logo

Back to Top

We follow moms on   Facebook  and   Twitter
  Light Theme      Dark Theme
Pssst. Konami Code + Enter!
You may remix stuff our site under creative commons w/@
- Destructoid means family. Living the dream, since 2006 -